Who is this choice relevant to?

Puzzle gamer looking for a traditional joystick

You want familiar arcade controls, but need to check that the input mode and buttons suit your game. 8BitDo and MAYFLASH describe models with a joystick and different directional inputs.

Gamer who plays with headphones

You want to know in advance whether audio comes through your console or PC, or through a socket on the controller. Nintendo, HORI and MAYFLASH describe different audio connections and model-specific requirements.

Gamer who prefers separate directional buttons

You’re looking for a flat controller without a joystick and want to compare its button layout with the controls in your puzzle game. 8BitDo describes an Arcade Controller with separate buttons.

What should you consider when choosing?

First, check that the exact model works with your platform and game. Then compare the directional controls you prefer and how you’ll connect your headphones.

What to consider What should you check? Who is this for?
Platform and game Check the exact platform, system version, game and required buttons, as well as any adapter requirements. Do I want to make sure my puzzle game accepts the controls on my device before choosing a controller? Around 33% of consumers prioritise platform and game compatibility.
Headphone connection Decide where you’ll plug in your headphones and check that game audio is supported through that connection for your model, platform and setup. If I play with headphones, I want to know where to plug them in and whether I’ll hear game audio. Around 27% of consumers prioritise how they connect their headphones.
Joystick or buttons Compare the layout with the actions in your game and check whether you can configure the buttons or directional mode. I want to decide in advance whether a joystick or separate directional buttons will suit the way I want to control my puzzle game. Around 27% of consumers prioritise the controls.
Size and customisation Compare the space you’ll need to play and store the controller with its dimensions, and check what you can customise on the exact model. If space or the ability to customise the controller later matters more to me than the other options, I want to know how much room it takes up and what I can change. Around 13% of consumers prioritise size or customisation.

Common pitfalls when choosing

  • Assuming console compatibility means your puzzle game is supported

    A mention of a console, adapter or firmware requirement doesn’t automatically mean that the game supports the inputs you need. MAYFLASH lists such requirements for certain models and systems.

    Compare the actions in your game with the input modes on the exact model, and check separately whether you need an adapter.

    Some combinations may also require an additional adapter, so check this for your setup.

  • Assuming a headset port or Bluetooth controller connection provides headphone audio

    Audio support can vary by platform and connection type. A Bluetooth connection between a controller and device doesn’t, by itself, prove that the controller can also send Bluetooth audio to your headphones.

    Check the audio output for your specific combination, or use a headphone connection supported by your gaming device.

  • Choosing a fighting game stick without checking your puzzle game

    MAYFLASH warns that the F700 Elite should not be used with PS5 games other than the specified fighting games. A general compatibility claim therefore doesn’t confirm support for every game.

    Check whether the manufacturer confirms support for your specific game and setup, or choose a controller with confirmed support for the inputs you need.

Brands to consider

8BitDo

The Arcade Stick has a joystick, while the Arcade Controller has a flat, button-only layout. The product pages list Switch and Windows, subject to the requirements of each version.

  • According to 8BitDo, the Arcade Stick has Bluetooth, 2.4GHz and USB-C connections, as well as configurable button mapping. The Arcade Controller has programmable buttons.
  • 8BitDo’s FAQ rules out direct compatibility between the Arcade Stick and PS4, PS5 and Xbox. The product pages reviewed don’t confirm a headphone output, so check audio through your gaming device.

MAYFLASH

The F300 and F500 V2 are arcade sticks with a joystick and switchable directional input modes. They’re worth comparing if you want a particular input mode or need to check platform requirements.

  • According to MAYFLASH, the F500 V2 supports headset audio and chat on PS4 and Xbox One. For the F300, the manufacturer lists a switch between D-pad and X/Y analogue stick modes.
  • The F500 V2 headset claim doesn’t automatically apply to other systems. For the F300, MAYFLASH specifies that an original controller must be connected for systems including PS4 and Xbox; firmware may affect supported features.

HORI

The Fighting Stick α for PS5, PS4 and Windows is worth considering if you’re looking for an arcade joystick and a socket for wired headphones.

  • For the PlayStation version reviewed, HORI specifies a 3.5mm socket and a casing that opens for maintenance and customisation.
  • The socket doesn’t confirm that every puzzle game will work or that the same audio feature is available on every platform. Check the version and your audio setup.

Qanba

Qanba lists the Drone 2 for PS5, PS4 and PC, and specifies a headset interface.

  • Its listed platform support makes the Drone 2 worth comparing if you’re looking for an arcade stick for one of these systems.
  • Qanba also describes the 3.5mm port as a microphone input. Check with the manufacturer whether the version you’re considering sends game audio to headphones through this connection.

Arcade controllers on Joybuy

Related products coming soon.

Frequently asked questions

Do I need to plug my headphones into the arcade stick?

No, connecting them to the console or gaming device may also be an option. Nintendo explains how to connect headphones to the Switch console. If you’re plugging them into the stick, check that the manufacturer confirms audio support for your platform and connection.

Where can I check headphone audio settings on a PS5?

On PS5, go to Settings > Sound > Audio Output. PlayStation lists options such as the output device and ‘Output to Headphones’ setting; the available options depend on the connected equipment.

How do I maintain or customise the controls?

Check the manual for the exact model. For the Fighting Stick α reviewed, HORI describes a casing that opens for maintenance and customisation; 8BitDo describes software-based button mapping for the Arcade Stick.

What are my rights when buying online in the Netherlands?

According to ACM ConsuWijzer, when you buy a product online you generally have up to 14 days after delivery to change your mind, subject to some exceptions. You’re also covered by the legal guarantee if a product doesn’t perform as you’d reasonably expect under normal use; the seller must put this right in line with the applicable terms.