Who is this buying guide for?

Players with a range of retro games

If you switch between puzzle games on Windows, you’ll want to know whether the controller’s input mode matches what each game supports. MAYFLASH lists both XInput and DirectInput for the F101; HORI lists only XInput for the NSW-149 on Windows.

Players of four-way puzzle games

If your games require separate horizontal and vertical directions, it’s important to distinguish between an eight-way stick and one that is mechanically restricted to four directions. 8BitDo describes its Arcade Stick as an eight-way stick; Ultimarc describes mechanical switching between four-way and eight-way operation for its standalone Mag-Stik Plus.

Players short on desk space

If you need room for a keyboard, mouse or papers while working from home, compare the stated width and depth with the space you actually have available. HORI lists the NSW-149 at approximately 210 × 150 mm; 8BitDo lists the Arcade Stick at 303 × 203 mm.

What should you look for when choosing?

First, check the directions and input mode your game requires. Then compare the controller with your desk space and preferred connection.

What to consider What should you check? Who is this important for?
Compatibility Check your system, connection and the input mode used by the game, such as XInput or DirectInput. MAYFLASH lists both modes for the F101 on Windows; HORI lists XInput, but not DirectInput, for the NSW-149 on Windows. If I play different puzzle games on PC, I want to know whether each game recognises the controller input I’ve chosen. Around 36% of consumers rank compatibility as their main buying concern.
Directional control Check whether the game needs diagonal inputs and whether a stated four-way mode is mechanically restricted. An eight-way stick is not the same as a stick that can be mechanically switched to four-way operation. If my puzzle game only requires separate cardinal directions, I want to know how the stick physically restricts those movements. For around 29% of consumers, suitable directional control comes first.
Desk space Compare the width and depth with the space available, and allow room for your hands and the cable. HORI lists the NSW-149 at approximately 210 × 150 mm; 8BitDo lists the Arcade Stick at 303 × 203 mm. If I want to use or store the controller alongside my work essentials, the space it takes up matters. Around 21% of consumers prioritise desk space.
Connection and customisation Check the connection options for the exact model and whether the button mapping suits your game. According to 8BitDo, the Arcade Stick offers Bluetooth, 2.4 GHz and USB-C, and its buttons can be mapped using software. If I want to position the controller flexibly or customise its buttons, I want to know which connections and settings the model offers. Around 14% of consumers name connectivity and customisation as their main consideration.

Common buying mistakes

  • Assuming ‘works on PC’ means ‘works with every PC game’

    PC compatibility doesn’t automatically tell you which input mode a controller can use with a particular game. HORI lists XInput, but not DirectInput, for the NSW-149 on Windows; MAYFLASH lists both modes for the F101.

    Check the game’s input mode and the exact model variant before choosing.

  • Confusing a square or octagonal gate with four-way control

    The shape of a gate doesn’t prove that the stick is mechanically restricted to four directions. 8BitDo describes the Arcade Stick as an eight-way stick; Ultimarc describes the standalone Mag-Stik Plus as having a mechanical switch between four-way and eight-way operation.

    If a game requires four-way control, specifically check that the stick has a mechanical restriction, rather than relying on the shape of the gate.

  • Buying a standalone joystick as if it were a complete USB controller

    The Ultimarc Mag-Stik Plus is a joystick component; the other models discussed are complete controllers.

    Choose a standalone joystick only if you’re planning to build a suitable complete setup yourself.

    A complete setup may also require a case, buttons, a connection and mounting.

Brands to compare

MAYFLASH

The wired F101 is worth considering if you play on Windows and want to choose between XInput and DirectInput.

  • According to MAYFLASH, the F101 supports both input modes and its buttons can be customised.
  • The included octagonal restrictor doesn’t prove that the stick can be mechanically restricted to four directions; check this requirement separately.

HORI

The Fighting Stick Mini NSW-149 is a compact model for Nintendo Switch and Windows PC.

  • HORI lists the NSW-149 as approximately 210 × 150 mm, with a USB-A cable measuring around 2.5 m.
  • According to HORI, this Windows version supports XInput games, but not DirectInput games. Check the full model code.

8BitDo

The Arcade Stick has a joystick and several connection options; the separate Arcade Controller uses directional buttons instead of a joystick.

  • According to 8BitDo, the Arcade Stick offers Bluetooth, 2.4 GHz and USB-C. The manufacturer describes this model as having an eight-way stick.
  • According to 8BitDo, the Arcade Stick has a footprint of 303 × 203 mm. At 301 × 201 mm, the joystick-free Arcade Controller doesn’t take up much less space; also check that its controls suit your game.

Ultimarc

The Mag-Stik Plus is a standalone joystick for building your own setup with switchable four-way and eight-way control.

  • Ultimarc describes a mechanical switch on the top.
  • This isn’t a complete USB arcade controller; also consider the mounting and other components you’ll need.

Joybuy products

Related products coming soon.

Frequently asked questions

Will every PC arcade stick work with my classic puzzle game?

No. Check which inputs the game accepts. HORI lists only XInput for the NSW-149 on Windows, while MAYFLASH lists XInput and DirectInput for the F101. Also check that the game supports the buttons and directions you need.

How do I connect a wired stick to my home-working PC?

Follow the instructions for the exact model variant and check that your PC has the connection it requires. HORI lists USB-A for the NSW-149; MAYFLASH lists a USB connection for the F101. Then select the input mode supported by your game.

Does an arcade controller need to be maintained in a particular way?

Follow the manufacturer’s instructions for your model. If you want to replace parts, first check which tools and components are compatible; 8BitDo lists a T10 Torx screwdriver and a Phillips screwdriver for customising the Arcade Stick.

What are the warranty and returns rules in the Netherlands?

According to ACM ConsuWijzer, the statutory guarantee doesn’t have a fixed term of exactly two years: what matters is what you can reasonably expect from the product with normal use. For a standard online purchase, you’ll generally have up to 14 days from receipt to change your mind; check the relevant exceptions and return conditions.

Which product safety rules apply to a controller in the Netherlands?

According to the Dutch Ondernemersplein, electrical and electronic products placed on the market must comply with the applicable European rules. A product description alone doesn’t prove that a specific item being offered complies with those rules.