Your choice mainly depends on the directional controls your puzzle game requires and which you find comfortable to use. A joystick isn’t automatically a better option than separate directional buttons. Next, check the exact combination of controller, platform and game, and consider whether the casing and playing angle suit your set-up. Specifications don’t automatically tell you how comfortable something will feel during long sessions.
Who is this buying guide for?
Players who enjoy long puzzle sessions
You want to enter directions repeatedly and have enough room to position your hands and change your posture. Arboportaal recommends a relaxed posture when working at a screen, but this is not a comfort assessment of arcade controllers during gaming.
Players using a specific platform
Perhaps you play on Switch, Windows or PlayStation and want to choose the right version. Also check whether the specific game supports the controls; system compatibility alone doesn’t tell you this. 8BitDo and HORI product information lists separate versions for different platforms.
Players looking for classic controls
Your choice mainly comes down to a joystick, separate directional buttons or a mechanically adjustable restrictor. Manufacturers such as 8BitDo and Ultimarc describe different control options; the right choice depends on the game and your preference.
What should you look for when choosing?
First, decide which directional controls suit the game. Then check platform and game support, and measure the space you’ll need for the controller, your hands and movement.
| What to consider |
What to check |
Who is this important for? |
| Hand space and posture |
Measure the space for the controller and your hands; check whether you can keep your wrists relaxed and change your posture. |
If I play for a long time, I want to position my hands without being locked into one posture. Around 31% of consumers make extended use their main priority. |
| Platform and game |
Check the exact model version, system version and connection type, and whether the game accepts the input you want to use. |
I want to play a specific puzzle game on my chosen system, not just have a controller described as compatible with that system. Around 31% of consumers prioritise compatibility. |
| Directional controls |
Check whether the game uses four or eight directions and whether you want a joystick, separate buttons or a mechanical restrictor. A D-pad mode is not the same as a mechanical four-way restrictor. |
My first consideration is how I want to enter directions and what the game requires. Around 25% of consumers prioritise the type of controls. |
| Playing and storage space |
Compare the overall dimensions with your table, leaving room for your hands, the cable and movement. |
If my table or storage space is limited, I want to know how much room the controller takes up. Around 13% of consumers make space their main priority. |
Common buying mistakes
-
Assuming different platform versions are the same product
Even within one brand, versions for Switch, Xbox and PlayStation can differ. For some console connections, MAYFLASH also requires a wired controller to be connected.
Before buying, compare the full product name and the instructions for your console and game.
-
Confusing a D-pad mode with a mechanical four-way joystick
The MAYFLASH F300 offers a switchable input mode, while the Ultimarc Mag-Stik Plus has a mechanically switchable restrictor. These are different features.
If you need a mechanical four-way restrictor, check that the product specifically has one and confirm whether you’re buying a complete controller or just a component.
-
Assuming compact or adjustable means comfortable
Dimensions and adjustable feet describe the set-up, but they don’t prove how the controller will fit your hands or feel during extended use.
Check the available table space, try a relaxed hand position and change your posture while playing.
Brands to consider
8BitDo
Offers both an arcade stick with a physical joystick and a button-only controller. The separate Arcade Stick for Xbox is a different platform version.
- For the Switch and Windows models reviewed, the manufacturer describes different connection and configuration options.
- This information doesn’t automatically apply to every 8BitDo version or puzzle game; check the exact model and game.
HORI
The Fighting Stick Mini range is worth considering if you’re looking for a compact joystick. The Switch and PS5/PS4 versions are separate products.
- For the versions reviewed, HORI lists a casing measuring around 8 × 6 inches.
- A compact design doesn’t tell you whether there’s enough room for your hands. The PS5/PS4 version’s product description states that it has no touchpad.
MAYFLASH
The F300 is a wired arcade stick for players who want to use different input modes.
- MAYFLASH lists switching between D-pad and analogue stick modes, as well as support for replaceable parts.
- According to the manufacturer, some consoles require a wired controller to be connected; compatibility may also depend on firmware.
Qanba
The Drone 2 is a joystick option that Qanba describes as compatible with PS5, PS4 and PC.
- Qanba lists a platform switch and a touchpad.
- Qanba’s claim that the larger casing is better suited to larger hands comes from the manufacturer; it isn’t based on an independent comfort assessment.
Ultimarc
The Mag-Stik Plus is worth considering if you’re building your own arcade control panel and want to switch mechanically between four-way and eight-way operation.
- According to Ultimarc, you can switch the restrictor from the top of the panel.
- This is a joystick component, not a complete controller you can plug in and use straight away; mounting and the other electronics need to be arranged separately.
Joybuy products
Related products coming soon.
Frequently asked questions
Will every arcade stick work with my puzzle game?
No. Support for a system doesn’t confirm that a controller will also work with a specific game. Compare the game’s directions and buttons with the exact model version, input mode and system version. Sony recommends checking with the manufacturer whether a controller works with specific titles on PS5.
How do I connect the 8BitDo Arcade Controller to Switch or Windows?
For Windows, the 8BitDo manual describes X mode using a USB cable or 2.4GHz adapter. For Switch, it describes S mode via Bluetooth or USB. For a wired connection on Switch, enable the Pro Controller wired communication setting.
Should I buy an ergonomic controller for long gaming sessions?
A label such as ‘ergonomic’ doesn’t in itself prove that extended use will prevent discomfort. Try a set-up that lets you keep your hands and wrists relaxed, and change your posture. Arboportaal’s advice is about working at a screen, not a test of gaming controllers.
What are my rights in the Netherlands if a controller I bought online is faulty?
When you buy remotely from a business, you’ll often have a 14-day cooling-off period; check the applicable exceptions and terms of sale. If a product is faulty, the seller is your point of contact for the statutory guarantee. According to the Dutch government, there is no fixed statutory guarantee period in the Netherlands that applies to all products.