Who is this choice for?

Console player practising combos

You want a model that works with your game version on PS5 or Xbox. Check the exact platform model; the name of a controller range alone doesn’t tell you which version you need.

Player looking to practise a different input style

You’re comparing joystick movements with separate direction buttons and want to use the same controls consistently while practising.

Player gaming from a seat some distance away

You practise on a big screen and want the cable route or wireless connection to suit the distance between your seat and gaming device.

What should you look for?

Choose the right platform version and input style first. Then check that the connection and any adjustments suit your setup.

What to consider What should you check? Who should prioritise this?
Game and platform compatibility Check the exact version, your console or PC, the game version and any adapter requirements. I want to know before buying whether the model works with my game and platform. Around 33% of consumers put compatibility first.
Joystick or direction buttons Choose the input style that suits the movements you want to practise; a leverless model doesn’t have a joystick. I want to practise combos using the movement inputs I intend to use consistently. Around 27% of consumers prioritise this input style.
Connection and screen setup Measure the cable route or check which wireless modes are supported. Also check your TV’s Game Mode. I play some distance from my gaming device and want my seat and connection to work well together. Around 20% of consumers prioritise their TV setup.
Maintenance and customisation Check which parts can be adjusted or accessed on each model, and whether any accessories need to be bought separately. I want to know whether I can adjust or access parts for maintenance, and what I’ll need to do so. Around 20% of consumers prioritise customisation.

The differences aren’t just about the controls. Nacon says the PlayStation Daija comes with a 300 cm USB cable; 8BitDo lists Bluetooth, 2.4 GHz and USB-C for its Arcade Stick for Switch and Windows. Check that the connection on the exact model suits the distance and device in your setup. Samsung describes Game Mode on its own TVs as a setting that reduces input lag; this isn’t a general claim about all screens.

Common buying mistakes

  • Ordering the wrong platform version

    Controllers with similar names may be designed for different platforms. The wrong version might not work with your gaming device.

    Compare the full model name and stated platform with your console or PC and game version.

  • Confusing PS5 support with a direct connection

    MAYFLASH says the F500 Elite can connect to PS5 using a converter and additional steps; that’s different from connecting it directly.

    Before choosing a model, check which converter and firmware are needed, and what’s included in the box for your exact setup.

    A converter may be a separate part of your setup and involve extra connection steps.

  • Blaming all input lag on the controller

    Your screen settings may also be part of the setup. Samsung describes Game Mode on its own TVs as a way to reduce input lag.

    Check your screen’s connections and Game Mode before choosing a different controller.

Brands to compare

Nacon

Nacon says the PlayStation Daija is suitable for PS5, PS4 and PC; check that the platform version matches your gaming device.

  • Nacon says this version has Sanwa controls, adjustable buttons, interchangeable joystick tops and a 300 cm USB cable included.
  • These features apply to the version mentioned. Nacon lists the older Daija for PS4 and PC as no longer available.

HORI

HORI lists the Fighting Stick α for PS5, PS4 and Windows; access to the inside may matter if maintenance or customisation is important to you.

  • For this α version, HORI lists Hayabusa buttons and joystick, an opening case and an interchangeable top panel.
  • Don’t assume that smaller HORI sticks have the same parts or maintenance options.

8BitDo

8BitDo offers different versions: an Arcade Stick for Switch and Windows, and a leverless Arcade Controller for Xbox for Xbox and Windows.

  • For the Arcade Stick, 8BitDo lists Bluetooth, 2.4 GHz and USB-C; for the Xbox model, it lists SOCD settings and a tournament lock.
  • The platforms and input styles vary by model. Check the full product name rather than just the brand.

Razer

Razer describes the Kitsune as a leverless controller for PS5 and PC, designed for players who want to enter directions using separate buttons.

  • According to Razer, the Kitsune has four direction buttons and optical switches.
  • Razer’s claims about faster or more precise input don’t prove that an individual player will learn combos more quickly.

MAYFLASH

The F500 Elite is a joystick model worth considering if you want to check carefully that it connects to your platform.

  • MAYFLASH describes the F500 Elite as having Sanwa parts, nine buttons and a four-way joystick.
  • For the PS5 setup described, MAYFLASH specifies a converter. Check the required firmware and parts; this setup doesn’t mean the stick connects directly.

Joybuy products

Related products coming soon.

Frequently asked questions

Will a PS4 arcade stick automatically work with every PS5 game?

No, don’t assume so just because it has a PS4 label. PlayStation lists compatibility for certain officially licensed specialist controllers, including arcade sticks; also check that your exact model works with your game version.

Do I need to connect the controller directly to the TV?

No, the controller connects to the gaming device, such as your console or PC; the TV is the screen. Measure the distance to your gaming device: Nacon says the PlayStation Daija comes with a 300 cm USB cable, while 8BitDo also lists wireless modes for its Arcade Stick for Switch and Windows.

Can a TV setting make a difference when practising?

Check the Game Mode on your own TV. Samsung describes this setting on supported Samsung TVs as a way to reduce input lag; the precise effect depends on your screen and gaming setup.

What should I keep in case it needs maintenance or develops a fault?

Keep your proof of purchase and the details of the exact model. According to ACM ConsuWijzer, statutory warranty in the Netherlands doesn’t have a fixed general end date of two years; what you can reasonably expect from the product under normal use is important.

Can I return a controller bought online if I don’t like the controls?

Online consumer purchases come with a statutory cooling-off period, according to ACM ConsuWijzer. Check the applicable time limit, exceptions and conditions for trying out and returning your purchase.