Who is this guide for?

The quiet-practising room sharer

You want to practise regularly while someone else is resting in the same bedroom. Assess button and joystick noise separately: noise-dampening buttons don’t guarantee a quiet controller overall. The RIVM notes that noise can cause annoyance or disrupt sleep.

Platform gamer with a dedicated console or PC

Your device and the controls used by your game determine which controller layout will work. Some models have different input modes or require an extra connected controller with certain consoles. Check the requirements for your exact model and platform.

Player with limited storage space

You’re looking for an arcade-style layout that can be put away after playing on a shared desk or bedside table. Compare its size with your available playing space, and consider stability and cable routing. HORI and 8BitDo list model dimensions that you can compare with your own storage space.

What should you consider when choosing?

First, check that the directional and action inputs suit your game and device. Then compare the noise made by the controls and the space the controller takes up, including its cable.

What to consider What should you check? Who should pay particular attention?
Noise Assess the buttons and joystick separately. Qanba describes silicone dampening for specific Gravity KS buttons, but that claim doesn’t tell you whether a complete controller is quiet. If I want to practise while my room-mate is resting, I need to know how much noise both the buttons and joystick make. Around 29% of consumers prioritise noise reduction.
Device and game Check the exact model, system version, required game inputs and any additional connection requirements. MAYFLASH states that the F300 and F500 FLAT require a connected wired controller with certain consoles. If you want to find out first whether your device and game will work, check the required directional and action inputs. Around 29% of consumers prioritise compatibility.
Directional controls Compare a joystick with a button-only layout, and check that your game supports your chosen input. According to the manufacturer, the MAYFLASH F300 lets you switch between directional-pad and joystick input; the F500 FLAT has a button-only layout. If I want to practise platform games, I want to choose between joystick movement and separate directional buttons based on the controls in my game. Around 24% of consumers prioritise this layout.
Space and storage Measure your playing and storage space, and allow for the cable. HORI lists the Fighting Stick Mini at around 8 × 6 inches; 8BitDo gives the Arcade Stick dimensions as 303 × 203 × 111,5 mm. If you have limited space or want to customise parts, check the dimensions and space required against your room before buying. Around 18% of consumers prioritise space or customisability.

Common buying mistakes

  • Assuming a noise-dampening button makes the whole controller quiet

    Qanba’s dampening claim applies to specific Gravity KS buttons, not automatically to the joystick, case or entire playing area.

    Consider all the sources of noise and check that the parts are compatible before modifying your controller.

    Modifications may involve spending money on compatible replacement parts.

  • Assuming a compatibility list means you can play straight away on any console

    The MAYFLASH F300 and F500 FLAT models reviewed here have additional connection requirements with certain consoles.

    Check the instructions for your exact model, console and game, and allow for the possibility that you’ll need an extra wired controller.

  • Choosing a compact stick without allowing for the cable and playing surface

    A small size doesn’t tell you how much room you’ll need to play or where the cable will go. The HORI Fighting Stick Mini reviewed here is wired.

    Compare the listed dimensions with both your playing space and your storage space.

Brands and models to consider

8BitDo

The Arcade Stick is worth considering if you want to choose between different connection methods on a supported Switch or Windows PC.

  • According to 8BitDo, the Arcade Stick offers Bluetooth, 2.4 GHz, wired USB-C and button mapping.
  • Check the specified system version and game compatibility; these specifications don’t tell you how quiet the controls are.

MAYFLASH

The F300 and F500 FLAT offer different input layouts to compare: a stick with switchable directional input or a controller with buttons only.

  • MAYFLASH documents switchable input and customisable parts for the models listed.
  • The manufacturer lists additional connection requirements for certain consoles; these can vary by model.

HORI

The wired Fighting Stick Mini for Nintendo Switch is a compact stick to consider if storage space is important.

  • HORI lists an eight-button layout, a microswitch joystick and a compact size for this version.
  • These specifications don’t prove that it’s quieter, and they don’t necessarily apply to other versions.

Qanba

The Drone 2 is worth considering for the PlayStation and PC platforms listed; Gravity KS are replacement buttons for a compatible modification.

  • Qanba lists PS4, PS5 and PC support for the Drone 2, and describes silicone dampening for Gravity KS buttons.
  • Support doesn’t prove that every platform game will work. The dampening claim doesn’t mean the Drone 2 includes those buttons as standard or is quiet overall.

Joybuy products

Related products coming soon.

Frequently asked questions

Can I play every platform game with an arcade stick?

No, a general platform compatibility listing doesn’t prove that. Compare the actions in your game with the buttons and directional input on the exact model, then check that your device and system version are supported.

Does wireless play make an arcade stick quiet?

No, a wireless connection replaces the cable, not the mechanical buttons or joystick. Qanba describes noise dampening for specific replacement buttons; that isn’t a noise measurement for a complete controller.

What should I check when connecting a controller or replacing buttons?

Choose the input mode that suits your device and check the requirements for the exact model. For the F300 and F500 FLAT models reviewed here, MAYFLASH requires a connected wired console controller with certain consoles. Before replacing buttons, check their size and mounting first, and follow the instructions.

What are my rights when buying an arcade controller online in the Netherlands?

For online distance purchases from a business, you’ll often have a 14-day cooling-off period, according to the Government of the Netherlands. The product must also meet the terms of your agreement; in the Netherlands, there is no fixed statutory guarantee period. If a product is faulty, contact the seller. The cooling-off period and your statutory rights are separate matters.