For group minutes, an all-in-one printer with an automatic document feeder (ADF) is useful for handling stacks of loose pages. However, if your originals are double-sided, check separately whether the model can scan both sides automatically. The Dutch Consumers’ Association points out that an ADF saves you from placing loose sheets on the glass one at a time. Scanning to PDF does not automatically create searchable text: you need OCR for that, and you should test handwriting recognition with your own documents. If minutes contain personal data, decide who should have access and how long scans will be kept; the Dutch Data Protection Authority stresses that personal data must be appropriately protected.
Who is this choice for?
Secretary dealing with stacks of minutes
Digitises several loose pages after meetings and wants to know in advance whether double-sided originals are fed automatically. The Dutch Consumers’ Association recommends looking for an automatic document feeder when handling loose sheets.
Group archive manager
Wants to be able to find scans, manage access for the right people and handle names and other personal data carefully. Adobe distinguishes between a scan saved as an image and text that can be searched using OCR.
Treasurer who also prints
Wants to weigh up the printer, the ink or toner it needs and expected print usage together. The Dutch Consumers’ Association points out that your printing habits also affect how you use a printer.
What should you look for when buying?
| What to consider |
What should you check? |
Who is this important for? |
| Stacks of loose pages |
Check whether there’s an ADF, how many sheets it can handle according to the specifications, and which paper size it supports. |
If I need to process a stack of loose pages after a meeting, I don’t want to place each sheet on the glass individually. An ADF is the top buying priority for around 29% of consumers. |
| Double-sided originals |
Check the exact model for an explicit mention of double-sided scanning, and make sure it fits the workflow you need. |
If my meeting papers are printed on both sides, I don’t want to keep turning them over myself. Double-sided scanning is the top buying priority for around 23% of consumers. |
| Searchable scans |
Check whether it can output PDFs and which OCR software is needed; if necessary, try it with representative notes of your own. |
If I want to search minutes later or reuse the text, I want to know whether the chosen software can handle our documents. Searchability is the top buying priority for around 18% of consumers. |
| Running costs |
Compare your own print volume and proportion of colour pages with the suitable ink or toner and any parts that need to be replaced separately. |
If the group prints regularly, I want to choose consumables that suit our own black-and-white and colour usage. Running costs are the top buying priority for around 18% of consumers. |
| Access to minutes |
Check where scans are stored, who can open them and how long they’re needed for. This is particularly important if they contain personal data. |
If minutes contain names or other personal data, I want to be able to decide who can view the files and how long they’re kept. Access management is the top buying priority for around 12% of consumers. |
Common buying mistakes
-
Confusing double-sided printing with double-sided scanning
These are separate features. A mention of automatic double-sided printing doesn’t confirm that the printer scans both sides of an original.
Check the scanning features of the exact model before making double-sided minutes a regular part of your workflow.
Without double-sided scanning, you’ll spend extra time turning originals over by hand.
-
Looking only at the purchase price
Running costs also depend on your own printing habits. The Brother MFC-L2800DW has toner and drum units that are replaced separately.
For the expected number of black-and-white and colour pages, compare the suitable consumables and any parts that need to be replaced separately.
Depending on the model, maintenance or a print subscription may also add to the cost of use.
-
Assuming a PDF scan contains searchable text
Adobe explains that a standard scan to PDF may contain image data rather than searchable text; you need an OCR step to make the text searchable.
Try the complete scanning and OCR workflow with a representative set of meeting minutes, then check the recognised text.
Allow time to check and correct the recognition results. Depending on the workflow you choose, you may need OCR software.
-
Sharing or keeping scans containing personal data indefinitely
If minutes contain personal data, the group must protect access appropriately and set a retention period that fits the purpose.
Before you start using the system, decide who will have access, where scans will be stored and when they’ll no longer be needed.
Brands to consider
Brother
The MFC-L2800DW is an example of a black-and-white laser printer suited to text and stacks of loose pages.
- Brother specifies a 50-sheet ADF for this model, as well as toner and drum units that can be replaced separately.
- This model doesn’t print in colour. Double-sided printing doesn’t confirm that it can scan both sides automatically.
HP
The OfficeJet Pro 9132e is a colour inkjet printer with an ADF and specified double-sided scanning.
- HP specifies automatic double-sided scanning for this model.
- Check the terms and conditions for HP+ and any printing services. HP also specifies dynamic cartridge protection for this model.
Epson
The EcoTank ET-4950 combines refillable ink with a double-sided ADF, according to Epson.
- The specified double-sided scanning feature is available on the ET-4950.
- Don’t assume the older ET-4850 has this feature. Epson’s claims about ink savings are manufacturer claims, not measured savings for a specific group.
Canon
The MAXIFY GX4050 is a colour ink-tank printer with an ADF.
- Canon specifies that the ADF can hold 35 A4 sheets.
- A specified simplex scanning speed doesn’t confirm that the ADF scans both sides automatically. Automatic double-sided printing is a different feature.
Joybuy products
This selection features colour printers with scanning and refillable ink. Check that each model’s paper-feed and PDF features suit your documents.
No image available
HP Smart Tank 7305 Wireless All-in-One colour printer
The 35-sheet ADF can be useful for stacks of loose minutes; this model doesn’t scan both sides automatically.
Colour printing, refillable ink bottles, wireless connectivity and PDF support.
Double-sided printing is specified, but this doesn’t confirm double-sided scanning.
Joybuy
No image available
HP Smart Tank 7005 Wireless All-in-One colour printer
Worth considering if your group wants to print in colour and save scans as PDFs, without automatic double-sided scanning.
Colour printing, refillable ink bottles, wireless connectivity and support for the HP Smart app.
Double-sided printing is specified; the model doesn’t scan both sides of originals automatically.
Joybuy
Frequently asked questions
Can an ADF also scan the back of minutes automatically?
Not necessarily. Look specifically for double-sided scanning on the exact model; double-sided printing is a different feature. HP specifies this for the OfficeJet Pro 9132e, and Epson specifies a double-sided ADF for the ET-4950.
Will handwritten minutes become searchable automatically after scanning?
No. A standard PDF scan may contain image data; you need OCR to create searchable text. Test whether the software you’ve chosen can recognise handwriting in your own notes, rather than assuming it can based on the printer’s scan-to-PDF feature.
How should you compare maintenance and printing costs?
Compare the expected number of pages and the proportion printed in colour with the suitable ink or toner and any parts that need to be replaced separately. The Dutch Consumers’ Association points out that, with some inkjet printers, printing infrequently can mean that a relatively large amount of ink is used for cleaning. This isn’t a guaranteed outcome for every model.
What rules apply to scanned minutes that include members’ names?
If minutes contain personal data, the GDPR applies to how that data is processed. The Dutch Data Protection Authority says that security must be appropriate and personal data must not be kept for longer than necessary. The GDPR doesn’t set a general retention period in days or years. So decide who needs access, where scans will be stored and what retention period suits the purpose.