Who are these options for?

Player with limited desk space

Looking for a joystick for 2D fighting games that’s easy to put away between sessions. HORI gives the Fighting Stick Mini’s dimensions as approximately 8 × 6 inches; compare these with the space you need for your hands and cable too.

Player with a dedicated console

Wants to check that the exact controller works with their console and game version, and whether a converter is needed. In 2020, Sony Interactive Entertainment advised checking the compatibility of the specific accessory.

Player who shares their room

Wants to take the noise from the controls into account. QANBA describes components in the Q8 as ‘Silent’, but this label isn’t based on an independent noise measurement.

What should you look for when choosing?

What to consider What should you check? Who is this important for?
Playing and storage space Measure the space available on your desk and check the dimensions of the casing, as well as the room needed for the cable. If my desk is small, I want to know whether the stick will fit while I’m playing and can be put away afterwards. Around 31% of consumers put available playing and storage space first.
Platform and game Check the exact model, the list of supported platforms, your game version and any firmware or converter requirements. If I play on a dedicated console or PC, I want to know before buying whether my specific model and game version are supported. Platform compatibility comes first for around 25% of consumers.
Noise for people you live with Check which joystick and buttons are included in the version you’re buying; if necessary, ask for a demonstration or relevant measurement data. In a shared room, I want to take the noise from the controls into account without relying solely on a product label. Noise is the top purchase priority for around 25% of consumers.
Joystick or all-button Choose the type of directional control you want to use, then check platform support. If I prefer using a lever or want to learn to use directional buttons, I want to choose what suits my own preference. Around 19% of consumers put the type of controls first.

Common mistakes

  • Assuming a PS4 stick works with every PS5 game

    Compatibility with a PS4 model doesn’t automatically mean the stick works with every game on PS5. In 2020, Sony Interactive Entertainment advised checking the compatibility of the specific accessory.

    Before buying, check the exact model, game version, any converter and the required firmware. For the MAYFLASH F300, MAYFLASH describes a PS5 setup using MagicBoots-S5 and compatible firmware.

    The PS5 setup described for the F300 may require a separate converter; check whether it’s included with the version you choose.

  • Assuming ‘Silent’ means silent in use

    QANBA uses this label for components in the Q8, but it doesn’t indicate an independently measured noise level.

    Check which components are included in the exact version, and ask for a demonstration or comparable measurement data if noise is a deciding factor.

  • Measuring only the casing

    The stated dimensions don’t tell you how much space your hands and cable will take up while you play.

    Measure the space available for playing and storage, then compare it with the dimensions of the exact version.

Brands to consider

HORI

The Fighting Stick Mini is designed for anyone who wants a compact joystick stick that’s easy to put away. The Fighting Stick α is worth considering if you want access to components for maintenance or customisation.

  • HORI gives the Mini’s dimensions as approximately 8 × 6 inches. According to HORI, the α opens up to give you access to its components.
  • According to HORI, the Mini doesn’t have a touchpad. The α’s features don’t automatically apply to the Mini.

8BitDo

The range includes a joystick stick and a separate all-button controller. Check which controls and platforms are supported for each model.

  • 8BitDo lists Bluetooth, 2.4 GHz and USB-C for the Arcade Stick, and a thickness of 22 mm for the Arcade Controller.
  • The platform lists provided mention Switch and Windows, but not PS5.

MAYFLASH

The F300 is worth considering if you want to be able to replace components and check compatibility with your platform in advance.

  • MAYFLASH lists compatibility with replacement Sanwa components.
  • For PS5 use, MAYFLASH describes a MagicBoots-S5 converter and a suitable firmware update; check the requirements for the exact version.

QANBA

The Q8 may appeal to PC players specifically looking for joystick and button components that QANBA describes as ‘Silent’.

  • QANBA lists a Gravity ‘Silent’ joystick and ‘Silent’ buttons for the Q8.
  • ‘Silent’ is a manufacturer’s label, not an independent noise measurement. The product page referred to lists PC, not PS5.

Razer

The Kitsune is an all-button alternative for anyone who doesn’t need a physical joystick and is looking for a version for PS5 and PC.

  • Razer describes the Kitsune as portable and lists a detachable USB-C cable.
  • Its directional controls differ from those of a stick with a joystick; claims about input speed aren’t an independently verified performance advantage.

Joybuy products

Related products coming soon.

Frequently asked questions

Will every PS4 arcade stick work with my PS5 fighting game?

No. Don’t assume it will just because it’s labelled PS4. In 2020, Sony Interactive Entertainment warned that not every officially licensed or other accessory works with every PS5 title. Check the exact model and game version with the manufacturer. For the MAYFLASH F300, MAYFLASH describes a separate converter and firmware setup.

How do I use a MAYFLASH F300 with a PS5?

MAYFLASH describes using the F300 with a MagicBoots-S5 after a suitable firmware update. The converter instructions explain how to connect it to a compatible stick and select PS5 mode; check the instructions for your version of the F300 before buying.

What can I do if the buttons are faulty, and do I need an extended warranty?

If you buy as a consumer in the Netherlands, the product must meet the standards you’re entitled to expect, according to the Government of the Netherlands; there’s no fixed statutory warranty period in the Netherlands. Report any fault to the seller. An extended warranty is mainly worth considering if its terms give you more than your existing rights.

Do I always have 14 days to change my mind when buying online in the Netherlands?

According to the Government of the Netherlands, in many cases you have 14 days to change your mind when buying remotely from a business. The same guidance says that purchases from private sellers aren’t covered by the distance-selling rules. Check the applicable exceptions and the seller’s terms too.