Who is this for?

Player with a small desk

Wants to put their controller away after playing, so pays attention to its dimensions, room for their hands and space for the cable. HORI lists the Fighting Stick Mini at around 8 × 6 inches, while 8BitDo gives the Arcade Controller a footprint of 301 × 201 mm.

Player on PC or console

Wants to check in advance that the exact version and input mode work with their system and game. HORI describes separate Fighting Stick Mini versions for Switch and for PlayStation and Windows; MAYFLASH lists XINPUT and DINPUT for the F300 on PC.

Player in a shared room

Bears in mind that buttons and joysticks can make noise, without assuming that a controller is silent. QANBA describes certain Q8 components as quiet, but this product description isn’t an independent sound measurement.

What should you look for?

First, check that the exact version and input mode work with your system and game. Then measure the space available for playing and decide whether you want a joystick or separate directional buttons.

What to consider What to look for Who it matters to
Platform and game Check the full model version, the platform it’s listed for and the input mode your game accepts. Some console connections may require extra steps or accessories. If I play on PC or console, I want to know whether this particular version works with my system and game; around 33% of consumers focus mainly on compatibility.
Desk space and storage Compare the width and depth with the space available, leaving room for your hands and the cable. Even a low-profile casing can take up a sizeable area of your desk. With a small desk, I want to use my controller without having to move my other belongings; around 27% of consumers prioritise space and storage.
Noise during use Check which joystick and button components are included in the version you’re considering. If possible, assess the noise in a similar environment. In a shared room, I want to be considerate of my housemates, but I wouldn’t rely on a ‘quiet’ product name as a sound measurement; around 20% of consumers put this first.
Control type Choose between a physical joystick and separate directional buttons. Also check whether the game supports your preferred controls and any button mapping. For a shoot-’em-up, I first want to know which control style suits my preferences; around 20% of consumers focus mainly on the type of controls.

Common pitfalls

  • Assuming compatibility applies to every version

    HORI’s Fighting Stick Mini versions have different lists of compatible platforms. Some console connections for the MAYFLASH F300 may require extra steps.

    Before buying, compare the full model name, platform and input mode. Also check whether you need any accessories for your system.

  • Assuming ‘compact’ or ‘low-profile’ means it’ll fit your desk

    A low-profile controller can still take up a lot of space, while even a small joystick needs room for your hands and cable.

    Measure the space where you’ll actually play, allowing room to move your hands around, not just space to store the controller.

  • Taking ‘quiet’ to mean proven silent operation

    QANBA describes certain Q8 components as quiet, but that label doesn’t tell you how much noise your housemates will hear in your room.

    Check the components in the exact version you’re considering and, if possible, assess the noise in a similar environment.

Brands to compare

HORI

Fighting Stick Mini versions for anyone looking for a physical joystick in a compact casing.

  • HORI lists the Mini versions at around 8 × 6 inches and with a wired connection.
  • The Switch version and the PlayStation and Windows version are separate products; check the platform list for the exact model.

8BitDo

Offers both an arcade stick and a controller with separate directional buttons for the listed Switch and Windows systems.

  • The manufacturer lists different connection options and button-mapping features for its products.
  • The models vary in size and controls; the specifications of one model don’t automatically apply to another.

MAYFLASH

The F300 is a wired arcade stick worth comparing if input modes and customisable components matter to you.

  • MAYFLASH lists XINPUT and DINPUT for use on PC, as well as support for compatible Sanwa components.
  • Some consoles may require extra connection steps; check the firmware and whether any accessories are needed.

QANBA

The Q8 is worth considering if you play on PC and are looking for a joystick offered with components described as quiet.

  • According to QANBA, the Q8 has a Gravity joystick and Gravity KS buttons, which the brand describes as quiet.
  • That description isn’t an independent measurement of noise in a room; QANBA also offers the option of traditional Sanwa components.

Joybuy products

Related products will be available soon.

Frequently asked questions

Will every HORI Fighting Stick Mini work with my console?

No, compatible platforms vary by version. HORI describes a Switch version that also works with PC, and a separate version for PS5, PS4 and Windows 11/10. Before buying, check the full model name and list of compatible platforms.

How do I connect the MAYFLASH F300?

Follow the instructions for your system and, on PC, choose the input mode your game accepts; MAYFLASH lists XINPUT and DINPUT for PC. For PS5 use with MagicBoots-S5, MAYFLASH specifies a compatible stick and up-to-date firmware. Check which connection steps and accessories apply to your console.

Can I return a controller I bought online in the Netherlands?

For online purchases, you generally have a statutory cooling-off period of up to 14 days after delivery, according to ACM ConsuWijzer. Check whether a statutory exception applies to your purchase and which returns policy applies to your order.

Do I need an extended warranty if the buttons stop working early?

Not necessarily: an extended warranty doesn’t replace your statutory guarantee. ACM ConsuWijzer explains that with normal use, you’re entitled to a product that meets the standards you could reasonably expect; if a product is faulty, the seller must offer a solution under the applicable terms.