Choose according to how your journal is bound. If the pages need to stay bound, a flatbed scanner is more important than an automatic document feeder (ADF), which is mainly designed for loose sheets. Also compare the scanning area, connectivity for shared users and running costs for your print volume. If the binding is delicate, a standard all-in-one printer may not be the right scanning solution.
Who is this for?
People preserving bound journals
If you want to digitise pages without removing them, consider the space on the flatbed and the condition of the binding. The National Archives takes the physical condition of archival material into account when digitising it.
Users of a shared workspace
Several users may need to print or scan. Agree where personal scan files will be stored, and who can access them.
People digitising loose travel documents
If you scan piles of loose documents as well as a journal, an ADF may be useful, provided the documents are suitable for the feeder.
What should you look for?
| What to consider |
What to look for |
Who should pay particular attention? |
| Bound and delicate pages |
Check the flatbed and maximum scanning area. Don’t press a delicate binding flat to make the book fit. |
If I want to preserve a bound or delicate journal, I’ll first check how it fits on the flatbed. Around 36% of consumers prioritise preserving and scanning bound pages. |
| Shared use and careful handling |
Check the network or USB connection, and agree where scan files will be stored and who can access them. |
At a shared desk, I want others to be able to use the device without giving everyone access to my personal scans. Around 29% of consumers prioritise shared access and where scans are saved. |
| Loose travel documents |
Compare the ADF capacity and check separately whether it can scan single- or double-sided. Use the feeder only for suitable loose sheets. |
If I regularly scan piles of loose papers, I want to know whether the feeder is suitable for my documents. Around 21% of consumers prioritise handling loose travel documents. |
| Print volume and running costs |
Estimate how many black-and-white and colour pages you’ll print, then compare the ink or toner required and any maintenance parts. Consider ink yield claims in light of how you’ll use the printer. |
If I only print occasionally, I want to know what maintenance and running costs mean for that usage pattern. Around 14% of consumers base their choice on expected print volume and running costs. |
Common pitfalls
-
Confusing an ADF with a book scanner
An ADF feeds suitable loose sheets; bound pages can’t be fed through it as a stack.
First check the journal, flatbed and scanning area. Use the ADF for loose papers that are suitable for it.
Placing pages on the flatbed takes time and effort; a delicate binding may call for a different scanning method.
-
Confusing double-sided printing with double-sided scanning
These are separate functions. Canon specifies that the PIXMA TR7650 has a single-sided ADF as well as automatic double-sided printing.
Check the specifications for your chosen model to confirm explicitly whether it supports double-sided scanning.
You may need to turn over double-sided loose originals by hand.
-
Overlooking running costs and maintenance
The Consumers' Association notes that ink may be used for cleaning if you print infrequently. The Brother DCP-L2660DW uses separate toner and drum consumables.
Choose a model to suit your expected print volume, and check which consumables and maintenance parts it uses.
If the model uses separate consumables, allow for keeping track of and replacing each one.
Brands to consider
Canon
Canon offers models with different scanning setups; features vary by model.
- Canon specifies that the PIXMA TS7650i has a CIS flatbed scanner, suitable for placing pages on the glass one at a time.
- According to Canon, the PIXMA TR7650 has a single-sided ADF with a capacity of up to 20 sheets, for suitable loose documents.
- An ADF isn’t a solution for bound pages. Don’t assume that other PIXMA models have the same scanning features either.
Brother
The DCP-L2660DW is a monochrome laser all-in-one printer for a desk where most printing is text documents.
- Brother specifies that this model has Wi-Fi, Ethernet and a 50-sheet ADF.
- Monochrome printing is less suitable if you also need to print coloured journal pages in colour. Check the scanning method separately for bound pages.
Epson
The EcoTank ET-3950 combines colour printing, refillable ink tanks and an ADF.
- According to Epson, the ET-3950 has a double-sided ADF.
- Epson’s claims about ink savings and the ink included are manufacturer claims, not a prediction of running costs for your print habits. Also check whether the scanning area is suitable for your journal.
- Double-sided printing doesn’t automatically mean the device can scan both sides.
HP
The Smart Tank 7305 is a colour ink-tank all-in-one printer with an ADF.
- HP specifies a 35-sheet feeder and automatic double-sided printing.
- Double-sided printing doesn’t confirm that double-sided scanning is possible. HP’s estimate for the life of the included ink depends on usage.
Joybuy products
These Joybuy picks are colour all-in-one printers for printing and scanning at a shared desk. For bound pages, check that the scanner has a flatbed large enough for your journal.
No image available
HP Smart Tank 7305 Wireless All-in-One Color Printer
The listed flatbed scanner is useful when you want to place pages on the glass one at a time; the ADF is designed for loose sheets.
The product information lists a 35-sheet ADF and Wi-Fi. The duplex function is for printing, not double-sided scanning.
Joybuy
No image available
Canon PIXMA MG2556S Inkjet A4
According to the product information, this model prints, scans and copies. Check that its scanning features suit your journal and how you’ll use it at a shared desk.
The listed specifications include USB 2.0 and 4800 × 600 DPI.
Joybuy
No image available
HP Smart Tank 7005 Wireless All-in-One Color Printer
The listed flatbed scanner is useful for pages placed on the glass one at a time; check that the scanning area is large enough for your journal.
The listed maximum scanning area is 216 × 297 mm. The product information includes Wi-Fi and refillable ink tanks. The duplex function is for printing, not double-sided scanning.
Joybuy
Frequently asked questions
Can I put a bound journal through the automatic document feeder?
No. An ADF is designed for suitable loose sheets. For a bound journal, consider the flatbed, scanning area and condition of the binding. The National Archives takes the physical condition of material into account when digitising it.
Does automatic double-sided printing also mean double-sided scanning?
No, these are separate functions. Canon specifies that the PIXMA TR7650 has automatic double-sided printing and a single-sided ADF; check the scanning specifications separately.
Where should I save scans if several people use the printer?
Choose a destination that only the intended users can access. For work documents containing personal data, the Dutch Data Protection Authority recommends a secure working environment and warns against careless use of cloud and storage services; this isn’t a general requirement for every personal travel journal.
What should I consider if I don’t print often?
Allow for maintenance-related usage and check which parts the device needs. The Consumers' Association notes that ink may be used for cleaning if you print infrequently; the Brother DCP-L2660DW uses separate toner and drum consumables.
Can I scan and share other people’s photos or writing in a travel journal?
According to the Dutch Government, you may make a private copy of copyright-protected material for your own use, but you can’t distribute or publish that copy without permission. This distinction matters if the journal also contains other people’s work.