Who is it for?

Players who are mindful of noise

If you play while your roommate is resting or studying, you may want to consider the noise made by the controls. SANWA and Qanba describe dampening for specific replacement buttons; this doesn’t tell you how much noise a complete stick makes.

Retro gamers with multiple devices

If you switch between devices such as a PC, Switch and console, it’s worth checking support for the exact model variant. 8BitDo says its Arcade Stick supports Switch and Windows, but doesn’t connect directly to PS4, PS5 or Xbox.

Players short on storage space

If you share a desk or bedroom, compare the stick’s dimensions, cable routing and storage space before buying. HORI lists the Fighting Stick Mini at around 8 × 6 inches; MAYFLASH gives the F700’s dimensions as 37,4 × 24,6 × 6,3 cm and its weight as 3,45 kg.

What should you look for?

First, check that the stick works with your gaming device and preferred connection. Then consider control noise, where you’ll use the stick and whether you might want to customise it.

What to consider What should you check? Who should give this more weight?
Control noise Check whether the buttons can be replaced, which size and fittings are compatible, and whether the joystick noise is acceptable too. SANWA describes dampening for OBSFS buttons; check that they fit the stick you’re considering. If my roommate is resting or studying, I want to know how much noise the controls make and whether compatible replacement buttons are available. Noise is the top priority for around 36% of consumers making this choice.
Device compatibility Check the exact model variant, your console or PC, and the connection you want. According to 8BitDo, the Arcade Stick doesn’t connect directly to PS4, PS5 or Xbox; certain MAYFLASH F300 console configurations also come with additional requirements. I want to connect the stick to the device my retro game runs on, without relying on general compatibility claims. For around 29% of consumers, working with their own device is the main priority.
Space and cable routing Measure your desk and storage space, then compare them with the dimensions and cable routing of the exact model variant. HORI lists the Fighting Stick Mini at around 8 × 6 inches; MAYFLASH gives the F700’s dimensions as 37,4 × 24,6 × 6,3 cm and its weight as 3,45 kg. If I need to put the stick away after playing or share a desk, I want to know whether its size and cable will fit comfortably. Space is the top consideration for around 21% of consumers making this choice.
Customising components Check replaceability, button size and joystick connection for the exact model. MAYFLASH says the F300 supports SANWA components; Nacon specifies SANWA components for the PlayStation version of the Daija. I want to be able to customise the controls later and find out in advance which components and fittings are compatible. Customisation is the most important factor for around 14% of consumers.

Common mistakes

  • Assuming wireless means quiet

    Bluetooth or 2.4 GHz tells you about the connection, not the noise made by the buttons or joystick. Dampening for specific buttons doesn’t prove that the whole stick is quiet either.

    Assess the connection and physical controls separately. Also check the size and fittings required for replacement buttons on the exact model.

    Replacement buttons may require compatible components and installation.

  • Assuming another version has the same compatibility

    According to the manufacturer, the 8BitDo Arcade Stick doesn’t connect directly to PS4, PS5 or Xbox. Certain MAYFLASH F300 console configurations require additional hardware or depend on the firmware.

    Before choosing a version, compare its full model name and connection instructions with your own console and game.

    Some connections may require a separate controller or adapter.

  • Assuming a compact stick is quieter

    HORI describes the Fighting Stick Mini as having a microswitch joystick. Its compact size alone doesn’t tell you how much noise the stick makes.

    Choose a smaller model for easier storage, and check control noise separately.

Brands to compare

The features listed below apply to the specific model ranges and versions mentioned; a brand name alone won’t tell you whether a stick suits your device or bedroom.

8BitDo

The Arcade Stick is worth comparing if you play on Switch or Windows and are considering different connection options.

  • 8BitDo lists Bluetooth, 2.4 GHz and USB-C as connection options.
  • According to the manufacturer, this model doesn’t connect directly to PS4, PS5 or Xbox. A wireless connection doesn’t mean the buttons are quiet.

MAYFLASH

The F300 and F700 are worth looking into if replaceable components or multiple connection options are important to you.

  • MAYFLASH lists replaceable components for the F300 and F700. The manufacturer gives the F700’s weight as 3,45 kg.
  • Certain F300 console configurations require an additional controller, adapter or compatible firmware.

HORI

The Fighting Stick Mini is a compact model worth comparing if storage space is a priority.

  • HORI specifies that the Fighting Stick Mini measures around 8 × 6 inches and has eight buttons and a microswitch joystick.
  • The product specifications don’t include comparable noise measurements for the stick.

Nacon

The PlayStation version of the Daija is a larger, wired option worth comparing if you’re looking for customisation options.

  • Nacon specifies SANWA components, configuration software and a 3-metre cable for the PlayStation version.
  • This version is wired; don’t confuse it with the separate Xbox version. The listed components aren’t automatically dampened OBSFS buttons.

Qanba

The Drone 2 and separate Gravity KS replacement buttons are worth comparing if compatibility or button dampening matters to you.

  • Qanba specifies B30 buttons and an OV7 joystick for the Drone 2.
  • The silicone dampening described is for Gravity KS buttons, not a feature of every Qanba stick. Check that the buttons fit your model.

Joybuy products

Related products coming soon.

Frequently asked questions

Does a wireless arcade stick make less noise?

Not necessarily: Bluetooth or 2.4 GHz changes the connection, but doesn’t tell you how much mechanical noise the buttons make. SANWA describes dampening for OBSFS buttons; check that they fit your stick.

How can I check whether a stick works with my retro game?

First check that the exact model works with your console or PC and which input mode the game requires. According to 8BitDo, the Arcade Stick supports Switch and Windows, but doesn’t connect directly to PS4, PS5 or Xbox. MAYFLASH says the F300 supports XInput and DInput on PC; some console connections come with additional requirements.

Can I make the buttons quieter later?

That may be possible with a stick that has compatible replaceable buttons. MAYFLASH says the F300 supports SANWA components, and SANWA describes dampening for OBSFS buttons. Before buying, check the size, fittings and space inside the casing; this won’t automatically make the whole stick quiet.

What are my rights when buying an arcade stick online in the Netherlands?

According to ACM ConsuWijzer, for a standard online product purchase you generally have a statutory cooling-off period of up to 14 days after delivery, although exceptions may apply. Your statutory guarantee is separate from any manufacturer’s warranty: if a product doesn’t perform as you could reasonably expect under normal use, the seller is responsible for providing an appropriate solution.