Who is this for?

Demo editor with an existing audio interface

You already record through an interface and mainly want direct control over speaker volume and your listening selection. Mackie and Behringer describe passive models for switching sources and speakers.

Songwriter recording vocals

You want to adjust headphone levels during recording or communicate with a musician. Check whether you also need a USB recording interface: Mackie and PreSonus describe different combinations of recording, headphone and talkback features.

Editor sharing two computers

You want to switch the same screens and peripherals between computers, not switch your studio speakers. StarTech describes the SV231DHU34K6 as a KVM for two HDMI screens and two computers.

What should you look for?

First decide whether you want to control audio or share screens between computers: an audio monitor controller manages your listening signal path, while the StarTech SV231DHU34K6 is designed to switch between computers.

The percentages indicate the approximate distribution of the main buying priorities when making this choice.

Priority What to check before buying Who is this important to?
Simple listening control Check your interface’s line outputs and whether source selection, mute and mono are available. If I want to adjust the volume and listening controls quickly while editing, I’m looking for a simple solution that works with my existing interface. Around 33% of consumers prioritise simple listening control.
Recording and monitoring vocals Check how many people need to listen at the same time and whether your interface already has microphone inputs and headphone controls. When I record vocals, I want to adjust headphone levels and communicate with a musician if needed. Around 25% of consumers prioritise recording and headphones.
Checking your mix on speakers Count the stereo speaker outputs you need and check whether you can adjust the levels for each pair. If I want to check my demo mix on several pairs of speakers, I need switching that suits my setup. Around 25% of consumers prioritise comparing speakers.
Sharing screens between computers Check whether you have a second computer and whether the video connections, resolution and peripherals are compatible. If I want to use the same two screens and peripherals with two computers, I’m looking for a KVM, not an audio monitor controller. Around 17% of consumers prioritise switching between computers.

Common buying mistakes

  • Assuming ‘two monitors’ means two screens

    For audio monitor controllers, ‘monitor pairs’ means speakers. A KVM switches screens between computers.

    Before you start looking, decide whether you want to control audio or switch computers between screens.

  • Assuming the Big Knob Passive has the Big Knob Studio’s features

    Mackie specifies USB recording and separate headphone outputs for the Studio, not the Big Knob Passive.

    Check the full model name and compare its features with those of your existing interface.

    If you also need recording or headphone control, check whether your existing equipment already handles these tasks.

  • Choosing outputs without counting your connections

    The models listed differ in the number of sources, speaker outputs and headphone outputs.

    Map out your current and desired signal path, then compare the connectors on the exact model.

Brands to consider

Mackie

The Big Knob Passive is designed for passive control of audio sources and speaker pairs. The Big Knob Studio offers a different combination of recording and headphone features.

  • Mackie says the Big Knob Passive has two sources, two speaker pairs, and mono, mute and dim functions.
  • According to the product specifications, the Big Knob Passive has no USB interface or headphone output. The USB and headphone features mentioned are available on the Studio.

Behringer

The STUDIO M offers a passive way to switch between sources and speakers.

  • Behringer specifies two stereo sources, two stereo speaker outputs, and mono, mute and dim functions.
  • This model controls line-level signals; the features described do not include USB recording or headphone monitoring.

PreSonus

The Monitor Station V2 is designed for setups with multiple speaker pairs and headphones for musicians.

  • PreSonus specifies three speaker pairs, four individually adjustable headphone outputs and talkback.
  • Check separately how your recording interface connects; these features apply to the Monitor Station V2.

Palmer

The MONICON XL and MONICON L G2 offer different combinations of analogue routing and connections.

  • According to Palmer, the MONICON XL has three speaker outputs and two headphone outputs. For the MONICON L G2, Palmer lists features including Bluetooth and two stereo outputs.
  • Features of one model do not automatically apply to the other. Palmer describes the L G2 as suitable for active and passive operation.

StarTech.com

The SV231DHU34K6 is an option for sharing two screens between computers.

  • StarTech.com Netherlands describes switching between two computers with two HDMI screens.
  • A KVM does not control studio speaker outputs or vocal recording.

Joybuy products

Related products coming soon.

Frequently asked questions

Do two screens automatically mean you need a monitor controller?

No, the number of screens alone doesn’t mean you need a monitor controller. Audio monitor controllers manage audio and speakers, while a dual-monitor KVM is designed to share screens between computers. Having one computer with two screens does not, by itself, mean you need a KVM.

Where do you connect a passive audio monitor controller?

Place the controller in the line-level signal path between a suitable audio source, such as your audio interface, and the inputs of your monitoring equipment. First compare the connectors and input types on your devices; Behringer specifies balanced or unbalanced line inputs and outputs for the STUDIO M.

How do you maintain a monitor controller?

Follow the instructions for your chosen model. For the Big Knob models reviewed, Mackie recommends cleaning with a dry cloth.

What can you do if the controller doesn’t work properly after you buy it?

For a consumer purchase in the Netherlands, a product must meet what you can reasonably expect; report any fault to the seller. The Dutch Government explains that there is no fixed statutory warranty period of two years. For an eligible online purchase from a business, you will generally also have a 14-day cooling-off period.

What product safety rules apply to electronic devices?

According to the Dutch Business.gov.nl information portal, businesses that place electrical or electronic devices on the market or trade in them must ensure that their products comply with the relevant European rules. The rules that apply depend on the device.