Who is this choice relevant to?

Editor evening out existing recordings

You’re mainly comparing recordings you’ve already made and want to know whether software will do the job before buying new hardware.

Creator recording takes regularly

You regularly record new vocals or instruments and want to set and monitor input levels quickly.

Creator working with multiple live sources

You need more control during recording or separate listening positions, and are weighing up a larger console against a compact interface.

Which questions should guide your choice?

Finishing existing files

Choose this if: you don’t need to make new analogue microphone or instrument recordings and can assess your files in software.

Trade-off: software editing won’t give you additional recording connections or physical level meters.

Manual level monitoring

Choose this if: you’re making new recordings and want to set and monitor the input level yourself; PreSonus lists meters and a mix control for the Studio 24c.

Trade-off: you set the recording gain yourself; the meter won’t automatically even out the loudness of files afterwards.

Auto Gain for new takes

Choose this if: you record regularly and want to spend less time setting input gain manually; Focusrite lists Auto Gain and Clip Safe for the Scarlett 2i2 4th Gen, while Audient lists Smartgain for the EVO 4.

Trade-off: these features adjust the input level during recording, not the final loudness of different files.

Controlling multiple live sources

Choose this if: you want to control multiple sources during live recording or need separate listening positions; RØDE lists physical and virtual faders and two headphone outputs for the RØDECaster Duo.

Trade-off: these extra controls aren’t needed just to even out the loudness of recordings you’ve already made.

Consideration What to look for when buying Who is this important to?
Evening out existing files Check whether your software supports loudness normalisation in LUFS and which target value suits your publishing needs. The Audacity Manual explains loudness normalisation; Audacity Support distinguishes it from peak normalisation. If I’m mainly comparing recordings I’ve already made, I want to even out their perceived loudness in software before buying hardware. Around 36% of consumers prioritise evening out existing files.
Setting up new recordings Compare the gain control, any Auto Gain or Smartgain features, level meters and the number of suitable microphone inputs on the exact model; manufacturers describe these features for each model. If I regularly record new takes, I want to be able to set and check the input level quickly. Around 29% of consumers prioritise recording new takes regularly.
Controls at a sit-stand desk Check the position of the connections and controls, and whether plugs and cables have enough clearance at both desk heights. If my desk changes height, I want the controls to remain within reach and to prevent cables from becoming taut. Around 21% of consumers prioritise having desk controls within easy reach.
Multiple live sources and listening positions Count the number of microphone and other inputs you need to use at the same time separately, and check how many headphone outputs you need. If I control multiple sources at once or need separate listening positions, I want to choose connections that suit my setup. Around 14% of consumers prioritise controlling multiple live sources.

Pitfalls when buying for recording levels

  • Buying an interface solely to even out existing files

    Input gain works during recording; loudness normalisation is applied to the audio file. So a new interface won’t change recordings you’ve already made.

    First, try the loudness feature in your audio software. Then decide whether you need extra recording or monitoring connections.

  • Assuming a peak meter or Auto Gain guarantees consistent final loudness

    Peak level and perceived loudness aren’t the same. Auto Gain sets the input level for new recordings; it doesn’t process the finished files.

    Check recording peaks during the session and assess the loudness of finished files separately.

  • Confusing the total number of inputs with the number of microphone inputs

    Yamaha lists one microphone preamp for the UR12MK3, as well as a separate instrument input; these don’t count as two microphone preamps.

    Count microphone, line and instrument inputs separately for your setup.

Relevant brands to consider

Focusrite

The Scarlett 2i2 4th Gen is worth considering if you’re looking at automatic gain settings for regular new recordings.

  • Focusrite documents Auto Gain and Clip Safe for this model.
  • These recording features won’t automatically even out the loudness of finished files.

Audient

The compact EVO 4 is an option if you want to use Smartgain on two inputs when making new recordings.

  • Audient lists two microphone preamps and automatic gain adjustment.
  • Smartgain doesn’t replace loudness normalisation for existing files.

PreSonus

The Studio 24c suits anyone who values manual level monitoring and a physical mix control.

  • PreSonus lists two microphone, line or instrument inputs, input and output meters, and a mix knob.
  • These features don’t mean the device can normalise files afterwards.

Yamaha

The UR12MK3 is a compact option if direct monitoring and loopback suit your setup.

  • Yamaha lists one microphone/line input and one separate instrument input.
  • Direct monitoring lets you hear the input signal, not necessarily the processed version.

RØDE

The RØDECaster Duo is worth considering if you need live controls, two headphone outputs or standalone recording.

  • RØDE lists two combo inputs, physical and virtual faders, and recording to microSD, USB storage or a computer.
  • The extra controls don’t remove the need to process your files to achieve your chosen loudness target.

Joybuy products for your recording needs

Related products coming soon.

Frequently asked questions

Does Auto Gain make old recordings equally loud?

No. Auto Gain and Smartgain are features for setting input levels when making new recordings. For existing files, you can analyse and normalise perceived loudness in audio software.

Is normalising to the same peak the same as matching perceived loudness?

No. Audacity distinguishes between peak normalisation and loudness normalisation: peak normalisation doesn’t take perceived loudness into account. Choose a suitable LUFS target value for your needs rather than judging by the interface alone.

How can I avoid cable problems when my desk goes up?

Check that USB, audio and headphone cables can move freely and aren’t pulling on the device when the desk is at both its lowest and highest positions. When positioning the device, allow enough room for connected plugs too.

What costs or consumer rights should I consider after buying online in the Netherlands?

Before buying, check which software, cables and accessories are included with the exact model. For online consumer purchases, there is generally a 14-day cooling-off period after delivery, with some exceptions under ACM ConsuWijzer rules. Your statutory guarantee is separate from any manufacturer’s warranty; ACM ConsuWijzer explains that the seller is responsible for faulty goods.