Who is this choice relevant to?

If you keep recipes in bound booklets

You want to capture pages from recipe booklets without taking them apart. So first check whether the exact model has a flatbed scanner.

If you also collect loose recipes

You regularly scan loose sheets as well as booklets. An ADF can help with this, but it won’t replace a flatbed scanner for a bound notebook. Canon Netherlands and Brother Netherlands list a 20-sheet ADF for the PIXMA TR4755i and DCP-J1360DW respectively.

If you print regularly at home

If you often print recipes and other documents too, your choice between cartridges and refillable ink also matters. Compare the options based on how much you print.

What should you look for when buying?

First check how the printer scans bound pages, then look at how it handles loose sheets. Next, consider how much you print and decide whether image scans are enough or whether you need text recognition.

What to consider What should you check? Who should pay particular attention?
Bound booklets Check whether the exact model has a flatbed scanner and supports the page size you need. Look at the optical scan resolution, not the print resolution. If you want to scan recipes without removing pages from the booklet, this feature is essential; around 39% of consumers give bound booklets top priority.
Loose sheets Check whether there’s an ADF, how many sheets the model can handle and whether it also has a flatbed scanner for booklets. Canon Netherlands and Brother Netherlands each list a 20-sheet ADF for the PIXMA TR4755i and DCP-J1360DW. If you regularly scan loose recipes or documents for a home office, you’ll want to spend less time feeding sheets in by hand; around 23% of consumers prioritise loose sheets.
Ink for printing Compare cartridges and refillable ink based on how many colour and black-and-white pages you expect to print, and which refills are compatible. The Consumers’ Association (Consumentenbond) highlights ink costs as something to consider; Epson Netherlands qualifies its savings claim with certain conditions. If you print regularly as well as scan, you’ll want to choose an ink system that suits your needs; around 23% of consumers put printing costs ahead of other considerations.
Handwriting recognition Decide whether an image scan is enough. If you need searchable text, check the software for the exact model and test it with representative handwritten pages. If you want to find recipes later by searching handwritten text, bear in mind that recognition errors can occur; around 15% of consumers give searchable handwriting top priority.

Common pitfalls

  • Confusing an ADF with a book scanner

    An ADF feeds in loose documents; to scan pages from a bound notebook, you use a flatbed scanner. So an ADF alone isn’t enough for this type of scanning.

    Before you buy, check the specifications for the exact model to make sure it has a flatbed scanner.

    Without a suitable flatbed scanner, you may have to do extra scanning by hand or choose another solution.

  • Assuming an ink claim tells you the total running costs

    The overall cost also depends on how much you print and which cartridges or refills are compatible with the model. Epson Netherlands qualifies its savings claim with certain conditions; that claim alone doesn’t tell you what it will cost your household.

    Compare the purchase price, compatible refills and your expected print volume on a like-for-like basis.

    You’ll need compatible cartridges or refill ink to use the printer; your consumption depends on how much you print and what you print.

  • Expecting OCR to convert handwriting perfectly

    A scan saves the page as an image, but text recognition can misread handwriting. Canon warns in the IJ Scan Utility manual that handwritten text may not be recognised correctly.

    Keep the original scan and test the text recognition you need with your own handwriting.

    Incorrect recognition can mean spending time correcting recipes by hand or adding search terms.

Relevant printer brands

Canon

The PIXMA TR4755i is worth considering if you switch between bound booklets and loose sheets.

  • Canon Netherlands lists a flatbed scanner, a 20-sheet ADF and an optical scan resolution of 600 × 1200 dpi for this model.
  • The model uses two FINE cartridges. The ADF doesn’t replace the flatbed scanner for bound booklets.

Brother

The DCP-J1360DW is a multifunction colour inkjet printer with a document feeder, making it an interesting option if you also handle loose sheets.

  • Brother lists a 20-sheet ADF, automatic double-sided printing and 2.4/5 GHz Wi-Fi.
  • Before buying, check whether the exact model has a flatbed scanner if you want to scan bound booklets.

Epson

The EcoTank ET-2951 is a multifunction A4 printer with a refillable ink tank, aimed at people who print regularly as well as scan.

  • Epson Netherlands lists printing, copying and scanning. The manufacturer claims that it can reduce printing costs, subject to certain conditions.
  • That claim doesn’t determine the total cost for your print volume. Also check whether the exact model has a flatbed scanner.

HP

HP offers Smart Tank models with flatbed scanners and OfficeJet Pro models with document-feeder options; the specific version determines what you get.

  • HP lists flatbed scanners for the Smart Tank 580/5000/5100 and 7000 series, and document feeders for the OfficeJet Pro 8120 series.
  • Series information doesn’t automatically confirm the configuration of every individual model. Check the specifications for the version you choose.

Joybuy products

This selection focuses on scanning bound recipes and loose sheets at home, with models for people who also print.

HP Smart Tank 7305 Wireless All-in-One Colour Printer

HP Smart Tank 7305

This model is suited to scanning bound recipes and printing as well.

Double-sided printing, copying and scanning.

Loose sheets need to be fed in by hand; this model doesn’t have an ADF.

View at Joybuy
Canon PIXMA MG2556S Inkjet A4 4800 x 600 DPI

Canon PIXMA MG2556S

An option for scanning, printing and copying at home; if you want to digitise bound booklets, check that this exact version has a flatbed scanner.

A4 inkjet printer; the product name lists 4800 × 600 dpi.

View at Joybuy
Epson EcoTank ET-M16680 Inkjet A3 4800 x 1200 DPI Wi-Fi

Epson EcoTank ET-M16680

This model is aimed at handling loose documents and regular printing. Before choosing it for bound booklets, check whether the exact model also has a flatbed scanner.

A3 inkjet printer; the product name lists 4800 × 1200 dpi and Wi-Fi.

View at Joybuy
Epson EcoTank ET-5185 Inkjet A4 4800 x 1200 DPI 37 ppm Wi-Fi

Epson EcoTank ET-5185

This model suits loose documents and regular printing. If you want to scan booklets, check whether the exact model has a flatbed scanner.

A4 inkjet printer; the product name lists 4800 × 1200 dpi, 37 ppm and Wi-Fi.

View at Joybuy
HP Smart Tank 7005 Wireless All-in-One Colour Printer

HP Smart Tank 7005

This model is suited to scanning bound pages and loose documents; check the scanning features listed for this exact version.

Double-sided printing, copying and scanning.

View at Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

Can I feed a bound recipe booklet through the automatic document feeder?

Use the flatbed scanner for pages from a bound booklet, if your chosen model has one, and scan one page at a time. An ADF is designed for loose sheets and doesn’t replace a flatbed scanner.

Will handwritten recipes automatically become searchable text?

Don’t count on it without testing first. Canon warns in an IJ Scan Utility manual that handwritten text may not be recognised correctly; check the software for the model you choose and try it with your own handwriting.

What should I check during setup and everyday use?

Check that the software and connection work with your computer or phone, and review your first scan before scanning a whole notebook. Follow the manual for your model when using the flatbed scanner and ADF.

Who should I contact if my printer is faulty?

For a consumer purchase in the Netherlands, the seller is responsible for providing a solution if there’s a problem with a product, according to the Rijksoverheid. Whether additional cover offers anything extra depends on the rights it provides beyond your existing statutory rights.

Where can I take an old printer?

The Rijksoverheid lists several options for disposing of old household appliances, including the shop or online service where you buy a new, similar appliance, a collection point and your local council recycling centre.