Who is this buying guide for?

Players who share a bedroom in the evenings

You want arcade-style controls while keeping the noise from both the joystick and repeated button presses to a minimum. Qanba describes specific Q8 components as quiet; the Dutch government advises people affected by noise to agree on arrangements together first.

Shoot-'em-up players using multiple systems

You want to check first that the stick, console and inputs are compatible. Mayflash and 8BitDo describe a range of platform and connection options, so check the requirements for your version and game.

Players short on storage space

You want to be able to put the controller away after playing, so check its dimensions and connection type. Mayflash, 8BitDo and Qanba publish product specifications that you can compare with the space where you plan to use or store the stick.

What should you look for when choosing?

First, check that the stick and its inputs work with your platform and game. Then consider noise and control style, before comparing the space you have for playing and storage.

What to consider What to look for when buying Who is this important for?
Operating noise Check whether the exact version describes both the joystick and action buttons as quiet. A quiet rating for individual components doesn’t guarantee inaudible use. If I play while someone else is resting, I want to keep the noise from both the joystick and buttons down. Around 33% of consumers say noise is their top priority.
Game and platform compatibility Check the required inputs and whether an adapter or connected controller is needed. 8BitDo says its Arcade Stick doesn’t work with PlayStation or Xbox; Mayflash lists additional connection requirements for some console combinations. I want the stick to work with my system and the inputs required by my shoot-'em-up, without unexpected connection steps. Around 27% of consumers put compatibility first.
Space and storage Compare the stated dimensions with your playing and storage space. Also allow for cables, a receiver or a connected controller, if required. If my playing space is limited, I want to be able to put the stick away easily after use. Around 20% of consumers choose space as their main consideration.
Directional controls Choose between a joystick and separate directional buttons. Then check that the layout suits the game’s inputs and that any replacement parts are compatible. I want to use a joystick or enter directions using separate buttons, and possibly change the parts later. Around 20% of consumers say controls are their first consideration when choosing.

Buying pitfalls

  • Taking ‘silent’ to mean the whole stick is inaudible

    Qanba describes a joystick and buttons on one Q8 version as silent. This description applies to the components mentioned and doesn’t tell you how loud the complete stick will be in your bedroom.

    Check the exact version and, if needed, agree with your roommate on when you’ll play.

  • Seeing a console on a compatibility list and missing the connection requirements

    For certain consoles, Mayflash requires a connected controller or an additional adapter. The exact requirements vary by model and platform.

    Read the instructions for the full model number and check the requirements for your console and game.

    You may need an additional adapter or a compatible connected controller; also bear in mind the extra connection required while playing.

  • Assuming wireless means quiet

    According to 8BitDo, the Arcade Stick offers Bluetooth, 2.4 GHz and USB-C. The connection type alone tells you nothing about the mechanical noise of the joystick and buttons.

    Consider your preferred connection and operating noise as separate factors.

Brands to compare

Qanba

The Q8 Silent is worth looking into if you mainly play on PC and want to reduce noise from the controls. The Drone 2 is a separate option for PS5, PS4 and PC.

  • For one Q8 version, Qanba describes a Gravity Silent joystick and KS Silent buttons.
  • This description isn’t a measure of noise in a bedroom and doesn’t automatically apply to another Q8 version or the Drone 2.

Mayflash

The F300 has a joystick and selectable input modes; the F500 FLAT has a joystick-free layout for players who prefer directional buttons.

  • Mayflash lists XInput and DInput support on PC and adjustable turbo functions for the F300.
  • A connected controller or adapter may be needed to use it with certain consoles. For the F500 FLAT, check the requirements for your console and version.

8BitDo

The Arcade Stick is worth comparing if you play on Switch or Windows and want a choice of wired and wireless connections.

  • According to 8BitDo, the model offers Bluetooth, 2.4 GHz and USB-C, with configurable buttons.
  • 8BitDo states in its FAQ that this model doesn’t work with PlayStation or Xbox. A wireless connection says nothing about mechanical button noise.

Nacon

The PlayStation Daija is a larger option to compare if you want PS5, PS4 and PC support, as well as interchangeable components.

  • Nacon lists a Sanwa joystick and buttons, along with a 3 m cable included in the box.
  • Nacon warns that games requiring two joysticks don’t always work with the Daija. The listed components don’t prove that it operates quietly.

Arcade sticks at Joybuy

Related products coming soon.

Frequently asked questions

Will every arcade stick work with my shoot-'em-up?

No. Check both the platform and the inputs the game requires. Nacon says games that require two joysticks don’t always work with the Daija.

How do I connect the 8BitDo Arcade Stick to Windows using a cable?

According to the manual, set the mode switch to X and connect the stick via USB-C. Also check that the version and system requirements are compatible with your Windows installation.

Can I make a Mayflash F300 quieter later by replacing its components?

Mayflash describes the F300 as customisable with Sanwa components, but check that each part is compatible. The fact that it can be customised doesn’t prove that a replacement will make the controls quiet enough in your room.

What rights do I have in the Netherlands if an arcade stick I bought online is faulty or doesn’t fit?

If a product is faulty, you’re entitled to a statutory guarantee and should contact the seller; according to the Dutch government, there is no fixed statutory end date for this guarantee in the Netherlands. For a standard online purchase, you generally have a 14-day cooling-off period starting the day after delivery. Business.gov.nl explains the cooling-off period; check the applicable terms and exceptions, for example for custom-made products.

What can I do if the noise from my arcade stick bothers my roommate?

The Dutch government advises people affected by noise to agree on arrangements together first. For example, discuss when you’ll play, and bear in mind that a version described as quiet won’t necessarily be inaudible.