Photographer with a desktop computer in the attic
Uploads photo albums from one workspace and can connect the computer via Ethernet. The main question is whether the sockets you choose provide a usable connection.
If you’re uploading your photo album from a desktop computer, a powerline kit with Ethernet may be suitable. If you’re using a laptop or phone without a network cable, the adapter in the attic will need to provide Wi-Fi. Test the connection using the sockets you plan to use and compare the upload speed with a measurement taken by the router. TP-Link makes clear that the stated powerline speed doesn’t guarantee actual throughput, and powerline won’t increase the upload speed of your internet package.
Uploads photo albums from one workspace and can connect the computer via Ethernet. The main question is whether the sockets you choose provide a usable connection.
Wants to upload from the attic without connecting a network cable to their laptop. Choose a kit whose attic adapter provides Wi-Fi.
Should check that the adapter matches the existing product family and standard before adding to the network. For example, devolo says Magic products aren’t compatible with dLAN or other HomePlug AV adapters.
Suitable if: you mainly upload from a desktop computer with a network connection and don’t want to run a cable to the attic.
Bear in mind: an Ethernet adapter doesn’t provide a Wi-Fi access point on its own, and the connection depends on your electrical wiring.
Suitable if: you upload from a laptop, phone or tablet without an Ethernet connection.
Bear in mind: Wi-Fi on the adapter won’t fix a weak connection between the powerline adapters; expandability and mesh features depend on the product family.
Suitable if: you can install a network cable or powerline doesn’t work well enough with the attic sockets you plan to use.
Bear in mind: installing a cable takes more work. Another local Wi-Fi solution won’t increase the upload speed of your internet package either.
| What to consider | What should you check? | Who is this most relevant to? |
|---|---|---|
| Connection through the sockets | Test the adapters directly in the sockets you plan to use and compare the upload speed with a measurement taken by the router. According to TP-Link, the stated powerline speed isn’t a measure of actual throughput. | If I want to know whether the electrical route to my attic is usable, I test the sockets I’m going to use. Around 36% of consumers prioritise how well the connection works between those sockets. |
| Ethernet or Wi-Fi | Check what type of connection your upload device needs and whether the attic adapter provides Wi-Fi. Also check the number of Ethernet ports and whether it’s a complete starter kit. | A wired connection may suit a desktop computer; Wi-Fi in the attic is important if you’re using a laptop or phone without a network cable. Around 29% of consumers prioritise the connection type they need. |
| Upload speed | Measure the upload speed by the router and then in the attic. This will help you work out whether the local connection is the limiting factor, rather than relying on the adapter’s speed rating alone. | If my photo album is uploading slowly, I first want to know where the delay is coming from. Around 21% of consumers prioritise this question about upload speed. |
| Existing adapters and sockets | Compare the full model names and check the compatibility, kit contents and connections of the exact version. Also look for a pass-through socket. | If you want to add to your existing adapters or keep a socket free for use, check the product family and version. Around 14% of consumers prioritise these points. |
The stated powerline speed is a maximum for the local connection. Actual throughput also depends on your electrical wiring, while your internet connection can limit upload speeds too.
Compare upload speeds by the router and in the attic before choosing a product based on a higher speed rating.
An adapter with Ethernet doesn’t automatically provide a Wi-Fi access point for a laptop or phone.
Check whether the attic adapter provides Wi-Fi in the exact kit you’re considering.
devolo says that Magic products aren’t compatible with dLAN or other HomePlug AV adapters.
Compare the full model names and powerline standards before adding to your setup.
An incompatible addition could mean you need a different adapter or a complete kit.
The range includes powerline starter kits with Ethernet and versions with Wi-Fi. Available connections vary by model.
The Magic range includes the wired Magic 2 LAN triple starter kit and versions with Wi-Fi.
According to the manufacturer, the FRITZ!Powerline 1260 WLAN Set combines powerline, Wi-Fi and a gigabit LAN connection.
These Joybuy products are aimed at providing Wi-Fi in the attic or a wired connection for a desktop computer.
No image available
The Wi-Fi option is suitable for uploading wirelessly from the attic; check that this version works with the devices you plan to use.
No image available
The wired powerline option is suitable for uploading from a desktop computer with Ethernet. The 500 Mbit/s in the product name isn’t a measured upload speed in the attic.
For a new powerline network, you’ll need two adapters: one by the router and one in the attic. Check that the pack contains both adapters; if you’re expanding an existing setup, the extra adapter must match your current product family.
TP-Link recommends plugging the adapters directly into wall sockets, as extension leads and surge protectors can significantly weaken the powerline signal. Test the connection using the sockets you intend to use.
Compare the upload speed by the router with the speed in the attic. TP-Link warns that the stated speed isn’t the actual throughput. If the measurement by the router is slow too, check your internet connection before considering a faster powerline kit on its own.
Choose Ethernet if your upload device will be connected by cable in the attic. If you want to work wirelessly, choose a kit with Wi-Fi on the receiving adapter. Check the exact version of the kit, as Ethernet doesn’t automatically mean the adapter also provides Wi-Fi.
It depends on the product family and standard. devolo says that Magic adapters aren’t compatible with dLAN or other HomePlug AV adapters, so compare the full model names before choosing an addition.