Who is this for?

Evening player with a roommate

You practise while someone else is resting in the same room, so you want to consider the noise from both the joystick and the buttons. Qanba describes components of the Q8 as silent, but that label doesn’t tell you how loud they’ll be in your bedroom.

Player with a specific platform game

You want to know in advance which directional inputs and controller functions your game supports. For the NSW-149 on PC, HORI lists support for XInput-compatible games, while Mayflash describes switchable directional input for the F300. Steam Support notes that a chosen input style won’t work if a game doesn’t support it.

Player sharing a desk

You need to share your playing space or use a stick with different supported systems. HORI lists the dimensions of its Fighting Stick mini; 8BitDo lists Bluetooth, 2.4GHz and wired USB-C for the Arcade Stick.

What should you look for?

First, check that your game and system support the controls you want. Then consider noise, space and connections in the context of your room.

What to consider What should you check? Who is this important for?
Noise from the joystick and buttons Check whether both components on the exact version are described as silent. A manufacturer’s description is not a measurement of noise in your room. If I practise while my roommate is resting, I want to know how both the joystick and buttons sound. For around 33% of consumers, keeping that noise down is the top priority.
Input for your game and system Check the input your game and system require, along with the stick’s input mode. Also look out for functions the model doesn’t support. If I want to control my platform game properly, I first check which inputs the game accepts. For around 27% of consumers, having the right game and system input is the top priority.
Desk space Compare the listed footprint with the space you have available, and allow for the joystick and cable routing. If I share a desk, I want to know in advance whether the stick will fit and where I can store it. For around 20% of consumers, how much space it takes up matters most.
Connections and customisation Check which connection your system supports and whether you need extra equipment for certain console combinations. Replaceable components don’t prove that the stick will be quieter. If I switch between supported systems or want to customise components later, I check what each model offers. For around 20% of consumers, connection or customisation flexibility is the top priority.

Common buying mistakes

  • Assuming ‘silent’ means inaudible

    Qanba describes certain Q8 components as silent, but that product description doesn’t tell you how loud the stick will be in a shared bedroom.

    Consider both the joystick and buttons, and check whether you can try them out within the applicable returns period.

  • Confusing system compatibility with game compatibility

    A working connection doesn’t guarantee that a game supports the stick’s directional input or functions. The Mayflash F300 has several input modes, according to Mayflash; for the NSW-149 on PC, HORI lists only XInput-compatible games.

    Before ordering, check the game, system, model version and required input together.

    Mayflash says that certain console combinations may require an additional wired controller.

  • Assuming a compact or wireless stick will be quieter

    Dimensions and connection options tell you about space and connectivity, not the mechanical noise of the joystick and buttons.

    Compare noise features separately from size and connectivity.

Brands to compare

These brands are relevant to different considerations around noise, input, space and connectivity; their inclusion here doesn’t in itself indicate availability.

Qanba

The Q8 is a PC option to consider if you’re looking for quieter controls.

  • Qanba lists the Gravity Silent Lever and Gravity KS Silent buttons for the Q8.
  • These descriptions aren’t independent noise measurements; also check that your PC and game are supported.

HORI

The Fighting Stick mini, model NSW-149, is a compact wired option for supported systems.

  • HORI lists dimensions of approximately 210 × 150 mm and support for Nintendo Switch and Windows 10/11.
  • For PC, HORI lists only XInput-compatible games; the model isn’t described as silent.

8BitDo

The Arcade Stick is an option if you’re looking for a choice of connection methods for supported Switch and Windows systems.

  • 8BitDo lists Bluetooth, 2.4GHz and wired USB-C.
  • The connection options don’t prove that the stick is quiet or works with every game.

Mayflash

The F300 is worth considering if you want to switch between D-pad and left-stick input or customise components.

  • Mayflash lists switchable input modes and compatibility with certain replaceable Sanwa components.
  • According to Mayflash, certain consoles require an additional wired controller to be connected; check the exact combination. Customisation doesn’t prove that the standard version is quiet.

Joybuy products

Related products coming soon.

Frequently asked questions

Will every arcade stick work with my platform game?

No. Support for your system doesn’t automatically mean that your game supports the controls. Check which inputs your specific game accepts and compare them with the directional mode and functions of the exact model. Steam Support says that a chosen input style won’t work if the game doesn’t support it.

What can I do if the directional input isn’t right?

First, check which input mode suits your game and system. According to Mayflash, the F300 has a switch for D-pad or left-stick input; Mayflash says that certain consoles require an additional wired controller. Follow the instructions for the exact model before deciding that the stick is faulty.

Do I need to replace the buttons or joystick to play more quietly?

You don’t need to replace anything to use a stick, and doing so doesn’t guarantee less noise. Mayflash says that the F300 is compatible with certain replaceable components; check compatibility and the seller’s terms before making any changes.

What if the stick doesn’t fit at home or makes too much noise?

For an online purchase in the Netherlands, ACM ConsuWijzer says you’ll generally have a statutory 14-day cooling-off period after delivery, with some exceptions. Faults are covered by different rules from a change of mind: ACM ConsuWijzer says that the statutory guarantee depends on how long you can reasonably expect a product to last, not on a general fixed period of exactly two years.

What rules apply to a wireless arcade stick sold in the Netherlands?

Radio equipment within the scope of the European Radio Equipment Directive must meet requirements before it can be placed on the market. According to the European Commission and Your Europe, CE marking is required when applicable harmonised EU rules say so. These general rules don’t confirm that an individual listing is compliant.