Who is this buying guide for?

Player sharing a room

You want to practise fighting games without disturbing the person you share with. Compare the noise made by both the joystick and the buttons; a label such as ‘SILENT’ isn’t an independent noise measurement. HORI uses this label for model SPF-039.

Console player who wants certainty

Your first priority is making sure it works with your console and version of the game. Check the full model name and connection requirements: the MAYFLASH F500 FLAT may need an extra connection or converter for certain consoles.

Player short on desk space

You want to know whether the controller will fit on your desk and be easy to put away after playing. According to 8BitDo, the Arcade Controller measures 301 × 201 × 22 mm; compare this with the space you have for playing and storage.

What should you look for?

First, check compatibility with your platform and game. Then choose between a stick with a joystick and a leverless layout, taking noise, space, customisation and any extra parts you may need into account.

Buying concern What should you look for? Who is this most important for?
Noise for the person you share with Check which parts the specific model has and whether its buttons or switches can be replaced. If noise needs to be kept to a minimum, ask for a measurement of the whole controller. If I share a room, I mainly want to know how much noise the joystick, buttons and contact with the desk make. Around 31% of consumers put noise first.
Works with your console, game and PC Check the exact model, console and game version, PC input mode and any connection requirements. Those most concerned about their controller not working with their console or game prioritise compatibility. Around 25% of consumers put platform compatibility at the top of their list.
Space, placement and storage Compare the dimensions, including any joystick that sticks out, and think about where you’ll put the controller while playing and when storing it. If my desk and storage space are limited, I want a controller that fits comfortably. Around 19% of consumers choose space as their main concern.
Maintenance and customisation Check whether the controller can be opened or has hot-swappable switches, and whether replacement parts are the right size and have the right connection. If you mainly want to change settings or parts, look at maintenance and customisation options. Around 13% of consumers put these first.
Parts and aftercare Check what’s included, whether you need a converter, who the seller is and what the returns policy covers. If I want a complete set and clear aftercare, I look beyond the controller itself. Around 12% of consumers give this the most attention.

Common pitfalls

  • Assuming ‘leverless’ means ‘silent’

    A controller without a joystick still has buttons and makes contact with the surface you play on. Descriptions of switches aren’t comparable noise measurements.

    Check the parts used in the specific model, and don’t assume your housemate won’t hear a thing.

  • Confusing PlayStation, Xbox or PC versions by name

    Platform support varies by model. You may also need extra connections or a converter for a particular console.

    Compare the full model name with the requirements for your console, game version and any PC input mode.

Brands to compare

HORI

Offers arcade sticks with joysticks for platforms including PlayStation and PC. The SPF-039 is labelled SILENT, but the model name alone doesn’t tell you its measured noise level.

  • HORI lists PS5, PS4 and PC as platforms for the SPF-039.
  • Don’t confuse the SPF-039 with the standard Fighting Stick α SPF-013. For PC, also check the game’s input mode: HORI says the standard Fighting Stick α supports XInput games, but not DirectInput games.

8BitDo

Offers compact leverless controllers in separate versions for different platforms.

  • 8BitDo lists hot-swappable low-profile switches for the Arcade Controller.
  • The Arcade Controller and Arcade Controller for Xbox have different listed platforms. The switches mentioned don’t prove that this controller is quieter than another model.

MAYFLASH

The F500 FLAT is a leverless controller for anyone comparing models that list support for multiple platforms.

  • MAYFLASH lists customisable buttons.
  • To use it with a PS4 or the Xbox consoles listed, MAYFLASH requires a compatible wired controller plugged into its USB port. For the PS5 option listed, you’ll need to buy a separate converter.

NACON

The Daija range has separate PlayStation and Xbox versions for players looking for a stick with a joystick.

  • For its PlayStation version, NACON lists Sanwa parts, customisable controls and an included cable.
  • These features don’t prove that the stick is quiet. Check which Daija version is right for your platform.

Qanba

Offers the Drone 2 as a stick with a joystick and sells Gravity KS buttons separately.

  • Qanba lists PS5, PS4 and PC for the Drone 2, and says the silicone parts in its Gravity KS buttons help reduce button noise.
  • This doesn’t mean the Drone 2 comes with Gravity KS buttons as standard. Check the size and space inside the controller before modifying it; the buttons tell you nothing about the noise of the whole stick.

Joybuy products

Related products coming soon.

Frequently asked questions

Will a PS4 arcade stick automatically work with the PS5 version of my fighting game?

No, don’t assume it will just because PS4 is listed. PlayStation says that officially licensed specialist peripherals are supported on PS5 with PS5 games and supported PS4 games. Also check the exact stick and game; MAYFLASH lists a separate converter as the PS5 option for the F500 FLAT.

What do I need to connect to use a MAYFLASH F500 FLAT with a console?

According to MAYFLASH, using it with a PS4 or the Xbox consoles listed requires a compatible wired controller plugged into the F500 FLAT’s USB port. For the PS5 option described by MAYFLASH, you’ll need to buy a separate converter; check the instructions for your model.

Can I maintain an arcade stick myself or fit quieter buttons?

It depends on the controller and which parts will fit it. HORI says you can access the inside of the standard Fighting Stick α for maintenance; 8BitDo lists hot-swappable switches for the Arcade Controller. Qanba describes the Gravity KS buttons as having noise-dampening parts. Check the size and connection before replacing anything; these features don’t prove how noisy the whole setup will be.

What are my rights when buying online in the Netherlands?

According to the Dutch government, a 14-day cooling-off period applies in many cases when you buy at a distance. Your statutory guarantee and any manufacturer’s warranty are separate things. Check who the seller is and what returns information applies to your specific purchase.

What should I check when buying an electronic device in the Netherlands?

The Dutch government says that electronic devices in the EU must carry a CE marking. This general requirement doesn’t confirm that a specific listing complies; check the model being offered and the seller.