Who is this choice relevant to?

Keeper of fragile originals

If you look after loose sheets or collections of poems, you won’t want to damage them while digitising them. The US National Archives warns that fragile, weak or curled paper is not suitable for automatic feeding.

Volunteer archiving poems

If you’re digitising poems, you’ll want to preserve the words and line breaks clearly. The KB, the national library of the Netherlands, explains how scan quality can affect text recognition; ABBYY notes that handwriting recognition depends on support for the handwriting in question.

Coordinator of a larger collection

If you’re processing lots of suitable loose sheets and also printing for a group, you’ll need to weigh ease of feeding against the condition of the originals and expected print usage. Brother Netherlands lists a document feeder for 20 pages on one model; the Consumers’ Association notes that infrequent printing with inkjet printers can mean relatively more ink is used for cleaning.

What should you consider when choosing?

First assess the condition and format of the poems, then decide what scan files you need. After that, consider the convenience of processing a stack and the cost of printing. The US National Archives advises against automatic feeding for fragile, weak or curled paper originals.

What to consider What should you check? Who should pay particular attention?
Protecting fragile sheets Check that the entire loose sheet fits on the flatbed. Use an ADF only for flat, sturdy sheets that are suitable for it. If I’m scanning fragile or valuable originals, I don’t want to feed them through rollers. Around 33% of consumers prioritise protecting originals.
A legible digital archive Check the colour and file options for the exact model, and scan a sample of handwriting, punctuation and line breaks. I want to be able to see the text and its original layout without relying on perfect recognition. Around 27% of consumers prioritise a legible, faithful archive.
Processing stacks of sheets Check the ADF capacity and supported paper sizes. Don’t feed fragile, curled or valuable sheets automatically. If I have lots of sturdy loose sheets to scan, I don’t want to place each one individually. Around 20% of consumers prioritise processing suitable stacks.
Printing costs Compare your own number of black-and-white and colour prints and the cost of compatible refills. Don’t treat a stated ink yield as a cost calculation for the group. For regular group collections, I want to know what our actual printing needs will cost. Around 20% of consumers put printing costs first.

Common pitfalls

  • Choosing an ADF for every original because it saves time

    Automatic feeding is unsuitable for fragile, weak or curled paper. An original could jam or be damaged.

    Damage could make a unique sheet unusable; repairs or rescanning would also take extra time.

    Sort the collection by condition. Scan suitable sturdy sheets with the ADF, and handle fragile sheets separately using an appropriate setup.

  • Assuming a scan or OCR is an accurate transcription

    A scan is an image; text recognition is a separate step. The KB, the national library of the Netherlands, notes that lower scan quality can make text recognition more difficult. ABBYY also explains that recognition depends on support for the handwriting in question.

    Allow time to check words, punctuation and line breaks manually.

    Keep the scanned image and test any handwriting recognition on representative poems before processing the whole collection.

  • Comparing only the purchase price

    Costs also depend on how often the group prints and which colours it uses. According to the Consumers’ Association, infrequent printing can mean that relatively more ink is used for cleaning.

    Factor in refills and any ink used for cleaning; the impact depends on the model and how it’s used.

    Estimate the expected number of prints and compare running costs with your own printing frequency, not just a stated ink yield.

  • Assuming you can share scans of poems freely

    Digitising a poem doesn’t automatically give you permission to share someone else’s work. Personal data in documents also needs to be considered before files are shared.

    Before sharing, check who owns the rights and what the permission covers. Also check what personal data is visible and whether there is an appropriate legal basis for sharing it.

Brands to consider

Epson

The EcoTank ET-2871 is an A4 all-in-one printer with an ink tank and flatbed scanner; Epson lists a scan resolution of 1,200 × 2,400 dpi.

  • The flatbed may suit loose originals that fit on the glass.
  • The scan resolution and ink claims are product specifications or statements from Epson, not a guarantee of a particular result with handwritten poems.

