First, check that the stick’s input works with both your device and the specific puzzle game. Then consider how much space you have and how noisy the buttons and joystick are. A compact wired stick may be easier to store, while a model you can customise offers more options for replacing parts. No independently measured noise levels are available here for any of the models discussed.
Who is an arcade stick suitable for?
Player sharing a room with someone who’s asleep
Wants to reduce the noise from pressing the buttons and moving the joystick. Replaceable parts or compatible dampening pads are options worth exploring, but they don’t guarantee that the whole stick will be quiet. Sanwa describes a separate Silent button range, while Focus Attack lists specific compatible button ranges for dampening pads.
Player with a small desk
Wants to set up and put away a stick without giving up too much playing space. Check the dimensions of the stick and cable, as well as how much room you’ll need to play comfortably.
Player on PC or console
Needs to check that both their device and the specific puzzle game support the stick’s connection and input mode. A model’s stated compatibility doesn’t automatically mean it will work with every game.
What should you look for when choosing one?
In a shared bedroom, noise, game compatibility, directional controls and available space may all be priorities. Decide which matters most for the way you play.
| What to consider |
What should you check? |
Who is this most important for? |
| Noise while playing |
Check the exact model’s button type and whether the buttons are accessible and replaceable. According to Focus Attack, dampening pads for 30mm buttons are only suitable for the button ranges it specifies. |
If I play while someone else is asleep, I want to know how loud both the buttons and joystick are. Around 33% of consumers prioritise reducing the noise from controls. |
| Compatibility with your device and game |
Note your device, game and required input mode, then compare these with the instructions for the exact model variant. HORI lists XInput support for the SPF-038 on Windows, but not support for DirectInput games; MAYFLASH says that using the F300 with certain consoles also requires a connected controller. |
If I’m buying a stick for my own PC or console, I want to make sure my specific puzzle game accepts its input. Around 27% of consumers give compatibility with their device and game the highest priority. |
| Suitable directional controls |
Check which directions and inputs the game uses, and which physical gate is fitted to the model you’ve chosen. MAYFLASH describes switching between D-pad and analogue output for the F300; check separately whether the physical gate you want is actually included. |
If a puzzle game requires specific directions or inputs, I want the stick to be a good match. Around 20% of consumers prioritise directional controls. |
| Space and ease of handling |
Measure your desk and storage space, and allow for the cable. HORI lists the SPF-038 at approximately 21 × 15 × 8,7 cm; MAYFLASH lists the F300 at approximately 30,2 × 23,6 × 11,3 cm. |
If my desk is shared or small, I want to be able to set up and store the stick without losing my playing space. Around 20% of consumers give available space the highest priority. |
Common buying mistakes
-
Assuming ‘works with PC’ means ‘works with my puzzle game’
Supported input modes vary by exact model. HORI lists XInput support for the Fighting Stick mini SPF-038 on Windows, but not support for DirectInput games.
Before buying, check your device, the game and the input mode it accepts.
A mismatch could mean the stick won’t work, or that you’ll need extra time to set it up.
-
Assuming ‘Sanwa buttons’ means ‘quiet buttons’
Sanwa describes a separate Silent button range. Dampening pads are designed for specific button types, so the presence of Sanwa parts alone doesn’t mean the whole stick will be quiet.
Check which button model is fitted and, if possible, ask for a sound demonstration of the complete stick.
Replacement buttons or dampening pads may require extra parts and installation. Check that they fit the buttons already fitted before buying.
-
Seeing a console on the compatibility list but overlooking connection requirements
For the MAYFLASH F300, the manufacturer also requires a connected controller when using it with PS4, Xbox One and Xbox 360.
Read the connection instructions for your console and the exact model variant before choosing.
For these consoles, you may need a compatible connected controller as well as the stick.
Brands to compare
MAYFLASH
The F300 and F300 Elite are worth comparing if connection options and replaceable parts matter to you.
- MAYFLASH lists support for Windows and Switch, among other platforms, and compatibility with Sanwa parts for the F300.
- According to MAYFLASH, using the F300 with certain consoles may require a connected controller. The stated compatibility doesn’t prove that every puzzle game will work, and the manufacturer doesn’t provide a comparable noise measurement for the F300 Elite.
8BitDo
The standard Arcade Stick and the separate Arcade Stick for Xbox are designed for different devices.
- For the standard Arcade Stick, 8BitDo lists Bluetooth, 2.4 GHz and USB-C, with support for Switch and Windows. According to 8BitDo, the Xbox version is designed for Xbox and Windows and offers 2.4 GHz and wired connections.
- Don’t treat the standard stick and the Xbox version as interchangeable. The manufacturer doesn’t provide comparable noise measurements for these versions.
HORI
The Fighting Stick mini is a compact option if storage space matters more to you than extensive customisation.
- HORI lists the SPF-038 at approximately 21 × 15 cm, with a wired USB-A connection.
- According to HORI, this Japanese model designation only works with XInput games on Windows, not DirectInput games. Check the identity and specifications of any European variant being offered separately.
Nacon
Daija is worth comparing if you’re also considering a larger stick designed for fighting games.
- Nacon describes Daija versions for PlayStation and Xbox with Sanwa parts.
- The product information focuses on fighting games and doesn’t show that this product range is quieter or better suited to the puzzle game in question.
Joybuy products
Related products coming soon.
Frequently asked questions
Will an arcade stick work with every classic puzzle game on PC?
No. PC compatibility alone doesn’t tell you whether a specific game will work. Check which input mode the game accepts: HORI lists XInput support for the SPF-038 on Windows, but not support for DirectInput games.
How can I reduce the noise from an arcade stick?
First, check which buttons are fitted and whether they’re accessible and replaceable. Sanwa describes a Silent button range, and Focus Attack lists dampening pads for specific button ranges; neither guarantees that a complete stick will be quiet.
What can I do if a stick doesn’t work properly after buying it online?
According to ACM ConsuWijzer, online consumer purchases in the Netherlands often come with a cooling-off period of up to 14 days after delivery, although exceptions apply. Faulty products are covered by the legal guarantee; according to the Dutch government, there is no fixed statutory guarantee period in the Netherlands.