Who is this choice for?

Players who switch between systems

You play 2D fighting games on PC and may also play on a console, so the right platform version and any PS5 limitations will affect your choice. Nacon, Razer and 8BitDo list different system compatibilities for different product versions.

Players choosing an input layout

You want to choose between joystick movement and separate directional buttons, without assuming one layout works better for everyone. HORI describes a joystick model, while Razer and 8BitDo describe all-button layouts.

Players sharing a desk

You tidy away your gaming setup after a session, so you’ll want to check the stated dimensions, cable and options for replacing parts later. 8BitDo lists the dimensions of its Arcade Controller; Nacon describes a detachable 3 m cable for the PlayStation version of the Daija.

What should you look for when buying?

Arcade stick with joystick

Best for: anyone who wants to keep using a joystick and has a permanent spot on their desk or lap.

Bear in mind: check the exact console version. PlayStation and Xbox versions in the same product family aren’t automatically interchangeable.

Leverless controller

Best for: anyone who prefers to enter directions using separate buttons. Razer lists PS5 and PC compatibility for the Kitsune; 8BitDo lists Windows and Switch compatibility for its Arcade Controller.

Bear in mind: the button layout may take some getting used to, so don’t choose it based on a general promise of greater speed or comfort.

What to consider What should you check? Who is it most relevant to?
Platform and game Check the exact version, the system you plan to use and the game. Mayflash describes PS5 use of the F700 Elite for fighting games; for the F500 Elite, the company lists a separate Magic-S Ultimate adapter route. If I play on PC and may also play on a console, I want to know whether this exact version works with my system and game. Around 36% of consumers prioritise platform and game compatibility.
Input layout Decide whether you want to use a joystick or separate directional buttons. Product specifications don’t prove a universal performance advantage. If I want to choose how I enter directions, I compare the physical layout with my preference. Around 29% of consumers give this choice priority.
Space and cable Measure the available desk space and consider the cable route and where you’ll store the controller. 8BitDo lists dimensions of 301 × 201 × 22 mm for its Windows/Switch Arcade Controller; Nacon lists a detachable 3 m cable for the PlayStation Daija. If I also use my desk for work, I want to be able to put the controller down or store it after playing. Around 21% of consumers are most concerned with how well it fits into their workspace.
Customisation and accessories Check which parts can be replaced and whether any required adapter needs to be bought separately. HORI describes a case that opens for access; 8BitDo lists hot-swappable switches for the Windows/Switch version. If I want to customise parts later or need a complete PS5 setup, I want to know what’s required. Around 14% of consumers prioritise customisation or additional accessories.

Avoid common buying mistakes

  • Assuming a platform name in the product family guarantees compatibility

    PlayStation and Xbox versions may have different system compatibility lists. The PS5 route can also vary between Mayflash models.

    Before buying, compare the full version name, the system you plan to use and the game. Check whether your PS5 setup requires an adapter.

  • Choosing an all-button layout based on a general speed claim

    A stated button layout doesn’t mean that everyone will play better or faster with it.

    Choose the controls you want to use, and check the rules of the specific event if you plan to compete.

  • Forgetting about dimensions and the cable on a shared desk

    The case size and cable length will affect where you can place the controller while playing.

    Measure the available space and compare it with the specifications for the exact version. Also plan where the cable will run and where you’ll store the device.

Brands to consider

HORI

The Fighting Stick α is a joystick option for PS5, PS4 and Windows. Check you’re looking at the exact version you need.

  • HORI lists HAYABUSA buttons and joystick, plus a case that opens for customisation and maintenance.
  • These features apply to this model and aren’t automatically available on other HORI controllers.

Nacon

The PlayStation version of the Daija is designed for use with PS5, PS4 and PC.

  • Nacon lists SANWA components, profiles, a button lock and a detachable 3 m cable.
  • The PlayStation version isn’t interchangeable with the Xbox version, so check which one you’re buying.

Razer

Razer describes the Kitsune as a slim, all-button controller for PS5 and PC.

  • Razer lists optical switches and a low-profile case.
  • Razer’s claim that the layout eliminates input errors is a manufacturer claim, not a proven result.

8BitDo

The Arcade Controller has a leverless layout. The Windows/Switch and Xbox versions are different products.

  • For the Windows/Switch version, 8BitDo lists three connection methods, hot-swappable switches and dimensions of 301 × 201 × 22 mm.
  • Check the compatibility list for the exact version and your system; don’t assume the other version offers the same support.

Mayflash

The F700 Elite and F500 Elite offer different ways to use the controllers with multiple systems.

  • Mayflash describes the F700 Elite as suitable for PS5 fighting games. For the F500 Elite, the company lists a separate Magic-S Ultimate adapter route to PS5.
  • Mayflash limits the stated PS5 use of the F700 Elite to fighting games. For the F500 Elite, also check that the adapter route works with your game.

Qanba

The Drone 2 is a joystick model with a selector switch for PS5, PS4 and PC.

  • Qanba lists a touchpad and its own Qanba buttons and joystick.
  • Before buying, check that the stated system selection works with your platform and fighting game.

Joybuy products

Related products coming soon.

Frequently asked questions

Can I use any PS4 arcade stick with a PS5 version of a fighting game?

No. Don’t assume PS5 compatibility just because a stick supports PS4. Check the exact model and game; some manufacturers distinguish between PS5 fighting games and other PS5 games.

How do I set up a Nacon Daija for PlayStation?

According to Nacon, select PC, PS4 or PS5 mode and connect the included USB cable. Before buying, check that you’re looking at the version for your system.

Which parts can I maintain or replace?

It varies by model: HORI describes the Fighting Stick α as having an opening case, while 8BitDo lists hot-swappable switches on the Windows/Switch Arcade Controller. Check the manual for your exact version for details of the parts and how to work on them.

Do I need a separate adapter to use a Mayflash F500 Elite with PS5?

Yes. If you want to use the Magic-S Ultimate route to PS5 described by Mayflash, the adapter is a separate product. Check that this route works with your game.

What are my rights when I buy the controller online in the Netherlands?

For an online consumer purchase, you generally have a statutory 14-day cooling-off period after delivery, subject to legal exceptions. The product must also meet what you can reasonably expect from it. According to ACM ConsuWijzer, the seller must resolve any fault that means it doesn’t. This is separate from any voluntary commercial warranty period.