Who is this guide for?

Players of classic games that rely on directional input

You want to know which joystick directions suit your puzzle game and are considering a mechanically switchable restrictor. Ultimarc describes the Mag-Stik Plus as switchable between 4 and 8 directions.

Players on Switch or PC

You’re looking for a complete controller without having to build an arcade panel yourself. Check the full model name and choose the version that suits your system; 8BitDo and HORI describe different options for Switch and PC.

Players in a bright room

You play on an existing screen where incoming light or reflections can interfere with the picture. As well as choosing your controller, consider the light in the room and where you place the screen.

What should you look for when choosing?

Start with the directions your game uses, then check the platform and connection requirements. Assess screen visibility separately from the controller.

Separate, switchable joystick

Choose this if: you’re building or adapting an arcade panel and want to switch between 4-way and 8-way control.

Bear in mind: the Ultimarc Mag-Stik Plus is a joystick component, not a complete plug-and-play controller; you’ll need to arrange the installation and connection yourself.

Complete stick for Switch or Windows

Choose this if: you want to play on a supported Switch or Windows PC without building a panel; 8BitDo and HORI describe complete options for these systems.

Bear in mind: the 8BitDo Arcade Stick for Switch and Windows is a different version from the Xbox model; the HORI Fighting Stick Mini for Switch is wired.

Complete stick for other platforms

Choose this if: you need a version for another system and want to compare the connection requirements of options such as the MAYFLASH F500 Elite or the Nacon Daija.

Bear in mind: platform listings don’t guarantee that every game will work; also check the connection requirements and the exact joystick restrictor setting.

What to consider What to check before buying Who should consider this?
Directions and joystick Check which directions your game uses and whether the joystick can be switched mechanically. Ultimarc describes this feature for the separate Mag-Stik Plus. If I want the right input for a puzzle game that relies on directional controls, I’ll focus on the joystick setting; around 36% of consumers give directional control top priority.
Compatibility with your platform Compare the full model name, system, connection type and game mode. 8BitDo describes separate Switch/Windows and Xbox versions. If I’m looking for a complete stick for my own PC or console, I want to know whether that specific version works with my game; around 29% of consumers say platform compatibility is their main consideration.
Screen visibility in daylight Assess reflections and the brightness of your existing screen in the place where you plan to use it. RTINGS describes incoming light and screen reflections as factors that affect how visible the picture is. If I play in bright daylight, I want to be able to see the puzzle clearly on my screen; around 21% of consumers put screen visibility first.
Positioning and connection Measure the available space and check the cable reach, receiver and included accessories for the exact version. HORI lists a wired connection and a size of approximately 8 × 6 inches for the Fighting Stick Mini. If space is limited or I’ll be connecting the stick in a fixed position, I want the size and connection to work for me; around 14% of consumers give positioning and connection top priority.

Things to consider before buying

  • Confusing the Switch/Windows version with the Xbox version

    8BitDo lists separate platform specifications for its Arcade Stick versions. So, even though the products have similar names, that doesn’t mean they support the same systems.

    Check the full model name and the system you’ll actually be playing the game on.

  • Mistaking a separate joystick for a complete controller

    The Ultimarc Mag-Stik Plus is a joystick component. If you’re using it in your own arcade panel, you’ll need to arrange the installation and connection separately.

    Choose a complete stick if you don’t want to build one yourself; only buy the separate component if you can handle the rest of the set-up.

    Building the panel and setting up the connection may require extra parts and time.

  • Buying a controller to fix screen reflections

    Reflections depend on your screen and the light sources in the room, not on the directional controls on your controller. RTINGS describes incoming light and reflection handling as factors that affect how visible the picture is.

    Assess your screen set-up separately before choosing a different controller.

Brands to consider

Ultimarc

The Mag-Stik Plus is a separate component for anyone building or adapting an arcade panel.

  • Ultimarc describes a mechanical switch from above between 4 and 8 directions.
  • The joystick isn’t a complete controller; you’ll need to arrange the installation and connection separately.

8BitDo

The Arcade Stick is available in separate versions for Switch/Windows and Xbox.

  • 8BitDo says the Switch/Windows version offers Bluetooth, 2.4 GHz and USB-C; the manufacturer lists 2.4 GHz and USB-C for the Xbox version.
  • The platform details for one version don’t automatically apply to the other; check your game’s requirements too.

HORI

The Fighting Stick Mini is a compact, wired stick for Switch.

  • HORI lists a joystick with microswitches, eight action buttons, rubber feet and PC compatibility.
  • Check that the compact size and wired connection suit your playing space; these features don’t prove that the stick is right for every puzzle game.

MAYFLASH

The F500 Elite is a complete stick with several platform options listed by the manufacturer.

  • MAYFLASH lists Sanwa components and compatibility with various platforms.
  • The product information mentions both a 4-way joystick and an included octagonal restrictor. Don’t assume which restrictor is fitted as standard; some connection options have additional requirements.

Nacon

The Daija PlayStation is a wired stick for PS5, PS4 or PC.

  • Nacon lists a Sanwa joystick and buttons, configurable keys and an included three-metre cable.
  • These are features of the PlayStation version, not proof that this controller is better than a simpler stick for classic puzzle games.

Joybuy products

Related products coming soon.

Frequently asked questions

Do I always need a 4-way joystick for classic puzzle games?

No, not as a general rule. Check which directions the specific game uses. Ultimarc describes the Mag-Stik Plus as switchable between 4 and 8 directions; it’s a separate joystick component.

How do I connect a wireless or wired stick?

Follow the instructions for the exact version and select the right system mode. 8BitDo says the Arcade Stick for Switch/Windows supports Bluetooth, 2.4 GHz with an included receiver, and USB-C; the HORI Fighting Stick Mini for Switch is wired. Also check your game’s input settings.

Do I need to maintain an arcade controller?

With intensive use, check that the buttons and joystick respond normally. Consult the instructions for the exact model before opening it or replacing parts. Ultimarc publishes information about switches and disassembly for the Mag-Stik Plus; those instructions don’t automatically apply to complete sticks from other brands.

Can an arcade controller help with daylight reflections?

No. Reflections depend on your screen and the light sources in the room. Assess the screen position and reflection handling separately from your choice of controller.

What return and warranty rights apply to online purchases in the Netherlands?

For a distance contract with a business, you usually have 14 days to change your mind, although there are some exceptions. You’re also entitled to a product that meets the required standards. According to the Rijksoverheid, the Netherlands has no fixed statutory warranty period; if something is faulty, contact the seller.