Who is this choice relevant to?

Digitising cassette tapes

You want to transfer a stereo tape using suitable line connections, then assess the noise reduction. The Audacity Manual discusses using the source’s line, tape or record output; Focusrite User Guides describe the line inputs on the Scarlett 2i2 4th Gen.

Listening together

You both want to listen through headphones at the same time, with each of you able to set your own volume. The Solid State Logic manual describes two independent headphone outputs with separate volume controls on the SSL 2+ MKII.

Reviewing an existing recording

You already have the audio file on your computer and want to check whether noise reduction has also affected sounds you want to keep. The Audacity Manual describes previewing the effect and listening to the residual audio: the sound removed during processing.

Which buying considerations deserve attention?

Consideration What should you check? Who is this important for?
Recording a stereo signal Check the deck’s left and right outputs, two suitable line inputs and the cables you’ll need. The Audacity Manual recommends using a line, tape or record output. If I want to transfer a cassette in stereo, I need to connect the left and right channels to suitable inputs. Around 36% of consumers prioritise stereo transfers.
Listening together Check how many headphone outputs there are and whether both listeners can adjust their volume independently; the SSL 2+ MKII manual specifies two independent outputs with separate controls. If we’re listening together, I want to set my own headphone volume without changing the other person’s. Around 29% of consumers prioritise listening at the same time.
Assessing noise reduction Check that you can listen to the software playback; the Audacity Manual also describes previewing the effect and listening to the removed residual audio. If the file is already on my computer, I want to hear what the processing removes and whether it also removes sounds I want to keep. Around 21% of consumers prioritise being able to check the processing.
Connecting to a computer Compare the operating system, available USB connection and any driver or power requirements with the manual for your chosen model. If I want to use the interface with a shared computer, I want to know in advance whether the connection and installation are suitable. Around 14% of consumers prioritise compatibility with their computer.

Which connection and listening mistakes can you avoid?

  • Mistaking direct monitoring for the processed result

    Direct monitoring routes the input signal to the headphone output without passing it through the computer’s processing. So you won’t automatically hear what noise reduction does to the software playback.

    Assess the processing by playing back or previewing the audio in the software. Use direct input monitoring only to check the incoming signal.

  • Mistaking two headphone sockets for two independent volume controls

    Audient lists two headphone sockets on the iD4 MKII; Solid State Logic specifies two independent outputs with separate volume controls for the SSL 2+ MKII. So the number of sockets alone doesn’t tell you whether both listeners can adjust their volume separately.

    Check the number of sockets, the volume controls and the audio routing you need separately. If a setup doesn’t offer the independent control you want, you may need additional listening equipment.

  • Connecting a stereo deck to an unsuitable input

    A cassette deck’s outputs and an interface’s inputs don’t necessarily use the same connectors. A line-level signal is also different from a standard microphone input.

    Before you buy, check the deck’s left and right outputs and the two line inputs you plan to use. Find out which cables or adaptors you’ll need for those connections.

    You may need suitable cables or adaptors for the deck output and interface inputs you choose.

Which brands and models are worth considering?

Focusrite

The Scarlett 2i2 4th Gen suits a stereo transfer with one listener; the Scarlett 4i4 4th Gen is worth considering if you also need to keep extra line sources connected.

  • Focusrite User Guides describe two line inputs and one headphone output on the 2i2; Focusrite lists two extra line inputs for the 4i4 4th Gen.
  • These connection features alone don’t tell you how effectively tape hiss will be reduced.

Solid State Logic

The SSL 2+ MKII is worth considering if two people want to listen at the same time and each needs to control their own headphone volume.

  • The Solid State Logic manual describes two independent headphone outputs with separate controls and two switchable mic/line inputs.
  • The Legacy 4K sound switch can affect what you hear when comparing audio; keep the settings consistent when assessing processing.

MOTU

The M2 combines two inputs with visible level meters; the M4 is worth considering if you also want to connect extra line sources.

  • MOTU lists two mic/line combo inputs and meters on the M2; for the M4, MOTU lists two extra line inputs.
  • The listed specifications state that both the M2 and M4 have one physical headphone output. Meters don’t prove that tape hiss reduction will sound better.

Audient

The iD4 MKII may be worth looking into if you want two headphone sockets and recording stereo from a deck isn’t your main priority.

  • Audient lists two headphone sockets on the iD4 MKII.
  • Audient specifies one microphone preamp and one instrument input. Don’t assume this combination provides two equivalent line inputs for a stereo transfer; two sockets also don’t prove that each has its own volume control.

Joybuy products

Related products coming soon.

Frequently asked questions

Do I need to buy a new audio interface if the cassette has already been digitised?

Not necessarily for noise reduction itself: you can use a noise profile in Audacity and preview the processed result. An interface is mainly useful if you want a particular headphone setup or still need to record an analogue source.

How do I connect a cassette deck for a new transfer?

Where possible, connect the deck’s line, tape or record output to suitable line inputs, and check which cable you need for the left and right channels. The Audacity Manual warns against connecting a line-level signal like this to a standard computer microphone input.

How can I check whether noise reduction is removing too much sound?

Create a noise profile and listen to the preview before applying the effect. The Audacity Manual also describes a residual audio playback option, which lets you hear what is being removed; if the noise varies or is very loud, you may not get a satisfactory result.

What should I look for if two people want to listen at the same time?

Check whether the interface has two headphone outputs and whether both listeners can adjust their volume independently. The Solid State Logic manual lists these independent outputs and volume controls for the SSL 2+ MKII.

What should I check before digitising a cassette again?

Check the cassette deck’s playback head and follow the manufacturer’s cleaning instructions. The Audacity Manual warns that deposits can weaken high frequencies and cause more noise.