Brother

The MFC-J4350DW is an all-in-one colour inkjet printer. Brother Netherlands lists an automatic document feeder for 20 pages.

  • The feeder may be useful for suitable loose stacks.
  • A stated feeder capacity doesn’t mean fragile originals can be fed safely through the ADF. Check the scanning setup for the exact model too.

Canon

Canon lists both a flatbed scanner and an ADF for the PIXMA TR4755i, with an optical scan resolution of 600 × 1,200 dpi.

  • Canon gives the ADF a capacity of up to 20 A4 or Letter sheets.
  • Use the feeder only for suitable sheets; the specification doesn’t prove that every type of handwritten original can be processed safely.

HP

According to HP, the Smart Tank 7305 is an all-in-one ink tank printer with an automatic document feeder.

  • Could be worth considering if the group also prints regularly and processes suitable loose sheets.
  • A print volume stated by HP doesn’t measure how suitable the printer is for these poems or what it will actually cost the group.

Joybuy product picks

These Joybuy product picks are suited to printing and scanning for group projects. Check that the exact model has the scanning functions, scanning method and file options you need.

HP Smart Tank 7305 Wireless All-in-One Colour Printer

HP Smart Tank 7305 Wireless All-in-One Colour Printer

The listed flatbed scanner may suit originals that need to be placed individually. Check that the scanning area is large enough for the poems.

The product information lists colour scanning, a flatbed and ADF, a scanning area of 216 × 297 mm and PDF support. The stated ADF capacity is 35 sheets for suitable loose originals.

View at Joybuy
Canon PIXMA MG2556S A4 inkjet printer

Canon PIXMA MG2556S A4 Inkjet Printer

The product information lists printing, scanning and copying, so this model may be an option for a straightforward scanning and printing workflow.

The title lists A4 and 4800 × 600 dpi. Before buying, check which scanning methods and file formats this exact model supports.

View at Joybuy
Epson WorkForce Pro WF-C5390DW A4 colour Wi-Fi inkjet printer

Epson WorkForce Pro WF-C5390DW Inkjet Printer Colour A4 Wi-Fi

The product name describes an A4 colour printer with Wi-Fi. Before buying, check whether this exact model has the scanning function the group needs.

The title lists 4800 × 1200 dpi; don’t assume this indicates a particular scan resolution.

View at Joybuy
HP Smart Tank 7005 Wireless All-in-One Colour Printer

HP Smart Tank 7005 Wireless All-in-One Colour Printer

The product information lists a flatbed scanner, colour scanning and PDF support. Check that the glass is large enough for your originals.

The listed scanning area is 216 × 297 mm. The product title also mentions printing and copying.

View at Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

Will handwritten poems automatically become searchable text when we scan them?

No. A standard scan is an image; text recognition is a separate step. The result depends on factors including the scan and the original. Check words, punctuation and line breaks manually.

How should we scan fragile sheets or a bound notebook?

Don’t feed fragile, weak or curled sheets through automatically. Make sure a loose sheet fits entirely on the flatbed. Don’t force a bound notebook flat; consider using a suitable camera setup instead.

How can we keep the printing costs for group collections under control?

Compare costs with your own print volume and colour requirements, not just the purchase price or a stated ink yield. The Consumers’ Association points out that inkjet printers can use ink for cleaning when printing is infrequent.

Can we freely share or publish scans of poems by group members?

Not automatically. According to the Dutch government and Auteursrecht.nl, a private copy for personal use doesn’t give you general permission to share a protected poem in a group collection or on a website. If a scan contains personal data, you’ll also need to establish an appropriate legal basis under the GDPR and check the document before sharing it. What’s required depends on the work, the rights holder, the data and the intended use.

What warranty or service options should we check?

Before buying, check the warranty terms, available support and consumables for the exact model. A manufacturer’s warranty or possible extension applies only under the terms stated for that model and offer.