Who is this printer advice for?

Teacher with stacks of loose articles

Wants to process several A4 sheets in a row without placing each one on the scanner glass. For double-sided originals, it matters whether the ADF also scans both sides, as recommended by Consumentenbond and specified by Brother for the MFC-L5710DW.

Researcher who wants to find text again

Wants to save scans as searchable documents, so checks OCR, file format and scan destination separately. Brother lists scan-to-OCR for the DCP-L8410CDW, while Canon lists searchable PDF for the i-SENSYS MF465dw II.

Administrator of a shared classroom

Needs to coordinate scan destinations, access and running costs for multiple users. If scans contain personal data, the school must take appropriate steps to protect it; the Dutch Data Protection Authority explains these requirements for schools.

What should you look for in an all-in-one printer?

Compare scanning features separately from printing features: feeding loose originals, text recognition, shared access and printing costs each answer a different question.

Requirement What to look for when buying Who is this most relevant to?
Processing lots of loose, double-sided pages Check the ADF capacity and whether it explicitly scans both sides. An ADF is designed for loose sheets; assess bound originals separately. If I’m processing stacks of articles, I don’t want to turn every sheet over by hand. Around 36% of consumers rank scanning stacks as their main concern when buying.
Finding text in scans Check whether OCR or searchable PDF output is available through your preferred scanning route, and test it with your own documents if possible. If I want to search for words in scanned articles later, a standard image scan isn’t enough. Around 29% of consumers put searchable documents first.
Sharing scans and handling documents carefully Agree network connectivity, scan destination and user permissions with the administrator. Apply the institution’s protective measures when handling personal data. If several people use the same device, I want to know where scans go and who can access them. Around 21% of consumers give shared access and a suitable workflow top priority.
Colour requirements and running costs Decide whether you need colour prints and compare the purchase price and consumables for the same expected print volume. If I need colour, I also want to understand the cost of ink or toner. Around 14% of consumers put colour and running costs first.

What to watch out for when scanning publications

  • Assuming an ADF or duplex printing means double-sided scanning

    A sheet feeder and double-sided printing don’t confirm that the ADF scans both sides of an original. Consumentenbond recommends checking this scanning feature separately.

    Look specifically for double-sided scanning via the ADF in the model specifications, not just duplex printing.

    Without this feature, you may need to turn double-sided originals over by hand and put them back in order.

  • Assuming a PDF scan contains searchable text

    A PDF scan may simply be an image of a page; that doesn’t automatically mean the text is searchable.

    Check whether your preferred scanning route offers OCR or searchable PDF, and try it with a representative article.

    If text recognition isn’t part of your preferred workflow, you may need to spend extra time processing scans with OCR or searching manually later.

  • Looking only at the purchase price

    The ink, toner and other consumables you need affect running costs. Savings quoted by a manufacturer aren’t guaranteed for every print volume.

    Compare models for the same expected volume and factor in the consumables you’ll need.

    Ink, toner and any other consumables are ongoing costs; what you need depends on the model.

  • Sharing scans without checking permissions and access

    According to the Dutch government, permission is required to make and share digital copies of copyrighted publications. If personal data is involved, the school must also put appropriate safeguards in place.

    Before sharing, check the publication’s rights and the institution’s policy. For personal data, restrict access in line with that policy.

Brands to consider

Brother

Brother offers models for both mono scans of loose sheets and colour printing with an ADF.

  • Brother specifies a 50-sheet ADF and double-sided scanning for the MFC-L5710DW. For the DCP-L8410CDW, Brother lists a 50-sheet ADF and scan destinations including OCR; the information provided doesn’t confirm that the ADF on this model scans both sides.
  • The MFC-L5710DW is a mono laser printer. Check that the scan destination for each model is compatible with your school network.

Epson

The EcoTank ET-4950 is an ink-tank all-in-one with colour features and an ADF that Epson says scans both sides.

  • Epson lists double-sided scanning and printing, as well as colour copying and scanning, for this model.
  • The savings and ink yield advertised by Epson depend on the terms and how you use the printer. Compare costs based on your expected print volume.

Canon

The i-SENSYS MF465dw II is an example of a business mono laser printer with document scanning formats.

  • Canon lists searchable PDF output for this model.
  • The Canon Netherlands Store listed the model as discontinued and unavailable. Its specifications should therefore not be taken as evidence that it is currently available.

HP

The LaserJet Pro MFP 4102fdw is a mono all-in-one designed for shared use.

  • HP says this model is suitable for teams of up to 10 people.
  • HP warns that its dynamic security may block cartridges containing a non-HP chip. Keep this restriction in mind when comparing consumables.

Joybuy products for colour and single-sided scans

These Joybuy product picks are colour all-in-ones for colour printing and feeding loose sheets through an ADF. They are not suitable if you need automatic double-sided scanning via the ADF.

HP Smart Tank 7305 Wireless All-in-One colour printer

HP Smart Tank 7305 Wireless All-in-One colour printer

Suitable for colour printing and scanning loose sheets in batches, but not for automatic double-sided scanning via the ADF.

The product information lists a 35-sheet ADF, colour scanning, PDF output and scanning to software or an email server. Double-sided printing is listed; double-sided scanning isn’t available.

Wi-Fi and the HP Smart app are also listed.

View at Joybuy
HP Smart Tank 7005 Wireless All-in-One colour printer

HP Smart Tank 7005 Wireless All-in-One colour printer

Suitable for colour printing and scanning loose sheets; choose another model if you need double-sided originals to be scanned automatically via the ADF.

The product information lists colour scanning, PDF output and Wi-Fi. Double-sided scanning isn’t available.

Scanning via the HP Smart app is also listed.

View at Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

Is double-sided printing the same as double-sided scanning?

No. Check the ADF’s duplex function separately: Consumentenbond lists double-sided scanning as a separate feature to check when buying a printer with a scanner.

How can I make scanned articles searchable later?

Choose a scanning route with OCR or searchable PDF output, and check the results using your own documents. Brother lists scan-to-OCR for the DCP-L8410CDW and Canon lists searchable PDF for the i-SENSYS MF465dw II; these features don’t guarantee perfect text recognition.

What should I check when setting up a printer for shared use?

Agree network connectivity, scan destination and user permissions with the administrator. If documents contain personal data, the school must be able to demonstrate that it has appropriate technical and organisational measures in place for processing it.

Which costs will keep coming up after I’ve bought it?

Compare ink or toner and any other consumables based on your expected print volume. Consumentenbond takes the cost per print into account when assessing printers; the consumables you need vary by model.

Can a school share scanned research publications with the class?

Not automatically. According to the Dutch government, permission is required to make and share digital copies of copyrighted publications; an applicable reprographic rights scheme may cover use within an institution. Check the rights and the institution’s terms, as well as those of the specific publication, before sharing scans.