A flatbed scanner is handy for old photos and delicate papers, while an automatic document feeder is most useful for stacks of suitable loose sheets. Then choose based on your colour-printing needs and how often you’ll print after the school project. A printer’s stated print resolution alone doesn’t show how well it scans.
Who is this guide for?
If you want to preserve old family photos
A flatbed scanner lets you place photos and delicate papers on it one at a time. The Consumers’ Association assesses scans for factors including colour and photo quality, so check scan results for the materials you have rather than looking only at the stated print resolution.
If you want to digitise a stack of documents
An automatic document feeder can save you time when you have lots of loose pages that are suitable for it. If there’s text on both sides, check separately whether the model supports double-sided scanning.
If you’ll keep printing after the project
If you’ll also print schoolwork or other documents in future, factor in your colour-printing needs and print volume. The Consumers’ Association also notes that maintenance-related ink use can matter if you print infrequently.
What should you look for when buying?
Colour inkjet with flatbed scanner and ADF
Best for: Anyone who wants to scan delicate photos individually as well as feed suitable loose documents into the printer.
Trade-off: An ADF shouldn’t be the deciding factor when handling delicate originals. If you print infrequently, consider ink use and refill costs too.
Colour inkjet with refillable ink tanks
Best for: Anyone who’ll continue printing in colour regularly after the project and wants to factor in refill costs over the longer term.
Trade-off: A manufacturer’s savings claim doesn’t automatically tell you what will be cost-effective for your print volume. Check the scanning features of the exact model too.
Black-and-white laser all-in-one
Best for: Anyone who mainly scans loose documents and will mostly print in black and white afterwards.
Trade-off: A black-and-white model won’t print colour photos. Remember to factor in toner and any separate components when comparing running costs.
The Consumers’ Association assesses scans for factors including text, colour and photo quality. Compare the features of the exact model with the originals you have and the prints you need.
| What to consider |
What to look for |
Who is this important for? |
| Photos and delicate papers |
Check that the exact model has a flatbed scanner and look for scan reviews covering photos and colour. Check scans for legibility and missing edges. |
If I want to preserve old photos or delicate paper, I need to be able to place originals on the scanner one at a time and check the result. Around 36% of consumers say that carefully scanning delicate originals is their main consideration. |
| Loose documents |
Check the ADF capacity and compatible paper sizes. Look separately for confirmation that double-sided scanning is supported. |
If I have lots of suitable loose family papers, I don’t want to feed them in one page at a time. Around 29% of consumers focus mainly on handling a stack of documents. |
| Running costs after the project |
Compare the ink or toner that works with the model against your expected print volume. If you print infrequently, factor in maintenance-related ink use too. |
If I’ll continue using the printer regularly after the project, I want to consider refills and other consumables. Around 21% of consumers prioritise ongoing printing costs. |
| Print format for the project |
Check whether you need colour, which paper size is suitable and whether the model is compatible with the device you’ll print from. |
If my assignment requires colour images on paper, I want to make sure the printer supports that print format. Around 14% of consumers focus mainly on the print format required for their school project. |
Common pitfalls
-
Assuming print resolution proves photo-scanning quality
Printing and scanning are different functions. A stated print resolution doesn’t tell you how well a device scans photos.
Compare scan reviews for the type of original you want to digitise.
-
Letting the ADF be the deciding factor for delicate originals
A feeder for loose sheets isn’t a substitute for carefully placing delicate photos or papers on the flatbed scanner.
First decide which originals need to be scanned individually, then compare the ADF capacity for your other documents.
-
Looking only at the purchase price
Ink, toner and other replaceable components can also affect running costs. Compare the consumables for the exact model with how much you expect to use it.
The Brother DCP-L2660DW has a separate drum and toner, so factor both into your comparison.
Brands to consider
Canon
The PIXMA TR4755i is a colour inkjet model with a flatbed scanner and automatic document feeder. It’s for anyone who needs to scan both individual originals and suitable loose documents.
- Canon specifies an ADF for up to 20 A4 sheets and an optical scan resolution of 600 × 1200 dpi.
- Automatic double-sided printing doesn’t mean automatic double-sided scanning. Check for that scanning feature separately.
Epson
EcoTank models combine printing and scanning with refillable ink tanks. They may suit anyone who’ll continue printing in colour regularly after the project.
- Epson specifies refillable tanks for the EcoTank ET-2950.
- Epson’s cost-saving claim is based on the conditions of its own comparison and doesn’t guarantee savings for every print volume.
Brother
The DCP-L2660DW is a black-and-white laser all-in-one for text printing and loose documents.
- Brother specifies an automatic document feeder for 50 sheets and a separately replaceable drum.
- This model doesn’t print in colour, and its stated product specifications don’t prove it’s the best choice for photo scanning.
HP
According to HP, the Smart Tank 580 combines printing, copying and scanning. It may suit anyone who also wants to factor in future colour printing.
- HP specifies a flatbed scanner for the 580 series.
- Manual double-sided printing isn’t the same as automatic double-sided scanning. Check the features of the exact version.
Products on Joybuy
This selection includes printers for colour printing and individual scans, as well as models that specify a document feeder. For the Epson WorkForce Pro WF-C5390DW, first check whether the exact version also supports scanning.
No image available
HP Smart Tank 7305
The combination of a flatbed scanner and automatic document feeder may suit both individual originals and suitable stacks of documents.
The product description specifies an ADF for 35 sheets, refillable ink bottles and automatic double-sided printing. It doesn’t list automatic double-sided scanning as an available feature.
View on Joybuy
No image available
Canon PIXMA MG2556S
This model is listed as able to print, scan and copy, so it may suit a school project that also requires printed work.
The product name specifies A4 and 4800 × 600 dpi. The connection to a computer is listed as USB 2.0.
View on Joybuy
No image available
HP Smart Tank 7005
The flatbed scanner may suit anyone who wants to digitise photos and delicate papers one at a time.
The product description specifies colour printing and refillable ink bottles. It doesn’t list an automatic document feeder or automatic double-sided scanning as available features.
View on Joybuy
No image available
Epson WorkForce Pro WF-C5390DW
The product title describes an A4 colour inkjet printer. Before buying, check explicitly whether the exact version also has a scanner that meets your needs.
The product information specifies Wi-Fi and automatic double-sided printing. It weighs more than 15 kg; the product description recommends that two people lift it.
View on Joybuy
Frequently asked questions
Should old family photos go through the automatic document feeder?
Not as a general rule. It’s better to place delicate photos or papers individually on a suitable flatbed scanner and check the scan. Use the ADF for originals that the model specifications say are suitable.
Is automatic double-sided printing the same as double-sided scanning?
No. They’re different features. Check for each one separately on the exact model if your papers have printing on both sides.
What can I do if the printer doesn’t work properly after I buy it?
In the Netherlands, you’re entitled to a product that works as it should. According to the Government of the Netherlands, you can contact the seller if there’s a fault and ask them to put it right; an additional manufacturer’s warranty doesn’t replace this right. There’s no single fixed statutory warranty period for all products in the Netherlands.
Can a school publish identifiable photos of pupils from a project?
Not automatically. According to the Dutch Data Protection Authority, there are rules governing identifiable images taken and published by a school. Parental consent is required for pupils under 16; from the age of 16, pupils must give their own consent. This applies to publication by a school and doesn’t mean consent is needed for every private scan.
How can I make sure family information is easy to find after scanning?
Check that every page and edge is legible, give files clear names and store them in an organised way. The National Archives describes selecting, organising and describing records as part of digital archiving.