Who is this relevant for?

Archivist of large scores

You archive originals larger than A4 and want to check whether the scanner can handle the entire sheet. Brother Netherlands and HP Netherlands describe models with A3 scanning capabilities.

Archivist of fragile manuscripts

You scan bound or fragile pieces and need a flatbed that can accommodate the original. Canon Netherlands describes flatbed scanning as an option for materials that aren’t suitable for an ADF.

Volunteer with loose rehearsal sheets

You regularly scan piles of loose sheets and want to weigh the time saved by an automatic document feeder against the size and duplex scanning capabilities. The Consumentenbond points out that an ADF saves you from placing multiple pages on the flatbed one at a time.

What should you look for when choosing?

First check the flatbed’s scanning size, then decide how you’ll handle fragile and loose sheets, and finally factor in printing costs.

What to consider What should you check? Who should pay particular attention?
Scan size Compare the flatbed’s maximum size with your largest original. Check separately whether the ADF can handle the size you need. If I want to capture large scores in full in a single scan, the flatbed needs to be large enough. Around 36% of consumers focus mainly on the scan size for large originals.
Fragile or bound sheets Identify any pieces that can’t go through a document feeder and check whether they fit on the flatbed. For bound or fragile manuscripts, I want a scanning method that doesn’t require unsuitable feed-through. Around 29% of consumers prioritise careful handling of fragile originals.
Loose sheets and speed Check the ADF’s paper size and whether duplex scanning is supported. If I often scan piles of loose rehearsal sheets, I want to spend less time placing sheets on the flatbed by hand. Around 21% of consumers focus mainly on scanning speed for loose sheets.
Printing and refill costs Estimate your own print volume and compare the cost of suitable refills. If we also print batches regularly as well as scanning, I want to factor in refill costs when choosing. Around 14% of consumers focus mainly on the ongoing cost of printing.

Common pitfalls

  • Confusing A3 printing with A3 scanning

    A printer may print in A3 while its scanner only handles up to A4. A larger original won’t fit on the flatbed in full in a single scan.

    Check the stated scan size for the exact model and compare it with your largest score.

    A scanner that’s too small may mean extra manual work or the need for a separate scanning solution.

  • Feeding every manuscript through the ADF

    An automatic document feeder is designed for suitable loose sheets; bound or fragile pieces may need to be scanned on a flatbed.

    Sort your originals by size and condition, and check that they fit on the flatbed before choosing a model.

  • Looking only at the purchase price

    If your group also prints a lot, refills add to the running costs. The Consumentenbond takes refill prices and usage into account when assessing printer costs.

    Compare the suitable refills with your expected print volume. HP states that the OfficeJet Pro 9730 has dynamic security that may block cartridges without a suitable HP chip, so check the cartridge requirements for this model too.

  • Assuming scanning means you’re allowed to share

    The Rijksoverheid states that a private copy for personal use must not be distributed or made available to the public.

    Before sharing scans of protected material within your group, establish what permission or licence applies to your intended use.

Brands to consider

Brother

Brother offers models with different scan sizes, making it a useful brand to compare if you’re weighing up A4 and A3 scanning capabilities.

  • Brother lists A3 scanning for the MFC-J6977DW.
  • According to Brother, the MFC-J5955DW scans up to A4, despite being able to print in A3.

HP

The HP OfficeJet Pro 9730 is worth comparing if you’re looking for an A3 flatbed for large originals.

  • HP lists an A3 flatbed scanner and duplex scanning for this model.
  • HP states that dynamic security may block cartridges without a suitable HP chip, so check the cartridge requirements for this specific model.

Epson

According to Epson, the EcoTank ET-16655 combines A3 scanning with an ADF and refillable ink tanks.

  • Epson lists A3 scanning for this model.
  • A stated ink yield alone doesn’t prove that your group will save money; compare refill costs with your own print volume.

Canon

The PIXMA TS9550a series is a more compact all-in-one option to compare if you also want to print in A3.

  • Canon lists A3 printing and an ADF for this series.
  • Check the scan size of the exact variant before choosing it for large originals.

Joybuy products for A4 scans

These Joybuy products are suited to scanning in A4: check that your scores fit on the flatbed before choosing.

HP Smart Tank 7305 Wireless All-in-One Color Printer

HP Smart Tank 7305 Wireless All-in-One Color Printer

Suitable for A4 originals that fit on the flatbed, and for suitable loose sheets fed through the ADF.

Flatbed scanning area: 216 × 297 mm. ADF capacity: 35 sheets.

View at Joybuy
HP Smart Tank 7005 Wireless All-in-One Color Printer

HP Smart Tank 7005 Wireless All-in-One Color Printer

Suitable for A4 originals that fit on the flatbed, including bound or fragile pieces that shouldn’t go through an ADF.

Flatbed scanner with a maximum scanning area of 216 × 297 mm. Stated optical scan resolution: 1200 × 1200 dpi.

View at Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

Is A3 printing enough to scan an A3 score in one go?

No, check the scan size for the exact model too. Brother lists A3 printing for the MFC-J5955DW, but scanning is limited to A4.

Should bound or fragile manuscripts go through the ADF?

No, use a flatbed that can accommodate originals that aren’t suitable for a document feeder. Canon describes flatbed scanning as an option for bound documents and fragile materials that can’t go through an ADF.

How should you compare costs if your group also prints sheet music?

Compare the cost of suitable refills with your group’s expected print volume. The Consumentenbond factors refill prices and usage into its assessment of running costs; a stated ink yield doesn’t automatically predict what it will cost to print your scores.

Can a Dutch group share scans of protected sheet music with its members?

Don’t assume that a private copy can be shared: according to the Rijksoverheid, it is for personal use and must not be distributed or made available to the public. Before sharing for your intended purpose, establish which permission or licence applies; general government information doesn’t determine whether a specific arrangement applies to your sheet music and group.