First, check that the exact controller model works with your platform and shoot-'em-up. Then choose between a physical joystick and separate directional buttons. For gaming in the dark, check what actually lights up: 8BitDo says that a visual layout that changes is not the same as all the action buttons being illuminated, while Brook lists RGB effects without guaranteeing illuminated buttons. MAYFLASH warns that the F700 Elite is not intended for shooting games on PS5.
Who is this for?
Players on a specific console
You want to know whether the exact controller model works with both your console and the shoot-'em-up you play. This is especially important on PS5: MAYFLASH warns that the F700 Elite and F700 FLAT Elite are not intended for shooting games on PS5.
Players in a dark room
You want to find the buttons without constantly looking down at the controller. Check whether the lights illuminate the action buttons themselves and whether the layout is easy for you to recognise; RGB effects don't automatically mean illuminated buttons.
Players looking for a different way to control direction
You're comparing the movement of a physical joystick with entering directions using separate buttons. Also think about how much space you have and how you want to use the controller while playing.
What should you consider when choosing?
First, check the combination of controller, platform and game. Then compare the controls, visibility and practical connections with your gaming setup.
| What to consider |
What should you check? |
Who is this important for? |
| Platform and game |
Compare the full model name with your console and game. On PS5, also check the listed game category. |
If I use one console and a specific shoot-'em-up, I want to know before buying whether that exact combination is supported. Around 33% of consumers prioritise compatibility with their platform and game. |
| Visibility in the dark |
Check which parts light up and whether the lighting is adjustable; don't rely on the RGB label alone. |
When I want to identify the buttons quickly in a dark room, I look for illumination and a clear layout. Around 27% of consumers give visibility in the dark top priority. |
| Control style |
Compare a physical joystick with separate directional buttons, and check whether you can assign the functions. |
Above all, I want to decide whether a stick or separate buttons suit the way I play. Around 27% of consumers say control style is their main consideration. |
| Space and connection |
Measure the space available and check which connection your platform supports. |
If space is limited where I play or I need a particular connection, that matters more to me than other features. Around 13% of consumers prioritise placement and connection. |
Common mistakes
-
Assuming ‘PS5 compatible’ means suitable for every PS5 shooter
MAYFLASH explicitly rules out shooting games on PS5 for both the F700 Elite and F700 FLAT Elite. So a platform listing alone doesn't tell you whether that model is suitable for your game.
Check the full model name and the specific PS5 game. PlayStation advises checking with the manufacturer that the specific accessory is compatible with the game.
-
Confusing RGB effects with illuminated action buttons
RGB effects, a visual layout that changes and separate illuminated replacement buttons are different features. Qanba lists separate power wiring for the LED button we looked at.
Check which parts actually light up, and look at the installation and power requirements before making any changes.
-
Confusing a product range with a model for a specific platform
8BitDo describes separate models with different platform support, including one model for Xbox and others for supported Switch systems and Windows.
Before choosing, compare the full product name and the platform list for the exact model.
Brands to consider
8BitDo
8BitDo makes arcade controllers with either a joystick or separate directional buttons. For specific models, the manufacturer lists support for certain Switch systems and Windows; the Xbox model is a separate product.
- According to 8BitDo, the models we looked at have assignable buttons and a visual layout that changes when switching between certain platform modes.
- This visual layout doesn't prove that all the action buttons are illuminated. Check platform support for each model.
Qanba
Qanba describes the Titan as a joystick controller for PS5, PS4 and PC. The brand also sells separate illuminated replacement buttons.
- According to Qanba, the Titan has a non-slip underside and Sanwa components.
- This doesn't mean that the Titan comes with illuminated action buttons as standard. The LED button we looked at needs separate power wiring; check that it will fit too.
MAYFLASH
MAYFLASH makes the F700 Elite joystick model and the F700 FLAT Elite model with separate directional buttons.
- The two models offer different control styles for you to compare.
- MAYFLASH explicitly warns against using either model for shooting games on PS5. This warning applies to these models and this type of use.
Brook
Brook describes the Fighter Starburst as a controller with separate directional buttons and RGB effects.
- According to Brook, the controller has five lighting modes and interchangeable switches.
- RGB effects don't prove that the action buttons themselves are illuminated or easy for you to identify in your game. Check the listed platform and game-specific support.
Products at Joybuy
Related products coming soon.
Frequently asked questions
Will every arcade stick listed for PS5 work with my PS5 shoot-'em-up?
No, you can't tell from the platform listing alone. MAYFLASH warns that the F700 Elite and F700 FLAT Elite are not intended for shooting games on PS5. PlayStation advises checking with the manufacturer that the specific accessory is compatible with the game.
Are RGB lighting and illuminated action buttons the same thing?
No. Brook lists RGB lighting effects for the Fighter Starburst, while Qanba describes a separate illuminated replacement button. As well as the button's function, that Qanba button needs separate wiring for its 5 V LED to light up.
What should I check if I want to replace the buttons?
Check the size of the mounting hole and whether the casing is suitable for replacement. For the Qanba LED button we looked at, the manufacturer specifies a 30 mm opening and separate wiring for the lighting; don't assume it will fit every controller.
What are my rights in the Netherlands if a controller I bought online is faulty?
According to the Dutch government, the seller must provide a solution if a product is faulty; statutory guarantees in the Netherlands don't have a fixed two-year term. Online purchases from a business also generally come with a 14-day cooling-off period, subject to applicable exceptions. The cooling-off period and your rights if a product is faulty are different things.