Notebook keeper
You want to digitise stories from notebooks or other bound originals without feeding them through an automatic document feeder. Brother Netherlands describes scanning bound documents using a flatbed scanner.
For bound stories, an all-in-one printer with a flatbed scanner is the obvious choice; an ADF can save time when handling suitable loose pages. If the shared desk needs to handle both types of original, look for a model with both a flatbed scanner and an ADF, and check separately whether duplex scanning is supported. Don’t assume that standard OCR will turn handwriting into editable text, and check the scan destination and the cost of ink or toner too.
You want to digitise stories from notebooks or other bound originals without feeding them through an automatic document feeder. Brother Netherlands describes scanning bound documents using a flatbed scanner.
You regularly scan loose pages and want to know whether an ADF can handle a stack and, if needed, scan both sides. The Consumers’ Association recommends checking whether the ADF scans both sides if you need that feature.
Several people use the same device. You want scans to go to the right place and personal documents to be properly protected. The Dutch Data Protection Authority emphasises the importance of protecting documents when working from home.
Choose this option: if you mainly want to keep scans of notebooks, bound stories or delicate loose pages.
Bear in mind: you’ll need to place pages on the scanner one at a time. Also check the flatbed size and how to combine scans into a single file.
Choose this option: if you scan both bound stories and stacks of suitable loose pages at the same desk.
Bear in mind: the ADF doesn’t replace the flatbed scanner. Check paper sizes, feeder capacity, and whether the ADF scans one side or both.
Choose a colour model: if you also want to print coloured notes in colour. A black-and-white laser is suitable if monochrome printing is all you need.
Bear in mind: print technology alone says nothing about the quality of handwritten scans. Compare consumables based on how much you print.
| Key consideration | What to look for when buying | Who is this important for? |
|---|---|---|
| Bound or delicate originals | Check the flatbed size and, if possible, make a test scan to see whether pencil lines and coloured notes are clear. | If I want to keep a notebook or delicate page without feeding it through a document feeder, a flatbed scanner matters; around 36% of consumers prioritise bound or delicate originals. |
| Large numbers of loose pages | Check the ADF capacity, which originals it can handle, and whether duplex scanning is explicitly supported. | When I have a stack of loose stories, I don’t want to feed in each sheet separately; around 29% of consumers prioritise processing loose pages efficiently. |
| Scans at a shared desk | Check which scan destinations the exact model supports and how users can save files in the right place. | When several people use the same printer, I want to stop personal files ending up with the wrong user; around 21% of consumers prioritise shared access and file protection. |
| Colour and printing costs | Decide whether you need colour, then compare compatible ink or toner and any separate maintenance parts based on the same expected print volume. | If I mainly want to scan but also print, I want to factor consumables into my choice; around 14% of consumers prioritise printing costs. |
These are different features. The Canon PIXMA TS7750i is listed as supporting automatic double-sided printing, while its ADF is specified as single-sided.
If you need it, look for explicit confirmation of double-sided scanning via the ADF in the specifications.
Without this scanning feature, you may have to turn over written pages by hand.
A scan saves an image; standard OCR shouldn’t be assumed to convert handwriting into editable text. HP Support says that the ScanJet OCR discussed here can’t convert handwriting.
First, save a legible scan. Then test any handwriting recognition separately using representative pages and the software you plan to use.
Transcription and checking may take extra time.
Ink, toner and any separate maintenance parts all add to the cost if you use the printer for printing. Brother lists toner and a separate drum for the MFC-L2800DW.
Compare the total cost based on how much you expect to print; don’t count scanning as printing.
Depending on the model, you may need refills and a separate maintenance part.
The MAXIFY GX4050 is an example of a colour ink-tank printer with both a flatbed scanner and an ADF.
The EcoTank ET-4950 is a colour ink-tank printer with an ADF that Epson says can scan both sides.
The MFC-L2800DW is a black-and-white laser option for anyone who doesn’t need colour prints.
The Smart Tank 7005 and 7305 show two versions of a colour ink-tank printer with scanning.
This selection of Joybuy products includes models for bound originals and, where specified, loose pages. Check that the version you choose has the scanning feature you need.
No image available
The flatbed scanner is suitable for bound stories, while the ADF can make it easier to feed suitable loose pages.
The description lists a 35-sheet ADF, Wi-Fi and scanning to PDF. Duplex scanning isn’t available, so double-sided originals need to be turned over by hand.
No image available
The product description lists printing, scanning and copying. Check that the connection options are compatible with the computers used at the shared desk.
Colour inkjet, A4 and USB 2.0.
No image available
Before buying, check that this version has the scanning feature you need. Don’t choose it for digitising until that’s been confirmed.
A4 colour inkjet printer with Wi-Fi.
No image available
The flatbed scanner can scan bound stories one page at a time. This version has no ADF, so loose pages need to be placed on the glass individually.
The description lists scanning to PDF, Wi-Fi and use of the HP Smart app.
Don’t assume it can: a standard scan saves an image, and standard OCR doesn’t guarantee handwriting recognition. HP Support says that the ScanJet OCR discussed here can’t convert handwriting. First, save a legible scan, then test any handwriting recognition using your own pages and the software you want to use.
Use the flatbed scanner for a bound story and the ADF for a stack of suitable loose pages. Check the feeder requirements for the exact model, and don’t feed delicate originals through it without checking first.
Set your preferred scan destination and make a test scan to check where the file appears. Protect paper and digital documents containing personal information too; the Dutch Data Protection Authority emphasises document protection when working from home.
Compare compatible ink or toner and any separate maintenance parts based on how much you expect to print. According to the Dutch government, many online purchases from a business come with a 14-day cooling-off period; check which terms and exceptions apply to your purchase.