Who is this buying guide for?

Room-sharers who are mindful of noise

You practise while someone else is using the same bedroom and want to keep mechanical noise to a minimum. Consider button and lever noise separately: Focus Attack describes dampening rings for certain buttons, while Qanba lists quieter parts for a specific model.

Players with a specific platform

You play on a particular console or PC and need a controller that works with your version of the game. Sony advises checking with the manufacturer to confirm support for the specific product and game, so don’t assume PS5 compatibility based solely on a PS4 listing.

Players short on storage space

You want a controller that’s easy to set up and put away, and are weighing a flat, leverless layout against the lever control you’re used to. Razer describes the Kitsune as leverless and easy to store, but this layout does change how you input directions.

What should you look for when choosing?

Traditional stick with a lever

Choose this option: if you want to practise lever movements.

Bear in mind: as well as the buttons, the lever can be a source of mechanical noise.

Leverless arcade controller

Choose this option: if you’d rather use buttons to input directions and want to store a flatter device.

Bear in mind: you’ll be practising a different movement layout, and the buttons may still make noise.

Modify your existing stick

Choose this option: if you mainly want to reduce the noise from compatible buttons.

Bear in mind: dampening parts are designed for specific button types and may need fitting; they won’t reduce lever noise.

What to consider What should you look for? Who is this important for?
Mechanical noise Check which buttons and lever are fitted to the exact model, and whether compatible dampening parts are available. If I practise while sharing a bedroom, I want to know which controls make noise; around 36% of consumers prioritise reducing mechanical noise.
Game and platform support Check the full model variant, game version and any adapter requirements with the manufacturer. If I play on my own console or PC, my controller needs to work with my game; around 29% of consumers give compatibility with their game and platform top priority.
Storage and control Compare the stated dimensions with the space you have available and decide whether you want to use a lever or directional buttons. If storage space is limited, I want a layout that suits both my space and the way I play; around 21% of consumers look at this first.
Customisation and costs Check whether the parts are accessible and which compatible dampening parts or platform adapters you’ll need. If I want to replace parts or need an adapter, I want to know in advance what my chosen setup requires; around 14% of consumers prioritise customisation and additional costs.

Common buying mistakes

  • Confusing a headset socket or mute button with quiet controls

    Audio features won’t automatically eliminate the mechanical noise of button presses and lever movements. Check which parts the controller actually uses.

    Assess audio features and mechanical noise separately. For the latter, check the buttons and lever fitted to the controller.

  • Assuming PS4 support means PS5 support

    Support can vary by model, platform and game. For the Mayflash F500 Elite, the manufacturer lists a MagicBoots-S5 adapter for PS5 use.

    Before choosing a controller, check the full model name, support for your game and any adapter requirements.

  • Assuming a leverless model offers the same practising experience

    With a leverless controller, you input directions using buttons. This means practising a different movement layout, and the buttons may still make noise.

    First decide whether you want to learn lever movements or use directional buttons, then check that your chosen model supports your platform.

Brands to compare

Nacon

The Daija PlayStation version is a traditional stick for players who want to use a lever and action buttons.

  • Nacon lists Sanwa parts and options for customising the stick. The manufacturer lists support for PS5, PS4 and PC, subject to the stated XInput requirement for PC games.
  • These specifications are not an independent noise measurement. Check the platform requirements for the exact version.

Qanba

Qanba offers both traditional sticks, such as the Drone 2, and the separate, PC-focused Q8.

  • Qanba lists PS4, PS5 and PC support for the Drone 2. For the Q8, the manufacturer describes its Gravity lever and Gravity KS buttons as quiet.
  • The Q8 parts are not specifications for the Drone 2. Qanba’s description is not an independent measurement of the noise made by a complete controller.

Razer

The Kitsune is a leverless arcade controller for players who want to input directions using buttons.

  • Razer lists a flat design and a detachable USB-C cable. The manufacturer describes it as easy to store.
  • It works differently from a traditional stick and has not been measured for noise. Razer’s claims about accuracy are brand claims.

Mayflash

The F500 Elite and F700 Elite are different traditional sticks, each with its own platform requirements.

  • Mayflash lists Sanwa parts for the F500 Elite and PS5 support for fighting games for the F700 Elite.
  • For PS5 use with the F500 Elite, Mayflash lists a MagicBoots-S5 adapter. According to Mayflash, the F700 Elite doesn’t work with Xbox Series S/X and isn’t designed for other types of PS5 games.

8BitDo

The Arcade Stick is a traditional stick; the Arcade Controller is a separate, flat, leverless model.

  • 8BitDo lists Switch and Windows versions of the Arcade Stick. For the Arcade Controller, the manufacturer gives dimensions of 301 × 201 × 22 mm and a weight of 1097 g, among other specifications.
  • The models have different control layouts. The listed platform support does not confirm PS5 support or quiet operation.

Arcade controllers at Joybuy

Related products will be available soon.

Frequently asked questions

Will every PS4 arcade stick work with my PS5 fighting game?

No. Don’t rely on a ‘PS4 compatible’ listing alone. Sony warns that not every officially licensed or other peripheral works with PS5, and advises checking with the manufacturer for the specific product and game.

Can I reduce the button noise from an existing stick?

Possibly, if the buttons and casing are suitable. Focus Attack describes dampening rings for certain 30 mm Sanwa and Seimitsu buttons; check that they’re compatible with your button type. This doesn’t tell you exactly how much noise the lever will continue to make.

Do I need extra hardware to use the Mayflash F500 Elite with PS5?

Mayflash lists support for PS5 use with a MagicBoots-S5 adapter. Before choosing, check which adapter and firmware version you need, and whether the model works with your game; this listing is not a general guarantee of adapter-free PS5 use.

What are my rights when buying an arcade stick online in the Netherlands?

According to the Dutch government, when you buy from a business at a distance, you generally have a 14-day cooling-off period; not every transaction, such as an online purchase from a private seller, is covered by this rule. If a product is faulty, you’re also entitled to a product that works properly, and you should generally contact the seller. The Netherlands does not have one fixed statutory guarantee period that applies to all products.