Who is this for?

Players practising directions and jumps

You want to choose between a joystick and separate direction buttons. Compare the layout with the controls in your game before choosing a model.

Players with a specific console

You want to avoid buying a version made for another console, or one with limited game support, that you can’t use. So check both the console and the specific game.

Players gaming beside a bright window

You want to see the game clearly without blaming screen reflections on the controller. General information from the Occupational Safety and Health Administration warns that bright light can wash out images on a screen.

What should you consider when choosing?

What to consider What to look for Who it matters to
Game and platform compatibility Check the exact model version, console and game. Also check whether the game requires analogue input or two sticks. If I want to avoid ending up with a controller that can’t provide the input my game requires, I check the whole combination. Around 36% of consumers prioritise compatibility with their game and platform.
Control type Compare the joystick or direction buttons with the movements and jumps in your game. 8BitDo lists customisable buttons on specific versions. If you want to practise directions and jumps repeatedly, consider which type of control suits you. Around 29% of consumers prioritise the control type.
Visibility in a bright room Consider the position of windows, lamps and your screen in relation to one another. Also check whether you can see the controller’s controls clearly in your lighting. If incoming light makes it harder for me to see the screen, I adjust my setup first. Around 21% of consumers put visibility in the room at the top of their list.
Space, connection and maintenance Measure the available space and check the connection method and any accessories required for the exact version. HORI says the casing of the Fighting Stick α can be opened for maintenance and customisation. If you play at a desk or need a specific connection, you’ll want to know in advance whether it will fit your gaming space. Around 14% of consumers prioritise setup and connection.

Pitfalls to avoid when buying

  • Assuming ‘PS5 compatible’ means it works with every PS5 game

    A console listing doesn’t automatically mean a controller supports every game. MAYFLASH advises against using the F700 Elite with PS5 games other than fighting games, including action games.

    Check the game and any limitations for the exact model, as well as the console.

  • Confusing versions made for different consoles

    Platform lists vary between versions. For example, 8BitDo has separate Arcade Controller versions for Switch and Windows, and for Xbox.

    Compare the full product name and platform list, not just the brand or product range.

  • Buying a new controller to fix screen reflections

    Bright light can wash out the image on your screen; a different controller won’t change how the light falls on it.

    First, check the position of your screen, windows and lamps.

  • Overlooking extra connection equipment

    Connecting the MAYFLASH F500 Elite to a PS5 may require additional hardware. MAYFLASH’s instructions dated 18 November 2022 describe a connection method using an adapter.

    Check which connection method applies to your version and what you’ll need.

    Depending on the connection method you choose, you may need a separate adapter or compatible controller.

Brands to compare

8BitDo

Offers both joystick arcade sticks and leverless controllers, with versions for different platforms.

  • For specific Arcade Controller versions, 8BitDo lists multiple connection methods and customisable buttons.
  • The Switch and Windows version is not the same as the Xbox version. Check game compatibility separately.

HORI

The Fighting Stick α is an option if you want a joystick and easy access to the internal components matters to you.

  • HORI says the casing of this version can be opened for maintenance and customisation.
  • This specification doesn’t prove that it supports every platform game or that it will help you practise more effectively.

Nacon

The Daija is available in separate PlayStation and Xbox versions.

  • Nacon lists a 3-metre cable and interchangeable joystick knobs as included with the PlayStation version.
  • Nacon warns that some Xbox games requiring two joysticks are not compatible. Don’t assume this applies to another version.

MAYFLASH

The range includes arcade sticks with different connection options, including the F500 Elite and wireless F700 Elite.

  • The manufacturer describes several connection methods for the F500 Elite.
  • MAYFLASH advises against using the F700 Elite with PS5 games other than fighting games. Also check whether the F500 Elite needs additional hardware for your console.

Qanba

The Drone 2 is a joystick controller that Qanba lists as supporting PS5, PS4 and PC.

  • Qanba lists a platform switch and touchpad for this model.
  • Check that the specific game works with the input it offers; a platform listing alone doesn’t confirm this.

Joybuy products

Related products coming soon.

Frequently asked questions

Can I play any platform game on PS5 with a stick labelled ‘PS5’?

No. A platform listing alone doesn’t confirm that a controller works with every game. MAYFLASH advises against using the F700 Elite with PS5 games other than fighting games, including action games. Check the specific game and version before buying.

How do I connect an arcade controller?

Follow the connection method for the exact version. For the Arcade Controller, 8BitDo lists Bluetooth for Switch, 2.4 GHz for Windows and a wired connection for both; check which method applies to your model and platform.

Will illuminated buttons help if the sun is shining on my screen?

No, illuminated buttons won’t prevent reflections on your screen. General information from the Occupational Safety and Health Administration notes that bright light can wash out images on a screen. Adjust the position of your screen and lighting, and assess the buttons separately in your room.

Who can help if my controller is faulty, and can I return an online purchase?

If a fault develops during normal use, the seller is responsible for the statutory guarantee. According to ACM ConsuWijzer, online purchases generally come with a 14-day cooling-off period from delivery; check whether a legal exception applies to your purchase.

What rules apply to a wireless arcade controller?

EU rules on radio equipment may apply to wireless devices. According to the European Commission and EU guidance on CE marking, the mark is required when applicable harmonised product rules say so. Check the information for the specific model; a console licence is not a CE assessment.