Who is this choice relevant to?

Players who want a joystick

You want a physical stick with separate action buttons for shoot-'em-ups, and need a model that works with your system. 8BitDo, HORI, MAYFLASH and Qanba all describe specific joystick models.

Players who want directional buttons

You want to control movement with individual buttons and are happy to get used to a different layout and check the input settings. Hit Box Arcade describes a PC controller with separate directional buttons.

Players who play in daylight

You want to be able to make out the buttons and the game on screen in a bright room. Assess screen reflections separately from how easy the controller controls are to see.

What should you consider when choosing?

Joystick with action buttons

Choose this if: you prefer to control movement with a stick and use separate action buttons.

Trade-off: the brand name alone doesn’t tell you whether a particular model works with your console or PC.

Separate directional buttons

Choose this if: you want to use four separate directional buttons instead of a stick.

Trade-off: you may need time to get used to the layout and should check how the game handles opposing directional inputs.

What to consider What should you check? Who is this for?
Controls Choose a joystick with action buttons or separate directional buttons, and check the layout of the exact model. If I prefer to play shoot-'em-ups with a stick or separate directional buttons, I want to choose controls that suit me. Controls are the main priority for around 33% of consumers.
Platform and game Check the full model name, supported system, connection method and the input your game requires. If I play on a specific system, I want to make sure that both the controller and the input settings work with my game. Compatibility is the main priority for around 33% of consumers.
Visibility Check that you can distinguish the buttons in your lighting conditions, and assess screen reflections separately. If I play in a bright room, I want to be able to recognise the controls without expecting the controller to eliminate screen reflections. Daylight visibility is the main priority for around 17% of consumers.
Positioning and connection Compare the size with the space available and check where cables or other connection equipment are needed. If I have limited space where I play, I want to know whether the controller will fit and how to connect it. Setup is the main priority for around 17% of consumers.

Common buying mistakes

  • Assuming every arcade stick from a brand works with the same console

    Supported systems vary by model. For certain F300 console connections, MAYFLASH also states that a wired controller must be connected.

    Before buying, check the full model name, your platform and the manufacturer’s connection instructions.

    You may also need to connect a wired controller for some connections.

  • Buying a different controller to fix screen reflections

    Reflections depend on the screen and lighting, not on whether you choose a joystick or directional buttons. LG Electronics describes anti-reflective features on specific screens.

    Assess the screen’s position and the lighting separately; choose your controller based on its controls, button visibility and compatibility.

  • Treating a joystick-free controller as a joystick with a different shape

    A controller with separate directional buttons requires a different approach. Hit Box Arcade also describes different ways of handling simultaneous opposing directions.

    Check the available settings and how your game responds to opposing inputs before choosing this layout.

Brands to consider

8BitDo

According to 8BitDo, the standard 8BitDo Arcade Stick is designed for supported Switch and Windows systems, with wired USB-C, 2.4GHz and Bluetooth connections.

  • 8BitDo lists customisable button mapping and profiles for this model.
  • Don’t assume this platform information applies to other models, such as an Xbox model, or to PS5.

HORI

The Fighting Stick Mini for Nintendo Switch is a compact, wired stick with a joystick and eight action buttons.

  • HORI also lists PC compatibility, turbo and rubber feet for this specific model.
  • Check the model number: another Fighting Stick Mini may be designed for a different platform.

MAYFLASH

The MAYFLASH F300 is a joystick controller that the manufacturer lists as supporting several systems and PC input modes.

  • MAYFLASH says the F300 can be customised with compatible Sanwa parts.
  • For certain PS4 and Xbox connections, MAYFLASH says a wired controller must be connected; check the requirements for your system.

Qanba

Qanba lists the Drone 2 as compatible with PS5, PS4 and PC.

  • Qanba lists a platform switch and touchpad for this model.
  • These specifications don’t confirm support for Switch or other Qanba models.

Hit Box Arcade

According to Hit Box Arcade, the PC Hit Box uses separate directional buttons instead of a joystick and is listed as compatible with PC.

  • Hit Box Arcade describes several settings for simultaneous opposing directional inputs.
  • The layout takes some getting used to; the PC specification alone doesn’t confirm direct compatibility with consoles.

Joybuy products

Related products coming soon.

Frequently asked questions

For shoot-'em-ups, should I choose a joystick or a controller with directional buttons?

Choose the controls you want to use and check your game’s input settings. The PC Hit Box uses separate directional buttons and, according to Hit Box Arcade, has settings for opposing directional inputs; the stick models mentioned use a joystick. This doesn’t prove that either option has a general performance advantage.

What should I check when connecting and setting up a controller?

Check the exact model, the system it supports and the required mode. For the F300, MAYFLASH lists XInput/DInput, among other features, and a choice between D-pad and analogue-axis output. For certain PS4 and Xbox connections, MAYFLASH also states that a wired controller must be connected.

Will a different arcade controller help if sunlight falls on my screen?

A different controller won’t eliminate screen reflections. LG Electronics describes anti-reflective features on specific screens, so assess the screen and lighting separately from how easy the controller buttons are to see.

What are my rights when buying online or if a product is faulty in the Netherlands?

For an online consumer purchase covered by the rules on distance selling, the Dutch government generally provides a 14-day cooling-off period. If a product is faulty, contact the seller about your statutory guarantee; the Netherlands does not have a fixed statutory guarantee period of two years.