Who is this relevant to?

Players with limited desk space

If you use the same desk for studying and gaming, check that the controller fits while leaving room for your hands and the cable. HORI and 8BitDo list dimensions for their models.

Players with a dedicated console

Before buying, check that the exact version works with your PS5, Xbox or Switch. 8BitDo and Razer specifications vary by model; PlayStation Support also explains the requirements for specialist peripherals.

Players considering a different control method

Consider the physical joystick versus separate directional buttons, and whether a different hand position might take some getting used to. HORI, 8BitDo and Razer offer different types of controls.

What should you look for when choosing?

First check compatibility with your system and game, then compare the controls and the space needed for the complete setup.

What to consider What to look for Who might prioritise this?
Platform compatibility Check the full model name and the supported PC or console version; if you’re using an adapter, check that the combination is supported too. I want the controller to work with my system and game before considering the control method. Around 31% of consumers prioritise compatibility.
Playing space and storage Compare the case’s width and depth with the space available, and allow room for your hands, the cable and joystick movement. I also use my desk for studying and want to be able to set the controller up and put it away without overlooking the space needed to play. Around 31% of consumers prioritise space.
Joystick or directional buttons Decide which input method you want to use and whether the hand position suits your playing style; if you’re playing in a tournament, check its rules. I want to choose between the familiar movement of a joystick and separate directional buttons, while bearing in mind that the latter may take some getting used to. Around 25% of consumers prioritise the control method.
Customisation and maintenance Check whether parts are accessible or replaceable, and whether your system requires a separate adapter. I want to know in advance whether I can customise parts and which connection my system needs. Around 13% of consumers prioritise customisation and maintenance.

Buying pitfalls

  • Assuming similar model names mean the same version

    Arcade controllers with similar names may be designed for different platforms. For example, HORI lists a Fighting Stick Mini for PS5, PS4 and Windows, while 8BitDo specifies different platforms for different versions.

    Compare the full model name and the compatibility list for the version you want to buy with your own system.

    An incompatible version may be unusable; some connection options may require a separate adapter.

  • Measuring only the case

    The controller needs to fit with room for your hands, the cable and, with a stick, joystick movement. A flat case isn’t necessarily narrow, either.

    Clear the space where you plan to use it and consider the complete setup, not just the product photo.

  • Assuming it will work with PS5 or that a simple firmware update will do the trick

    MAYFLASH’s firmware information for the F500 V2 specifies a particular MagicBoots-S5 adapter and an update via a Windows PC.

    Before buying, check which combination of stick, adapter and firmware you need for your setup.

Brands to consider

HORI

The models described range from a compact stick for PS5, PS4 and Windows to a larger Fighting Stick α with access to its components.

  • For the Fighting Stick Mini reviewed, HORI lists a joystick and a size of around 8 × 6 inch.
  • The Fighting Stick Mini and Fighting Stick α are different models; compare the full model name with your system and playing space.

8BitDo

The range includes the Arcade Controller with directional buttons for Switch and Windows, and a separate Arcade Stick for Xbox and Windows.

  • For the Arcade Controller reviewed, 8BitDo lists dimensions of 301 × 201 × 22 mm.
  • The Switch and Windows version is not the same as the Xbox version; an Xbox listing does not confirm PS5 support.

Razer

The Kitsune is a flat leverless controller for PS5 and PC, with directional buttons instead of a joystick.

  • Razer describes the Kitsune as having a detachable USB-C cable, a cable lock and configurable SOCD functions.
  • The different hand position may take some getting used to. If you’re playing in a tournament, check the rules for that specific event.

MAYFLASH

The F500 V2 is a larger arcade stick for a dedicated playing space, and you’ll need to check how it connects to your system.

  • MAYFLASH lists XINPUT and DINPUT modes for PC use.
  • The PS5 firmware information specifies the MagicBoots-S5 adapter. Compare the dimensions of the exact version on offer.

Joybuy products

Related products coming soon.

Frequently asked questions

Will every PS4 arcade stick work with a PS5 fighting game?

No, don’t assume it will. PlayStation Support says officially licensed specialist peripherals, including arcade sticks, are supported with PS5 games and supported PS4 games. Also check the specific stick, game and any adapter requirements.

How do I fit a controller on a small desk?

Measure the available width and depth, leaving room for your hands, the cable and any joystick movement. For the Fighting Stick Mini reviewed, HORI lists dimensions of around 8 × 6 inch; for the Arcade Controller reviewed, 8BitDo lists a top-down footprint of 301 × 201 mm.

Can I customise buttons or parts later?

It depends on the model. HORI says the Fighting Stick α has a case that opens for customisation and maintenance; 8BitDo lists a hot-swappable circuit board for the Arcade Controller. Check which parts are available for the version you choose.

When buying online in the Netherlands, am I always entitled to an exact two-year warranty?

No, there is no fixed statutory warranty period in the Netherlands. According to the Dutch government, your right to a product that works properly depends, among other things, on the product and what you can expect from it under normal use.