Who is this for?

Player with a dedicated console

You want an arcade stick that works with your Switch, PlayStation, Xbox or PC. Check the platform list for the exact version you’re considering: 8BitDo and HORI both describe separate models for different systems.

Fan of classic arcade controls

You’re looking for a traditional joystick with action buttons and want to weigh up that layout against an all-button design. HORI describes the Fighting Stick Mini as having a joystick and eight action buttons; 8BitDo also offers an all-button version.

Player with bright light and limited space

You want a controller that’s easy to position or put away without taking up too much room. Consider screen reflections separately: BenQ describes incoming light and reflections as possible causes of glare on a screen.

What should you look for?

Classic arcade stick

Choose this option: if you want to play with a traditional joystick and arcade-style buttons, and have enough room for the stick.

Bear in mind: models vary by platform, and some console connections may require extra setup.

Compact arcade stick

Choose this option: if you want a joystick and eight action buttons in a smaller housing. HORI makes separate Fighting Stick Mini versions for Switch and for PlayStation and Windows.

Bear in mind: the HORI versions described are wired; according to HORI, the PlayStation version has no touchpad.

All-button controller

Choose this option: if you specifically want to use directional buttons rather than a joystick. According to the manufacturer, the 8BitDo Arcade Controller is designed for Switch and Windows.

Bear in mind: this is a different layout, not a proven advantage for every retro game. Check that it suits the game’s controls.

What to consider What should you check? Who should prioritise this?
System and game Check the full model name, system, game version and any required adapter, controller or firmware. If I mainly want the controller to work with my system and game, that combination comes first. Around 33% of consumers say compatibility with their system and game is their top purchase priority.
Joystick or buttons Check the layout of the directional controls and action buttons, and find out which inputs the game supports. If I’m looking for classic arcade controls, I focus on the physical joystick and the position of the action buttons. Around 27% of consumers give joystick controls top priority.
Light and visibility Assess how easy the controls are to see separately from reflections on the screen. If I play in a bright room, I want to use the controller easily and deal with screen reflections separately. Around 20% of consumers prioritise visibility in bright light.
Space and cables Measure the space available and check the dimensions, cable and any wireless connection options for the exact version. If I have limited space or want to put the controller away, its size and cable routing are decisive. Around 13% of consumers give space and cables top priority.
Customisation and maintenance Check that button mapping, firmware and any replacement parts you want are compatible with the version you’ve chosen. If I want to customise buttons or replace parts, I check what’s possible with the specific model. Around 7% of consumers prioritise customisation.

Avoiding common buying mistakes

  • Assuming different platform versions are the same model

    A product range can include versions for different systems. The model name alone doesn’t tell you whether the controller will work with your console.

    Before buying, compare the full model name with the platform list for the version you’re considering.

  • Assuming a broad compatibility list means you can connect without extra steps

    Mayflash specifies additional requirements for some console connections. For the PS5 setup described for the F500 V2, the manufacturer lists a MagicBoots-S5 adapter and compatible firmware.

    Check the connection instructions for your exact console and firmware version.

  • Expecting a different controller to fix screen reflections

    The button layout won’t change where light falls on the screen. Reflections are also affected by the light source and the position of the screen.

    First, look at the position of the light and screen; then choose a controller based on its controls and compatibility.

Brands to compare

8BitDo

The range includes arcade sticks for different platforms and an all-button controller. These versions aren’t interchangeable.

  • The manufacturer says that specific models have customisable buttons.
  • The all-button version has no joystick. Check platform support for the exact model.

HORI

The Fighting Stick Mini is available in separate versions for Switch and for PS5, PS4 and Windows.

  • HORI lists a joystick, eight action buttons and a wired connection for the versions described.
  • According to HORI, the PlayStation version has no touchpad. Check the version and the controls required by your game.

Mayflash

According to Mayflash, the F500 V2 is an arcade stick that supports several systems and has switchable input modes.

  • Its broad platform list may be useful if you’re comparing options for different systems.
  • Some console connections have additional requirements. According to Mayflash, the PS5 setup described requires a MagicBoots-S5 adapter and compatible firmware.

Qanba

Qanba describes the Drone 2 as an officially licensed stick for PS5, PS4 and PC.

  • The manufacturer lists features including a platform switch and touchpad.
  • These specifications apply to the Drone 2 and don’t necessarily apply to other Qanba sticks.

Joybuy products

Related products coming soon.

Frequently asked questions

Will a different controller make the picture easier to see in a bright room?

Not if the problem is reflections on the screen. Check where the light is coming from and how the screen is positioned; assess how easy the controller is to see separately.

Can I connect any arcade stick straight to a PS5?

No, it depends on the exact version and connection requirements. HORI specifies PS5 compatibility for the relevant Fighting Stick Mini; for the Mayflash F500 V2 described, Mayflash lists a PS5 setup that requires a specific adapter and firmware.

How do I connect the 8BitDo Arcade Controller to a Switch using a cable?

According to the manual, set the mode switch to S, enable ‘Pro Controller Wired Communication’ on the Switch and connect the controller via USB. These steps apply to the Arcade Controller and not automatically to every 8BitDo stick.

What if a controller I bought online isn’t suitable or breaks too soon?

For a standard online purchase in the Netherlands, you’ll generally have a statutory 14-day cooling-off period after delivery; check whether an exception applies. This is separate from your rights against the seller if a product doesn’t meet the standard you could reasonably expect when used normally.

Does a CE logo on a controller automatically prove it has been independently approved?

No. The European Union explains that CE marking applies when relevant harmonised rules require it, and that the manufacturer is responsible for the product’s conformity and marking. There is no central EU body that routinely issues a certificate for this; the rules that apply depend on the product.