Which type of controller is right for you?

Arcade player who prefers a joystick

You want a joystick with separate buttons for arcade games and need to check whether the stick works with your console or PC.

Player gaming from the sofa

You play on a big screen from your seat and are mainly looking for a suitable wireless connection and a controller with the right power supply.

Retro gamer who plays different types of games

You also play games where a handy gamepad with a four-way directional pad and extra buttons may be more practical than a large stick.

What should you consider when choosing?

Start with the device you play on. Then choose the controls that suit your games, and check that the connection and power supply work for your gaming set-up.

What to consider What should you check? Who is this important for?
Compatibility Check the exact model, the device you play on and any firmware or input-mode requirements. If I want to make sure the controller works with my console or PC before anything else, compatibility comes first; around 36% of consumers say compatibility with their gaming device is their main concern when buying.
Controls and button layout Compare the actions you need in games and menus with the joystick, buttons and button-mapping options. I want a joystick with separate arcade buttons to recreate the layout of an arcade cabinet; around 29% of consumers give the joystick and button layout top priority.
Distance and power supply Check the available connection, whether a receiver is needed, the cable length and whether the model uses batteries or a rechargeable battery. If I play from the sofa, I want to know whether a cable will reach my set-up and how the controller is powered; around 21% of consumers say playing distance, cables or power supply matter most.
Controls for other retro games Check whether the controller has enough buttons for the games and menus you want to use. I play different types of retro games and don’t want to use a different controller for every game; around 14% of consumers put versatile, straightforward controls ahead of other buying considerations.

Avoid common buying mistakes

  • Relying only on ‘works with PC’ or ‘works with console’

    Platform support doesn’t necessarily tell you how the controller connects to your specific console. For the F500 V2, MAYFLASH describes an additional connection option for PS5.

    Check the full model name, console version, any firmware requirements and the manufacturer’s connection instructions.

  • Assuming wireless means USB charging

    Power options vary by model. The PowerA manual specifies two AA batteries, while 8BitDo lists a rechargeable battery for the Arcade Stick.

    Check the power supply for the exact version and which accessories are included.

  • Choosing a classic joystick without counting the buttons

    Speedlink lists four fire buttons for the COMPETITION PRO EXTRA USB. Make sure that’s enough for the actions and menus in your games.

    Compare the actions you need with the available buttons and check what configuration options the game offers.

  • Confusing Switch and PlayStation versions with the same product family name

    HORI sells separate Fighting Stick Mini versions for Nintendo Switch and PlayStation 5/4.

    Match the full product version to the device you play on, not just the product family name.

Brands to compare

8BitDo

Offers arcade sticks, gamepads and leverless controllers for different styles of play.

  • According to 8BitDo, the Arcade Stick supports Bluetooth, 2.4 GHz and USB-C, and lets you map buttons.
  • These features don’t automatically apply to other models. Check the version of the SN30 Pro and how the Arcade Controller connects to your system.

MAYFLASH

The F500 V2 is a wired arcade stick with several system and input modes listed by the manufacturer.

  • MAYFLASH lists XInput and DirectInput for PC and describes a switchable directional mode.
  • For PS5, MAYFLASH describes additional connection options. Don’t assume every console will work straight away.

PowerA

The FUSION Wireless Arcade Stick is a wireless arcade stick option for Nintendo Switch.

  • The PowerA manual explains how to pair it wirelessly and connect it by cable via the Switch dock.
  • For battery power, the manual specifies two AA batteries; this is different from a built-in rechargeable battery.

HORI

The Fighting Stick Mini is available in separate versions for Nintendo Switch and PlayStation.

  • HORI describes the Switch version as a wired stick with eight buttons.
  • The Switch and PlayStation 5/4 versions are separate products. Check the platform version carefully.

Speedlink

The COMPETITION PRO EXTRA USB is a classic joystick for use with Windows or configurable RetroPie.

  • Speedlink lists DirectInput and four fire buttons; an OTG adapter is mentioned for Android use.
  • Check whether the available buttons are enough for your games and menus, and whether your set-up requires the adapter mentioned.

Gamepads for retro games on a big screen

These product picks are gamepads for PS4, PC, Xbox and Switch set-ups, among others. Check whether each model works with the device you use to play your retro games.

VIELLAN wireless Bluetooth gamepad for PS4, pale green

VIELLAN Wireless Bluetooth Gamepad for PS4 – Pale Green

Suitable for a PS4 set-up and anyone looking for a wireless gamepad with directional controls.

Bluetooth; 600 mAh battery; two vibration motors.

Joybuy
VIELLAN wireless Bluetooth controller for PS4

VIELLAN Wireless Bluetooth Controller for PS4

Suitable for anyone looking for a wireless PS4 gamepad with a rechargeable battery.

Bluetooth; 600 mAh battery; rechargeable; 6-axis.

Joybuy
GameSir Cyclone 2 controller, White-Bundle Edition

GameSir Cyclone 2 – White-Bundle Edition

Suitable for anyone looking for a gamepad for a Switch or PC set-up.

TMR sticks; 1000 Hz polling rate; 2-in-1 Hall effect and micro-switch triggers; charging dock.

Joybuy
Wolverine V3 Pro game controller, black

Wolverine V3 Pro – Black

Suitable for anyone looking for a gamepad for a PC or Xbox Series set-up who values customisable controls.

Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

Do you connect the controller directly to the TV?

First, check which device runs the game: the controllers mentioned are designed for consoles or PCs, not just any TV. For playing Switch games on a TV, Nintendo Netherlands describes using a dock connected to the television via HDMI. Then choose a controller that suits your version of the Switch.

How do you connect a wireless arcade stick to a Switch in a TV set-up?

Follow the instructions for your exact stick. The PowerA manual explains how to pair it wirelessly with a Nintendo Switch and specifies the USB port on the Switch dock for a wired connection. These instructions don’t automatically apply to other models.

Will a stick that works with Windows automatically work with PS5?

No. Windows support doesn’t prove that the stick will work directly with PS5. For the F500 V2, MAYFLASH describes specific connection options that require additional equipment, while HORI offers a separate Fighting Stick Mini for PlayStation 5/4. Check the requirements for the exact version.

What should you check about a wireless controller’s power supply?

Check whether the model uses batteries or a rechargeable battery. The PowerA manual specifies two AA batteries for the FUSION when using battery power; 8BitDo lists a rechargeable battery for the Arcade Stick. The connection option described for the MAYFLASH F500 V2 on PS5 may require additional equipment.

What are your rights when buying a controller online in the Netherlands?

According to ACM ConsuWijzer, when you buy online from a business you generally have 14 days after delivery to change your mind, subject to legal exceptions. The seller is also responsible for the legal guarantee if the product doesn’t meet what you could reasonably expect with normal use. In the Netherlands, there isn’t a fixed two-year period for every product.