Who is this buying guide for?

Long-session player

You mainly want enough room for your hands and wrists, and a controller that stays put. Compare the dimensions and support points, but don’t treat the manufacturer’s descriptions as a guarantee of comfort. Nacon describes the Daija as having a wrist rest; HORI lists rubber feet on the Fighting Stick Mini.

Console player with a particular game in mind

You want to know whether the exact controller model works with your console and chosen beat ’em up. A general mention of a platform may not be enough: according to the manufacturer, Mayflash limits use of the F700 Elite on PS5 to fighting games.

Player choosing an arcade control style

You’re comparing a physical joystick with separate directional buttons, while weighing up space, connection options and how easy each is to get used to. 8BitDo describes both joystick controllers and an all-button controller for certain Switch and Windows configurations.

What should you look for when buying?

What to consider What should you check? Who is this important for?
Room for your hands and stability Compare the case size with your playing space and check where you can rest your hands. HORI lists rubber feet on the Mini; Nacon describes the Daija as having a wrist rest. When I play for a long time, I want enough room for my hands and a setup that suits my posture. Around 36% of consumers put room for their hands and stability first.
Console and game compatibility Check the full model name, platform mode and support for your specific game. Mayflash warns that the F700 Elite is intended for fighting games on PS5, not other types of games such as action games. I want to know in advance whether my exact controller and beat ’em up will work on my system. An estimated 29% of consumers prioritise compatibility with their console, computer and game.
Joystick or directional buttons Check the controls and button layout of the model; an all-button controller has no joystick and may take some getting used to. When choosing between a classic joystick and separate directional buttons, I want to know which control style suits the way I play. Around 21% of consumers put the type of controls first.
Wireless or wired Check which connection mode works with your model and platform, and whether the cable or receiver you need is compatible with that version. I prefer to play without a cable in my gaming space and want to know which wireless connection my system supports. An estimated 14% of consumers give cable-free play top priority.

Common buying mistakes

  • Assuming that ‘PS5 compatible’ means it will work with every game

    Mayflash lists a limitation for the F700 Elite on PS5: the manufacturer specifies fighting games and excludes other types of games, including action games. So a general platform name doesn’t guarantee support for a particular beat ’em up.

    Before choosing, check support for the specific game you want to play and the exact controller model.

  • Treating similar 8BitDo model names as if they were the same version

    The standard Arcade Stick for Switch and Windows and the Arcade Stick for Xbox are separate models, with different supported platforms and connection options.

    Compare the full model name with the manufacturer’s compatibility information for your system.

  • Assuming a compact controller will automatically be more comfortable

    According to HORI, the Fighting Stick Mini takes up little space, while Nacon describes the larger Daija as having a separate wrist rest. Neither feature proves which shape will suit your hands during long sessions.

    Measure your playing space and check where you can actually rest your hands.

Relevant brands to consider

8BitDo

Offers a range of arcade controllers for specific platform combinations, including joystick models and a controller with buttons only.

  • According to 8BitDo, the standard Arcade Stick has Bluetooth, 2.4 GHz and USB-C; the manufacturer says the Arcade Controller uses different connection modes for Switch and Windows.
  • According to 8BitDo, the standard Switch/Windows stick isn’t intended for PS4, PS5 or Xbox. The Xbox version is a separate model.

HORI

Its range includes the compact Fighting Stick Mini and the larger Fighting Stick α for PlayStation and Windows.

  • HORI lists eight buttons and rubber feet on the Mini. According to HORI, the European Fighting Stick α can be opened for customisation and maintenance.
  • HORI says the Mini doesn’t have a touchpad. A compact case or access for maintenance doesn’t, by itself, tell you which model will suit your posture.

Nacon

The Daija discussed here is a wired arcade stick for PlayStation and PC.

  • Nacon describes the PlayStation version as having a textured wrist rest and interchangeable joystick heads.
  • The Daija mentioned here is wired. Manufacturer descriptions of comfort aren’t independent measurements and can’t guarantee a personal fit.

Mayflash

According to Mayflash, the F700 Elite combines several connection options with Sanwa components.

  • Mayflash lists Bluetooth, 2.4 GHz, USB and an anti-slip mat for the F700 Elite.
  • According to the manufacturer, use of this model on PS5 is limited to fighting games, and it isn’t compatible with Xbox Series X|S. So be sure to check the type of game, too.

Qanba

Qanba lists the Drone 2 as a joystick controller for PS5, PS4 and PC.

  • Qanba’s product information lists a touchpad, headset socket and platform switch.

Joybuy products

Related products coming soon.

Frequently asked questions

Will an arcade controller labelled ‘PS5 compatible’ work with every retro beat ’em up on PS5?

No, the label alone doesn’t tell you that. Mayflash says the F700 Elite is intended for fighting games on PS5, not other types of games, including action games. So check support for the specific game you want to play.

How can I connect the standard 8BitDo Arcade Stick?

According to 8BitDo, this version supports Bluetooth, a 2.4GHz receiver and USB-C. The mode you can use depends on your system, so check the manufacturer’s instructions for your platform.

Can I customise the buttons or other parts?

It depends on the model. 8BitDo describes button mapping for the standard Arcade Stick; HORI says the Fighting Stick α can be opened for customisation and maintenance. Check the manual for your exact model before changing any parts.

What are my rights when buying online in the Netherlands?

For many online distance purchases from a business, you have a 14-day cooling-off period, according to the Dutch government. This is separate from your rights if a product is faulty; in that case, contact the seller. The Dutch government states that the Netherlands doesn’t have a fixed statutory guarantee period covering all products.