First, check which inputs your puzzle game actually accepts on your system. Confirm this for the exact game version before choosing a controller. A physical joystick needs room for the stick and your hands, while a flat controller with directional buttons offers a different way to play and still takes up desk space. The Dutch government says electronic devices placed on the EU market must carry CE marking, so check this for the exact version.
Who is an arcade controller suitable for?
Puzzle player with a dedicated PC or console
Wants to check first whether their game accepts the required movements and actions through the controller they choose. For example, The Tetris Company lists a keyboard and mouse for its official web version; that doesn’t tell you whether another game version supports a joystick.
Student with limited desk space
Compares the space needed for the controller, hands and cable. HORI lists the Switch Fighting Stick Mini as measuring around 8 × 6 inches; 8BitDo gives the flat Arcade Controller’s dimensions as 301 × 201 × 22 mm.
Player keen to try arcade-style controls
Wants to choose between a physical stick, separate directional buttons or a simple retro joystick. These input types and features are product specifications, not proof that a particular puzzle game will work with them.
What should you consider when choosing one?
First check the inputs supported by your game and system. Then compare the control type, available space and connections you need.
Joystick with a physical stick
Choose this if: you want to use joystick movements and have room for the stick, your hands and a cable.
Trade-off: even a compact model needs room to operate on your desk; also check the exact platform version.
Controller with directional buttons
Choose this if: you deliberately want to play without a physical stick and prefer separate directional buttons.
Trade-off: according to the manufacturer, the 8BitDo Arcade Controller measures 301 × 201 × 22 mm. So being flat doesn’t automatically mean it takes up little desk space.
| What to consider |
What to look for when buying |
Who is this important for? |
| Compatibility with the game and system |
For the exact game version and platform, check which directional and action inputs are available, then compare them with the model’s input modes. |
If I want to play my puzzle game on my own system, I want to know in advance whether all the necessary movements and actions will work. Around 36% of consumers say compatibility with the game and platform is their top priority. |
| Desk space |
Measure the available width and depth, and leave room for your hands and the cable. Compare the dimensions of the exact version. |
With limited desk space, I want to have room left over while using the controller. Around 29% of consumers put available desk space first. |
| Stick or directional buttons |
Compare the physical controls and check whether the game lets you assign the actions you need. MAYFLASH lists input modes; 8BitDo says the Arcade Stick has customisable button mapping. |
If I want to use a particular hand movement, I want to know whether a stick or separate directional buttons will suit me. Around 21% of consumers say feel is their main priority. |
| Connections and aftercare |
Check which cable or receiver is included and whether you need an extra wired controller for your console mode. |
I want to know in advance which connections I’ll need and where to go if something goes wrong. Around 14% of consumers prioritise connections and aftercare. |
Which buying mistakes can you avoid?
-
Assuming a controller that works with your system will work with your game
A system may recognise a controller without a particular game accepting all the inputs you need. The official Tetris web version reviewed lists a keyboard and mouse as its controls.
Check the input options for your exact game version before choosing a controller.
If the inputs aren’t suitable, the controller may not work for the game you have in mind; setting it up could also take extra time.
-
Assuming ‘mini’ or ‘flat’ means it will fit your desk
A flat controller still takes up width and depth; a mini stick also needs room for your hands and cable.
Measure the available space on your desk and compare it with the dimensions of the exact version.
-
Assuming a connection mode or almost identical model name means it’s the same product
MAYFLASH says that a wired controller must be connected for certain console modes on the F300. The 8BitDo Arcade Stick for Xbox has a different list of supported platforms from the Switch/Windows version.
Compare the full model name, supported platform and connection instructions from the manufacturer.
Depending on the console mode you choose, you may need an extra controller or cable.
-
Overlooking unclear CE information for the exact version
The Dutch government says electronic devices placed on the EU market must carry CE marking. The product information must relate to the version you intend to buy.
Before buying, check the applicable marking and product information for the exact version.
Which brands are worth considering?
HORI
The Fighting Stick Mini is worth considering if you want a physical joystick for a small desk.
- For the Switch version, HORI lists dimensions of around 8 × 6 inches, a cable and eight action buttons.
- The separately described PlayStation version supports different platforms. The ‘Mini’ name doesn’t make the versions interchangeable.
MAYFLASH
The F101 and F300 are wired joystick models you can compare for their different input modes.
- MAYFLASH says the F101 switches between directional-button and stick input; the F300 also offers input modes and lists more platforms.
- For certain F300 console modes, the manufacturer requires a wired controller to be connected. These features don’t prove that a particular game will work.
8BitDo
The brand describes both an Arcade Stick for Switch/Windows and a separate button-only model.
- 8BitDo says both models have configurable buttons and lists three connection methods for the Arcade Stick: Bluetooth, 2.4 GHz and USB-C.
- The Arcade Controller has no physical stick. The Xbox Arcade Stick is a separate version with a different list of supported platforms.
Speedlink
The COMPETITION PRO EXTRA is a simple retro USB joystick worth considering for compatible Windows systems.
- Speedlink lists DirectInput and four action buttons.
- The manufacturer describes the microswitches as audibly clicky. This doesn’t prove that the joystick will work with every puzzle game.
QANBA
The Drone 2 is especially worth considering if PlayStation support is a deciding factor.
- QANBA lists PS5, PS4 and PC support, and describes it as a wired joystick.
- Its listed dimensions are 356 × 221 × 116 mm, which could be an important consideration for a cramped desk. There’s no demonstrated benefit for puzzle games.
Related products
Related products coming soon.
Frequently asked questions
Does an arcade stick work automatically with every version of Tetris?
No, support varies by game version. The official web version reviewed lists a keyboard and mouse as its controls; check which inputs and button-mapping options are available for your version.
How do you connect the 8BitDo Arcade Stick to a Switch using a cable?
Follow the Switch instructions in the 8BitDo manual: turn on ‘Pro Controller Wired Communication’, select S mode and connect the USB-C cable to the Switch dock. The manual says this procedure requires Switch system version 3.0.0 or later.
What should you do if a retro joystick gets dirty or damaged?
In the COMPETITION PRO EXTRA manual, Speedlink advises you not to open the device and to stop using it if it’s damaged. If it develops a fault, also follow the retailer’s instructions on your statutory guarantee.
When buying online in the Netherlands, do you have a cooling-off period and a guarantee?
According to the Dutch government, when you buy online from a business, you generally have 14 days to change your mind, although exceptions apply. A product must meet legal requirements, but there’s no fixed statutory guarantee period; contact the retailer if you have a problem.
What legal requirements should you check for an electronic controller in the Netherlands?
The Dutch government says electronic devices placed on the EU market must carry CE marking. Check the applicable marking and product information for the exact version.