Who is an arcade stick for?

PC retro gamer

You want to know whether the button layout and DirectInput or XInput support suit your game. Speedlink, 8BitDo, MAYFLASH and Nacon outline the PC support available for each model.

Console player with limited space

You’re looking for a stick for a specific console and want to consider its size and how well it supports your hands. HORI, 8BitDo and Nacon describe models for different consoles.

Player who wants to customise the controls

You want to be able to change buttons, profiles or components, and check which systems each version supports. 8BitDo, Nacon and MAYFLASH outline different customisation options.

What should you look for when choosing one?

First check that the game supports the controls and input protocol. Then compare the number of buttons and the space the stick takes up, and assess visibility in your gaming space separately.

What to consider What should you check? Who is this important for?
Platform and game compatibility Check the exact model, your system, the input mode and the game’s control requirements. If I want to be sure my game works on my PC or console, I check that both the system and the game are supported. Around 28% of consumers put compatibility first.
Number and layout of buttons Count the actions you need and check whether you can assign them in the game. The Speedlink COMPETITION PRO EXTRA has four fire buttons; the HORI Fighting Stick Mini has an eight-button layout. If you want to use all the controls in a beat ’em up effectively, pay attention to the number of buttons and how they can be assigned. Around 22% of consumers make this their first consideration when choosing.
Legibility in a bright room Assess the labels and modes in the lighting where you play; check for screen reflections separately. If I want to identify the buttons and selected mode easily while playing, I check how visible the controls are in my room. Around 22% of consumers prioritise legibility.
Size and placement Compare the dimensions with your table or storage space, and consider support and stability while playing. If I have a small table or limited storage space, I want to know whether the stick will fit and provide enough support. Around 17% of consumers start by considering size and placement.
Extra components and service Check the packaging for any adapters or controllers you need, and see who the seller is. If I want to know what else I’ll need alongside the stick and who I can contact after buying it, I check the components and seller in advance. Around 11% of consumers put these things at the top of their list.

Common buying mistakes

  • Assuming that a console compatibility list means everything will work straight away

    For the MAYFLASH F500 V2, the manufacturer describes additional connection methods for PS5 and Xbox Series X/S. The setup you need may therefore depend on your console and the method you choose.

    Before buying, check the instructions for your console, the required firmware and which components are included in the offer.

    Some setups may require a suitable adapter or controller, so check this before you choose.

  • Confusing a basic retro joystick with a full fight stick

    The Speedlink version reviewed has four fire buttons, while the HORI Fighting Stick Mini has an eight-button layout. The right layout depends on the actions your game requires.

    Count the actions you need, including any special functions, and check whether the game lets you assign them to buttons.

  • Assuming visual button labels are a guarantee of daylight visibility

    8BitDo describes a dynamic visual layout when switching between Switch and PC modes, but that doesn’t tell you how legible it is in bright daylight. Screen reflections are a separate issue, too.

    Assess the button labels in the lighting where you play, and check separately that the screen remains easy to see.

Brands to consider

Speedlink

The COMPETITION PRO EXTRA USB is a classic retro joystick for PC, with four fire buttons and DirectInput.

  • Speedlink says this version works with Windows 7 or later. The brand also mentions microswitches with an audible click.
  • For Android, Speedlink specifies an OTG adapter. Check whether four fire buttons and DirectInput are enough for your game; according to the brand, the included games are for Windows.

8BitDo

The Arcade Stick for Switch and Windows and the separate Arcade Stick for Xbox have different stated compatibility.

  • For the Switch and PC version, 8BitDo lists Bluetooth, 2.4 GHz, USB-C and a dynamic button layout.
  • Don’t assume the Switch/PC version also supports Xbox; check the compatibility of the exact model. The dynamic labels have not been tested for daylight visibility.

HORI

The Fighting Stick Mini for PS5, PS4 and Windows is a compact stick with eight buttons.

  • HORI lists a wired connection and rubber feet.
  • According to HORI, this model doesn’t have a touchpad. Consider whether its compact casing offers enough room and support for your hands.

MAYFLASH

The F500 V2 has a larger casing and, according to MAYFLASH, supports XInput and DirectInput on PC.

  • MAYFLASH describes metal panels and options for customising the stick.
  • For PS5 and Xbox Series X/S, the manufacturer describes specific additional connection options. Check which method and components your system requires.

Nacon

The PlayStation version of the Daija is a wired stick for PS5 and PS4, with customisable components and profiles.

  • Nacon lists Sanwa components, interchangeable faceplates and an included three-metre detachable cable.
  • According to Nacon support information, the Daija works with XInput games on PC; some games that require two joysticks are not compatible.

Arcade sticks at Joybuy

Related products will be available soon.

Frequently asked questions

What can I do if a PC game doesn’t respond to my arcade stick?

First check which input protocol the game supports and select the corresponding mode on the stick. For the Daija on PC, Nacon lists XInput games; for the F500 V2, MAYFLASH lists both XInput and DirectInput. Then assign the actions in the game.

Will the MAYFLASH F500 V2 work with PS5 games without an extra component?

Don’t assume it will: MAYFLASH describes specific adapters or compatible controllers for PS5. Check the connection method for your setup, the required firmware and what’s included in the packaging.

Can an arcade stick solve screen reflections in a bright room?

No. An arcade stick is an input device and won’t solve reflections on your screen. Assess the lighting around the screen separately, and check whether you can identify the labels and selected mode on the stick.

What rights do I have when buying online in the Netherlands?

According to the Dutch government, when you buy online from a business, you often have a 14-day cooling-off period; check the terms and any exceptions that apply to your purchase. If a product is faulty, the seller must offer a solution. The Netherlands has no fixed statutory guarantee period that applies to all products.