Who is this choice for?

Night-time player with a roommate

You play while someone else in the same room is resting, so you want to keep noise from both the directional controls and the buttons to a minimum. HORI and Qanba describe dampened components on specific models.

Console player who wants to be sure

You want to avoid ending up with a controller that works on your PC but not on your console or in your game. 8BitDo and MAYFLASH list different platform support for specific versions and models.

Player with limited storage space

You need to put your controller away after playing in a shared bedroom, so you’re comparing compact, flat designs with larger lever models. Features vary by model, as Razer and MAYFLASH point out.

What should you look for?

Leverless controller

A good fit if: you want to swap the lever for directional buttons and put away a flatter controller. HORI lists dampened switches for the NOLVA REACTOR; 8BitDo offers separate versions with different platform support.

Trade-off: you’ll need to get used to controlling the game with buttons. A dampened switch doesn’t prove that the whole device is quieter.

Arcade stick with a lever

A good fit if: you want to keep the classic lever movement. Qanba lists both a quiet lever and quiet buttons for the Q8; MAYFLASH offers the F700 Elite for compatible fighting games on platforms including PS5, Switch and Windows.

Trade-off: check the noise from the lever and buttons separately, and look out for limitations on the exact model. The Q8 is presented as a PC model; according to MAYFLASH, the F700 Elite doesn’t work with Xbox Series X|S.

What to consider What should you check? Who should prioritise this?
Noise from the buttons and directional controls Check which components on the exact model are dampened. If possible, compare the noise in your own room; there are no directly comparable noise measurements for the models mentioned. If I play while my roommate is resting, I want to hear as little as possible from both the buttons and directional controls. Around 33% of consumers put noise reduction first.
Platform and game compatibility Check the full model name against the platform list, and make sure it supports the fighting game you want to play. If I play on a particular console or PC, I want to know that the controller works with both my device and my game. Around 27% of consumers give platform compatibility top priority.
Storage and positioning Compare the stated dimensions with the space you have available, and check whether the model has features to keep it stable when set down. If I need to put my controller away after playing in a shared room, I want a size that fits the space I have. Around 20% of consumers put storage space first.
Lever or directional buttons Choose the control layout you want to use. If you opt for a lever model, also check that both the lever and the buttons meet your noise requirements. If I want to keep the familiar lever movement, that familiar style of control matters more to me than a flatter layout. Around 20% of consumers put this preference first.

Common buying mistakes

  • Assuming quiet buttons mean a quiet controller

    The buttons and directional controls are separate sources of noise. So a claim about quiet buttons doesn’t automatically tell you how noisy the lever is.

    Check which components on the exact model are dampened, and treat claims about quiet operation as claims made by the manufacturer, not as comparable measurements.

  • Choosing the wrong version from a brand

    Platform support can vary between versions from the same brand. There may also be limitations for a particular model or game.

    Check the full model name and listed platforms against your device and the fighting game you want to play.

  • Assuming leverless is automatically better or quieter

    Leverless controllers replace the lever movement with directional buttons. Product specifications don’t prove that this will improve your performance in a game or reduce noise in your room.

    Choose the control layout you want to use, and check the components and compatibility of the specific model.

Brands to compare

HORI

The NOLVA REACTOR is a leverless option for PS5, PS4 and Windows if dampened switches are important to you.

  • HORI lists dampened, replaceable switches, a detachable cable and a non-slip base for the NOLVA REACTOR.
  • The claim about quiet operation applies to this specific model and isn’t backed by an independent noise measurement. Check the exact version.

Qanba

The Q8 is a lever option for PC users who want to consider the noise from both the buttons and the lever.

  • Qanba lists a quiet Gravity lever and quiet Gravity KS buttons for the Q8.
  • The stated compatibility is for PC; don’t assume this means it supports consoles.

8BitDo

The brand offers separate leverless versions for Xbox and Windows, and for Switch and Windows.

  • According to 8BitDo, the Xbox version has replaceable switches and a non-slip mat. The standard Arcade Controller can connect to Switch and Windows, according to the brand.
  • The platform lists for these versions aren’t interchangeable. The stated features aren’t a comparative noise measurement.

MAYFLASH

The F700 Elite is a lever model for compatible PS5 fighting games, Switch, Windows and more.

  • MAYFLASH lists a Sanwa lever and buttons, along with several connection options for this model.
  • MAYFLASH states that the F700 Elite doesn’t work with Xbox Series X|S and advises against using it with other types of PS5 games. These limitations don’t necessarily apply to other F700 versions.

Razer

The Kitsune is a slim leverless controller for PS5 and PC.

  • Razer lists optical switches, a detachable USB-C cable and a lock.
  • Claims of fewer input errors or better performance are claims made by the manufacturer. The product information doesn’t support a noise benefit in a shared bedroom.

Products at Joybuy

Related products coming soon.

Frequently asked questions

Will every PS4 arcade stick automatically work with every PS5 game?

No, compatibility depends on the controller and the game. PlayStation describes support for certain officially licensed specialist controllers with PS5 games and supported PS4 games. Also check the information for the exact controller model and game; MAYFLASH, for example, limits the stated PS5 use of the F700 Elite to compatible fighting games.

How can I connect the controller without trailing cables across the room?

Check the connection options for each platform and version. According to 8BitDo, the standard Arcade Controller uses Bluetooth for Switch, 2.4 GHz for Windows and a wired connection for both. Don’t assume these options also apply to the Xbox version.

Can I replace noisy buttons later?

According to HORI, the switches in the HORI NOLVA REACTOR are replaceable; Qanba sells separate Gravity KS buttons with noise-dampening components. Before buying, check that the parts fit mechanically and are electrically compatible with your exact controller. Replacing them doesn’t guarantee a particular noise level.

What is the cooling-off period for online purchases in the Netherlands?

For distance purchases from a business, a 14-day cooling-off period applies in many cases. The Dutch government lists exceptions and distinguishes between buying from a private individual and buying from a business; check who the seller is and which terms and conditions apply.

Does an electronic arcade controller need a CE marking?

That depends on which EU rules apply to the product. Where those rules require CE marking, the product must comply and carry the mark. The European Union explains that CE marking is only mandatory for products covered by rules that specifically require it. Check the information for the product you’re considering.