First, choose a controller that your platform and game recognise, and that lets you comfortably operate the shoot, focus and bomb buttons. If keeping noise down is a priority, compare both the buttons and the joystick: a manufacturer's claim that certain components are quiet doesn't prove that the whole controller will be quiet enough for a shared bedroom. A compact or flat model may be easier to put away, but it could also change how you control the game.
Who is this choice relevant to?
Playing while your roommate is resting
You want to keep the sound of button presses to a minimum, so you're looking at both the buttons and the joystick. Qanba describes some of the Q8's components as quiet, but that isn't a sound measurement taken in your room.
Tailoring the controls to your shoot-'em-up
You want to comfortably control direction, shoot, focus and bomb. The best layout depends partly on the game and your preferences; 8BitDo lists button mapping for the Arcade Stick and programmable buttons for the Arcade Controller.
Putting a controller away in a small space
You want to put the controller away after playing, so you're considering its dimensions and any protruding parts. HORI lists the Fighting Stick Mini at approximately 21 × 15 × 8,7 cm; its compact size alone says nothing about compatibility or noise.
What should you look for when buying?
Joystick with components described as quiet
A good fit if: you want traditional stick controls and noise from both the buttons and joystick matters to you.
Bear in mind: Qanba describes the Q8 as PC-compatible and its joystick and buttons as quiet; there is no independent sound measurement for use in a shared bedroom.
Customisable traditional joystick
A good fit if: you want a joystick and the option to customise the button layout or components. 8BitDo lists Switch and Windows support for the Arcade Stick; Mayflash lists Sanwa components for the F500 Elite.
Bear in mind: the specifications listed don't show that these controllers are quiet out of the box; check that your game and platform are supported.
Flat, button-only controller
A good fit if: you want a flat model that's easy to store and prefer separate directional buttons.
Bear in mind: it feels different to use than a joystick. For the Mayflash F500 FLAT Elite, Mayflash describes PS5 support with a separately sold converter for fighting games only; this doesn't confirm support for PS5 shoot-'em-ups.
Compact joystick controller
A good fit if: storage space is your main concern and you play on a supported PlayStation system or Windows PC.
Bear in mind: HORI lists XInput games for Windows; the small size doesn't prove that the buttons or joystick are quiet.
In a shared bedroom, noise, game controls, platform recognition and storage space may each be a different priority.
| What to consider |
What should you check? |
Who is this most important to? |
| Noise from the buttons and joystick |
Check which components are included in the exact version and whether any dampening pads fit the button size. |
If I'm playing while someone next to me is resting, I want to reduce noise from both the buttons and joystick; around 33% of consumers make noise reduction their top priority. |
| Direction and game buttons |
Check which functions your game uses and whether you can change the layout; try the directional controls if possible. |
If I want quick access to shoot, focus and bomb, I mainly look for a layout that suits my game; around 27% of consumers put game controls first. |
| Platform and game |
Check the exact model, the supported input mode and whether you need an extra controller or converter. |
If I want to make sure my controller works with my own game and system, I check compatibility for each combination; around 20% of consumers make platform recognition their main concern. |
| Storage space |
Compare the dimensions, including the protruding joystick, and consider where the controller and cable will go after playing. |
If I want to put my controller away in a small bedroom after playing, size and shape matter most to me; around 20% of consumers make storage space their top priority. |
Pitfalls to avoid when buying an arcade controller
-
Taking ‘quiet buttons’ as proof that the whole controller is quiet
Buttons and joysticks are separate sources of noise. Qanba describes some of the Q8's components as quiet, but that doesn't tell you how loud the controller will be in your bedroom.
Check the exact version and assess both the buttons and joystick before relying on a quietness claim.
Some Mayflash connections may require a wired extra controller or a converter sold separately.
-
Looking only at the footprint
A joystick protrudes above the control panel, while a flat model changes how you use the directional controls. Comparing only width and depth therefore won't give you the full picture of storage or use.
Check the height too, and consider how much room your hands and cable will need.
-
Confusing the manufacturer's warranty with your full statutory protection
The Government of the Netherlands says there is no fixed statutory warranty period in the Netherlands. If a product is faulty, you should contact the seller; what you can expect from a product depends partly on the product and the circumstances.
Check what an additional warranty covers and keep the information provided by the seller.
Brands to compare
Qanba
The Q8 is a PC option with traditional joystick controls and Gravity components that Qanba describes as quiet.
- Qanba describes both the Gravity joystick and Gravity KS buttons as quiet.
- These manufacturer's claims aren't an independent sound measurement for use in a shared bedroom. The compatibility listed is for PC.
8BitDo
Offers an Arcade Stick with a joystick and a flat Arcade Controller with separate directional buttons; 8BitDo lists support for Switch and Windows for both.
- The Arcade Stick offers button mapping; according to 8BitDo, the Arcade Controller has programmable buttons.
- The two control styles are different, and the features listed don't prove a noise advantage.
Mayflash
The F500 Elite has a traditional joystick; the F500 FLAT Elite uses buttons only. Compare the exact version.
- Mayflash lists Sanwa components for both models.
- Additional connection requirements apply for certain consoles. The PS5 support described for the F500 FLAT Elite with a converter is limited to fighting games; quiet operation out of the box hasn't been confirmed.
HORI
The Fighting Stick Mini SPF-038 is a compact joystick controller for the PlayStation systems and Windows PC listed by HORI.
- HORI lists dimensions of approximately 21 × 15 × 8,7 cm.
- For Windows, HORI lists XInput games. Its size doesn't support a claim that the buttons or joystick are quiet.
Joybuy products for this choice
Related products coming soon.
Frequently asked questions
Is a button-only controller automatically better for shoot-'em-ups?
No. A button-only controller replaces joystick movement with separate directional buttons; try them out to see whether the layout suits your game and hands. The 8BitDo Arcade Controller product description confirms its control style, not a general performance advantage for shoot-'em-ups.
Can I connect a Mayflash F500 FLAT Elite directly to my console?
Not with every system mentioned, without meeting additional requirements. According to Mayflash, you need to connect a wired controller to the F500 FLAT Elite for PS4 and the Xbox systems listed. For PS5, Mayflash describes a converter sold separately and limits support to fighting games; check separately whether your PS5 shoot-'em-up works.
Can I make a regular arcade controller quieter after buying it?
That depends on the model and its components. Focus Attack LLC describes dampening pads for specific 30 mm Sanwa and Seimitsu buttons; installation requires care around the wiring and mounting tabs. This won't automatically dampen the joystick as well.
What are my rights if an arcade controller bought online isn't suitable or develops a fault?
For an online purchase from a trader, you generally have a 14-day right to withdraw, starting from delivery; check which exceptions and return costs disclosed in advance apply. If a product is faulty, you can contact the seller. The Government of the Netherlands says there is no fixed statutory warranty period in the Netherlands: what you can expect from a product depends on the product and the circumstances.