Who is this choice relevant to?

Scanning on a small desk

You want to know whether the printer will not only fit, but also be practical to use when you open the lid or load paper. Canon gives dimensions for the PIXMA TR4755i with the trays retracted, so remember to measure the space needed when it is in use too.

Keeping delicate letters safe

You would rather scan old, folded or damaged letters individually than feed them through an ADF. For the models covered by its instructions, Brother warns against feeding items including folded and torn paper. Follow the manual for your own printer.

Scanning stacks of loose documents

You also regularly process ordinary loose sheets as well as letters, and want to spend less time placing pages by hand. Canon and Brother list an ADF capacity of up to 20 sheets for the models mentioned.

What should you look for?

Compact cartridge printer

Best for: scanning individual letters occasionally and looking for a multifunction printer that fits on your desk.

The trade-off: with a flatbed scanner, you place each letter yourself; if you print infrequently, ink used for cleaning and replacement cartridges can add to the cost.

Printer with flatbed scanner and ADF

Best for: scanning individual letters as well as regularly processing stacks of suitable, loose documents.

The trade-off: an ADF is not automatically suitable for delicate originals, and it does not mean the printer takes up less space.

Multifunction ink tank printer

Best for: scanning letters and printing regularly too, with refillable ink tanks as an important requirement.

The trade-off: the higher upfront cost is worth considering mainly if you print enough too; having an ink tank says nothing in itself about scan quality.

What to consider What should you check? Who is this most important for?
Usable desk space Measure the width, depth and height of the exact model. Also check the space needed for the open lid, paper feed and cables. I want to be able to use the printer without the lid or feeder hitting anything; around 36% of consumers put usable desk space first.
Delicate letters Check whether the model has a flatbed scanner and follow the manual’s guidance on which documents the ADF can handle. If my letter is folded or delicate, I want to be able to scan it separately; around 29% of consumers give preserving delicate letters top priority.
Stacks of documents Check the ADF capacity and which paper sizes and document conditions are permitted by the manual. I often scan several suitable loose sheets and don’t want to keep placing them one by one; around 21% of consumers prioritise scanning stacks.
Printing costs Estimate how much you print and compare suitable ink or cartridges, along with any subscription terms for the exact model. If I print as well as scan, I want to know which ink option suits my needs; around 14% of consumers put printing costs first.

Avoid common buying mistakes

  • Assuming the closed dimensions are all the space you need

    Dimensions with the trays retracted don’t show how much room you need to open the lid and load paper.

    Before choosing a model, measure the available space as well as the room needed for the lid, feeder, cables and scanning.

    A printer may fit on the shelf but be awkward to use, meaning you need to rearrange your setup.

  • Putting every old letter through the ADF

    The automatic feeder is designed for suitable documents; instructions for the models they apply to may rule out folded or torn paper.

    Use the flatbed for delicate originals if available, and check the manual for the exact model before feeding paper through it.

    The wrong feeding method could damage an irreplaceable letter.

  • Looking only at the purchase price

    If you print too, ink or cartridges will add to the cost. The Consumentenbond also explains that an inkjet printer may use ink for cleaning if you print infrequently.

    Compare the ink options with how much you actually expect to print; don’t choose an ink tank solely for scanning.

    Replacement ink and cleaning can be recurring costs; the impact depends on the model and how you use it.

  • Assuming every cartridge will work

    HP describes dynamic security on the DeskJet 2920, which may block certain cartridges with modified or non-HP chips.

    Check which cartridges you want to use with the exact model and what HP says about them.

    This may limit your choice of refills.

Brands to compare

Canon

According to Canon, the PIXMA TR4755i combines a flatbed scanner with an ADF, making it an option if you want to scan individual letters as well as suitable stacks of documents.

  • Canon specifies an optical scan resolution of 600 × 1200 dpi and an ADF that holds up to 20 A4 sheets.
  • The stated dimensions of approximately 435 × 295 × 189 mm are with the trays retracted; measure the space required when the printer is in use.

Brother

According to Brother, the DCP-J1360DW combines printing, scanning and copying with a 20-sheet ADF.

  • A document feeder can be useful when scanning stacks of suitable loose sheets.
  • Don’t assume that the capacity means folded, torn or delicate letters are suitable. Check the DCP-J1360DW manual for this model’s paper restrictions.

Epson

The EcoTank ET-2871 is a multifunction printer with refillable ink tanks for those who print as well as scan.

  • Epson lists printing, scanning and copying functions for this model.
  • Epson’s claims about lower printing costs are manufacturer claims subject to conditions, and say nothing about scan quality. Check that the model and scanner setup suit your needs.

HP

HP describes the DeskJet 2920 as a compact multifunction printer for those who don’t consider an ADF essential.

  • HP lists printing, scanning and copying functions for this model.
  • HP describes dynamic cartridge security that may block certain cartridges with modified or non-HP chips, even after firmware updates. Check which refills you want to use beforehand.

Joybuy products

These multifunction printers are designed for scanning letters and other documents. Where the product information lists a flatbed scanner or ADF, that feature is described below for each model.

HP Smart Tank 7305 all-in-one printer

HP Smart Tank 7305 Wireless All-in-One

The stated flatbed scanner is suitable for scanning individual letters; the ADF is designed for suitable stacks of loose sheets.

The product information lists a flatbed scanner and a 35-sheet ADF.

View at Joybuy
Brother MFC-J6760DW A3 multifunction inkjet printer

Brother MFC-J6760DW A3 multifunction inkjet printer

The ADF capacity is useful if you scan stacks of suitable loose sheets as well as letters.

The product information lists a 50-sheet ADF and printing, scanning and copying functions. The title lists 1200 × 4800 dpi, 31 ppm and Wi-Fi.

View at Joybuy
HP Smart Tank 7005 all-in-one printer

HP Smart Tank 7005 Wireless All-in-One

The product information lists a flatbed scanner, which is suitable for placing letters on the scanner one at a time.

The model is described as a printer, scanner and copier. Check the space needed for the lid and paper feed at your own workstation.

View at Joybuy
Canon PIXMA MG2556S A4 inkjet printer

Canon PIXMA MG2556S A4 inkjet printer

The product information lists scanning, printing and copying functions for handling documents.

The title lists 4800 × 600 dpi. According to the product information, the paper tray holds 60 sheets; this is not a stated ADF capacity.

View at Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

Can I put a folded or torn letter through the automatic document feeder?

Don’t assume that you can without checking first. For the models covered by its instructions, Brother rules out items including folded and torn paper. If possible, use the flatbed for delicate letters and check the manual for your exact printer.

How can I stop my printer taking up too much space?

Measure not only the printer when closed, but also the space needed to open the scanner lid and load paper. Canon gives dimensions for the PIXMA TR4755i with the trays retracted, so those measurements alone don’t show the full space needed to use it.

Are searchable text and a good image of my handwriting the same thing?

No. If you use text recognition, keep and check the image of the letter too. In the manual for the LiDE 300, Canon warns that automatic text detection may be inaccurate with handwritten text; this is not a measured OCR result for the printers on this page.

What costs and rights should I consider when buying online?

If you print, compare the cost of suitable ink and any subscription terms too. According to the Dutch government, consumers buying online from a business generally have 14 days to change their mind. ACM ConsuWijzer also explains that the seller must resolve a problem if a product, when used normally, does not do what you were entitled to expect.

What can I do with my old printer?

According to Milieu Centraal, you can hand in an old, similar electrical appliance free of charge when you buy a new one. Your local council’s recycling centre is another option.