If noise is your deciding factor, check the construction of both the buttons and any joystick: a label such as ‘silent’ doesn’t measure how loud it will be in your bedroom. Qanba describes the Q8 Silent as having a quiet lever and buttons; HORI describes dampened switches for the NOLVA REACTOR. Then choose the movement layout you want to practise and check that the exact version works with your platform and game.
Who is this relevant for?
The quiet-bedroom trainee
You practise the same moves over and over while someone else is resting in the same room. So assess both the buttons and any lever. Qanba and HORI describe specific quiet or dampened components, but don’t provide independent noise measurements.
The platform-specific player
You practise on a particular console or PC and want to know whether the exact version of the controller you choose works with your fighting game. PlayStation and manufacturers describe compatibility by platform, version and, sometimes, game type.
The layout switcher
You’re choosing between joystick movement and four movement buttons, or want to be able to replace switches. Qanba, HORI and Razer describe different layouts and components for specific models.
What should you consider when choosing?
When practising combos in a shared bedroom, noise, platform compatibility, movement layout and customisation are separate things to consider before buying.
| What to consider |
What should you check? |
Who is this important for? |
| Noise |
Check the construction of both the buttons and lever on the exact version; don’t assume a guaranteed noise level. |
If I’m repeating combos while someone else is resting in the room, I also want to know whether a lever makes noise. Around 36% of consumers say noise is their top priority. |
| Platform and game |
Check the full model name, connection, any platform setting and support for the specific game. |
I want to practise my fighting game on my own console or PC, so I check the exact combination. Around 29% of consumers prioritise compatibility with their own platform. |
| Movement layout |
Compare joystick controls with four movement buttons, and check the action buttons for your game. |
If I mainly want to choose between a lever and movement buttons, I look for the layout that lets me practise the inputs I want to use. Around 21% of consumers give this choice priority. |
| Customisation |
Check which switches or components can be replaced in the exact version. |
I want to be able to customise components later, so I check which switches are compatible with the model. Around 14% of consumers prioritise customisation. |
Common buying mistakes
-
Assuming ‘silent’ means ‘inaudible’
For the models mentioned, this label refers to components that the manufacturer describes as quiet or dampened. It doesn’t prove how much noise the controller makes in a shared bedroom.
Assess the buttons and any lever separately, and consider the conditions in which you’ll be practising.
-
Assuming PS5 compatibility from a general platform listing
A controller may have limitations for certain games or require you to select the right platform setting before connecting it. MAYFLASH limits the described PS5 use of the F700 Elite to fighting games; Nacon describes a separate platform switch for the Daija.
Check the exact version, game and required setting or connection before choosing.
-
Assuming all-button is automatically better for combos
An all-button controller and a joystick use different movements. The product specifications consulted don’t show a universal performance advantage for combos.
Choose based on the movements you want to practise, and treat quiet components as a separate requirement.
Brands to compare when choosing an arcade controller
Qanba
The Q8 Silent is a joystick option for PC.
- For this version, Qanba lists a quiet lever and Gravity KS buttons.
- These are the manufacturer’s product specifications, not independent noise measurements. The specification consulted lists PC, not PS5.
HORI
The NOLVA REACTOR is an all-button controller for PS5, PS4 and Windows 11/10.
- HORI describes dampened, replaceable switches for this model.
- This description isn’t an independent noise measurement for use in a shared bedroom, and doesn’t automatically apply to other HORI models.
Razer
The Kitsune is an all-button option for PS5 and PC.
- Razer specifies four movement buttons and optical switches for the Kitsune.
- The listed specifications don’t substantiate quiet operation; any claim about avoiding input errors is a brand claim.
MAYFLASH
The F700 Elite is a joystick stick that the manufacturer describes for certain fighting games on PS5.
- MAYFLASH lists Sanwa components for this model.
- MAYFLASH advises against using it with other types of PS5 games and says the F700 Elite doesn’t work with Xbox Series S/X. The specifications don’t demonstrate quiet operation.
Nacon
The Daija is a joystick option with a choice of PC, PS4 or PS5.
- Nacon describes a separate platform switch and connection procedure for the Daija.
- The platform options don’t prove that it operates quietly; check the setting for your system before use.
Arcade controllers for this topic
Related products will be available soon.
Frequently asked questions
Will every PS4 arcade stick automatically work with my PS5 fighting game?
No, not automatically. PlayStation says that officially licensed arcade sticks work with PS5 games and supported PS4 games. So check the licence status, the full model version and support for your game.
How do I connect a Nacon Daija?
According to Nacon, first select the setting for PC, PS4 or PS5, then connect the supplied cable to the stick and your chosen system. These instructions apply to the Daija version described.
Can I return a controller bought online if I don’t like the controls?
For online consumer purchases in the Netherlands, you generally have a 14-day cooling-off period after delivery. ACM ConsuWijzer explains the conditions and exceptions for trying out and returning a product; check these before using the controller further.
Who should I contact if the product is faulty, and is the guarantee always exactly two years?
Report a potentially faulty product to the seller. According to ACM ConsuWijzer, statutory guarantee in the Netherlands doesn’t have a fixed duration of exactly two years: what you could reasonably expect from the product is what matters.
Does a controller sold in the Netherlands need to have a CE mark?
A CE mark is required when the specific version falls under EU product rules that require this marking. Your Europe and the European Commission explain the applicable product rules; ask the seller which requirements apply to the exact version, especially if it’s a wireless model.