Who is this for?

Quiet puzzle gamer

You share a bedroom with someone who needs peace and quiet, so you want to consider the sound of both the joystick and the buttons. A label such as ‘silent’ doesn’t guarantee that the whole setup will be quiet. Qanba uses this description for these components on the Q8.

Switch and PC gamer

You want to use the same controls across different systems you own, so you check the system version and whether the specific game is supported. 8BitDo and MAYFLASH list support for several systems for their respective models.

Gamer with limited desk space

You’re looking for a controller that fits the space available and can be put away after playing. HORI describes its Fighting Stick Mini for Switch as compact and wired.

What should you consider when choosing?

First, check that your system and the puzzle game support the stick. Then compare its control noise, space requirements and directional input with your gaming setup.

What to consider What should you check? Who is this for?
Control noise Check whether both the joystick and buttons on the exact version are described as quiet; also bear in mind that sound can travel through the desk. If I’m playing in a shared bedroom, I want to consider both the joystick and the buttons; around 33% of consumers put control noise first.
System and game Compare the exact console or Windows version and the game’s controller input options with the model’s compatibility. I want to know in advance whether my system and puzzle game will recognise the controller; around 27% of consumers prioritise compatibility.
Space and storage Measure the available desk and storage space, and check that the cable can be positioned conveniently. If I need my desk for other things too, I want to be able to put the stick away after playing; around 20% of consumers make space their top consideration.
Directional input Check which directions the game requires and whether the stick supports that input; verify the component and firmware versions before making any changes. I want the directional input to suit my puzzle game and preferences; around 20% of consumers prioritise control and customisation.

Pitfalls to avoid when buying

  • Assuming ‘silent’ means completely noiseless

    Qanba describes components on a specific Q8 version as quiet. That description doesn’t tell you how much noise the complete controller makes during use.

    Consider both the joystick and the buttons, and bear in mind the sound that can travel through the surface the stick is placed on.

  • Confusing a platform name with support for every system and game

    The 8BitDo FAQ rules out direct support for PS4, PS5 and Xbox. HORI also sells separate Switch and PlayStation versions.

    Check the full model, your system and the input options in the specific puzzle game before ordering.

  • Assuming customisable components make for a quieter upgrade

    The customisation options on the MAYFLASH F101 don’t mean its standard controls are quiet. The correct firmware also depends on the circuit board version.

    Try the standard controls first, and check hardware and firmware compatibility before replacing components or updating the firmware.

    Customisation may require extra components and assembly.

Brands to consider

Qanba

The Q8 may be worth considering if you play on PC and want to take the sound of both the joystick and buttons into account.

  • For the Q8 version, Qanba lists a Gravity Silent Lever and Gravity KS Silent buttons.
  • This is the manufacturer’s description, not a sound measurement of the complete controller. Don’t assume it’s supported by a console.

8BitDo

According to 8BitDo, the Arcade Stick is designed for supported Switch and Windows systems.

  • 8BitDo lists Bluetooth, 2.4 GHz and USB-C. The product specifications state that it supports Switch from version 3.0.0, Switch 2 from version 20.1.1 and Windows 10 from version 1903.
  • The official FAQ says the stick doesn’t work directly with PS4, PS5 or Xbox. The manufacturer doesn’t claim that this model has quiet controls.

HORI

The Fighting Stick Mini for Switch is worth a look if a compact design is important to you.

  • HORI describes the Switch version as wired, around 8 × 6 inches in size and also compatible with PC.
  • The micro-switch joystick isn’t described as quiet. HORI also has a separate PlayStation version; don’t treat it as the same product.

MAYFLASH

According to MAYFLASH, the F101 is a wired stick with customisable components and input modes.

  • MAYFLASH lists interchangeable buttons and modes for different input types on supported systems.
  • Customisation doesn’t mean the controls are quiet. MAYFLASH warns that an F101 with a new circuit board isn’t compatible with firmware V1.07 or earlier.

Joybuy products

Related products coming soon.

Frequently asked questions

Will every arcade stick work with my puzzle game?

No. Support for your console or PC doesn’t guarantee that a specific game will recognise the stick. Check the game’s input options and compare them with the controller’s modes; according to MAYFLASH, the MAYFLASH F101 can switch between directional button and analogue stick modes.

How do I connect the 8BitDo Arcade Stick to a Windows PC?

According to 8BitDo, you can connect via Bluetooth, the 2.4GHz receiver or a USB-C cable, within the Windows support specified by the manufacturer. The official FAQ rules out direct support for PS4, PS5 and Xbox.

Can I update the MAYFLASH F101 using any firmware?

No. MAYFLASH states that an F101 with a new circuit board isn’t compatible with firmware V1.07 or earlier. First, find out which hardware version you have and follow the instructions for that version.

What should I look for in a controller’s product safety information in the Netherlands?

The Dutch Authority for Digital Infrastructure says that electrical and electronic equipment must have the correct CE marking. Check this for the specific version; wireless equipment must also meet the applicable requirements for radio equipment.

What are my rights when buying online?

According to the Government of the Netherlands, distance purchases often come with a 14-day cooling-off period; check the terms that apply to your purchase. You’re also entitled to a statutory guarantee: if a product is faulty, the seller must provide a solution.