Who is this guide for?

Quiet PC player

You play while someone else in the same room is resting or asleep, and want to keep noise from the stick and buttons to a minimum. Qanba describes parts of the Q8 as silent, but this isn’t an independent measurement of how much noise it makes in a bedroom.

Retro player on Switch or PC

You want a traditional stick and check in advance that the version, connection and game you choose are compatible with your Switch or PC. 8BitDo and HORI list specific product and platform requirements for their sticks.

Player with limited desk space

You share a desk and want to know how much room the controller takes up. HORI lists a footprint of around 210 × 150 mm for the Fighting Stick mini for Nintendo Switch; its compact size doesn’t mean it operates more quietly.

What should you look for when buying?

First, check that the controller works with your platform and game. Then compare the noise it makes, the desk space it needs and whether you prefer a stick or button-only controls.

What to consider What to check Who should consider this?
Operating noise Check whether both the stick and buttons are described as silent for the exact version you’re considering. A button-only controller still makes noise when you press the buttons. If I play while someone else in the room is resting, I want to know whether both controls make noise. Around 33% of consumers prioritise keeping operating noise down.
Platform and game Check the full product version, platform and game, and whether you need an additional controller or converter. I don’t want to buy a stick that doesn’t work with my platform or the game I play. Around 27% of consumers give platform and game compatibility top priority.
Desk space Compare the stated dimensions of the exact model, and allow space for the stick and cable. If I share a desk, I want to be able to set the controller up and put it away without taking up more space than necessary. Around 20% of consumers prioritise the space available.
Control style Choose between a traditional stick and button-only directional input. Don’t assume either offers a proven noise or performance advantage. I want to know whether I’d rather play with a stick or get used to a button-only layout. Around 20% of consumers base their choice mainly on the control style.

Common buying mistakes

  • Taking ‘silent’ to mean ‘inaudible’

    A description of silent components doesn’t tell you how much noise the complete controller makes while you’re playing in a shared bedroom.

    Check whether the manufacturer is referring to both the stick and buttons on the exact version. Treat the description as a guide to help you choose, not a guarantee that the controller will be silent.

  • Assuming ‘multi-platform’ means it works straight away with every console and game

    The connection required can vary by console. Mayflash limits the PS5 support listed on its product page to fighting games, which doesn’t automatically mean every retro beat ’em up will work.

    Before you buy, check the exact game, console and connections required.

    Some Mayflash console connections require an additional wired controller. For the PS5 setup mentioned, Mayflash requires a converter, sold separately.

  • Assuming a small casing means a quiet one

    The dimensions of the HORI Fighting Stick mini tell you how much space it takes up, not how noisy it is in use.

    Compare desk space and noise as separate considerations, and check the dimensions of the exact version.

  • Assuming every online return is free

    The cooling-off rules for an online purchase aren’t the same as your rights if a product is faulty.

    Read the returns information in advance, and distinguish between changing your mind about a purchase and making a complaint about a faulty product.

Brands to compare

Qanba

The Q8 is worth considering if you play on PC, want a traditional stick and are mindful of noise.

  • Qanba lists a Gravity Silent stick and Gravity KS Silent buttons for the Q8.
  • These are the manufacturer’s descriptions, not the results of an independent noise test. Check the version and don’t assume it’s compatible with other platforms.

8BitDo

Offers separate sticks for Switch and Windows, and for Xbox and Windows. Check which product range suits your platform.

  • According to 8BitDo, the standard Arcade Stick has Bluetooth, 2.4 GHz and USB-C. The separate Arcade Stick for Xbox has 2.4 GHz and USB-C.
  • The connection options and supported platforms aren’t the same. The manufacturer doesn’t describe these models as silent.

HORI

The Fighting Stick mini for Nintendo Switch is a wired option if you’re short on desk space.

  • HORI lists dimensions of around 210 × 150 mm, eight buttons and PC support for XInput games on Windows 10/11.
  • HORI excludes DirectInput games from its stated PC support and doesn’t claim on the product page that the controller operates silently.

Mayflash

The F500 FLAT Elite is an option if you want button-only directional input.

  • The controller has a stick-free layout; check whether this way of playing suits you.
  • Mayflash lists an additional wired controller for PS4 and Xbox. The PS5 setup mentioned requires a converter, sold separately, and is limited to fighting games according to the product page.

Joybuy products

Related products coming soon.

Frequently asked questions

Is the standard 8BitDo Arcade Stick the same as the Xbox version?

No, they’re separate versions. 8BitDo lists the standard Arcade Stick for Switch and Windows, with Bluetooth, 2.4 GHz and USB-C; the Arcade Stick for Xbox is designed for Xbox Series X|S, Xbox One and Windows, and has 2.4 GHz and USB-C. Check the full product name and support for your game.

What do I need to connect a Mayflash F500 FLAT Elite to a console?

According to Mayflash, the PS4 and Xbox connections mentioned require a wired console controller. For the PS5 setup described, Mayflash lists a converter, sold separately, and support for fighting games. So check whether your specific beat ’em up will work.

Can I test the noise claim at home after buying online?

A description such as ‘silent’ doesn’t guarantee that your roommate won’t hear the controller. ACM ConsuWijzer states that the cooling-off period ends 14 days after the product is delivered; check in advance whether the rules apply to your purchase and read the returns information.

What can I do if the controller turns out to be faulty under normal use?

In the Netherlands, you can claim your statutory guarantee from the seller. The Rijksoverheid states that there is no fixed statutory guarantee period for all products; what you can reasonably expect from a product depends partly on the circumstances.

Are replacement buttons automatically compatible with my arcade controller?

No, don’t assume they are. 8BitDo and Mayflash describe the models mentioned as customisable, but that doesn’t confirm that any replacement part will fit. Check the manual for the exact version, as well as the part’s size and connection.