If you regularly scan piles of loose sheets, choose an all-in-one printer with an automatic document feeder. For delicate originals, a suitable flatbed is more important. Check duplex scanning separately from duplex printing, then choose between a colour inkjet, an ink-tank printer and a mono laser printer based on how much you print and the running costs.
Who has which scanning needs?
Family archivist with piles of paperwork
You want to digitise lots of loose family documents, some of which may be double-sided. The Consumers' Association distinguishes between automatic document feeding and duplex scanning as separate features to compare in an all-in-one printer.
Keeper of delicate originals
You occasionally scan old or delicate documents and prioritise a suitable flatbed and careful handling over speed. Canon describes a flatbed scanner as a way to scan delicate documents; check that the printer model you choose has a suitable flatbed.
Home user who prints infrequently
You want a scanner at home but don't print much. The Consumers' Association points out that cleaning cycles can use ink when an inkjet printer is used infrequently, so running costs matter alongside the stated page yield.
What should you look for when choosing?
First decide how you’ll scan your originals. Then check whether the printer has the colour and duplex features you need, and weigh its running costs against how often you print.
| What to consider |
What should you check? |
Who should pay particular attention? |
| Handling stacks of documents |
Check for an automatic document feeder (ADF) and whether automatic duplex scanning is explicitly listed. |
If I want to archive lots of loose family documents without handling every page separately, ease of processing stacks matters a great deal to me. Around 36% of consumers give this need top priority. |
| Delicate originals |
Check whether there’s a flatbed and whether its size suits your documents; a flatbed requires you to place each item by hand. |
I don’t want to feed old or delicate documents through a paper feeder, and would rather take a slower, manual approach. Around 29% of consumers put careful handling of originals first. |
| Costs when you print infrequently |
Consider how often you print and compare cartridges, refillable tanks or toner. The stated yield alone doesn’t tell you what irregular use will cost. |
If I mainly want to scan and only print occasionally, I make sure the printer suits how I’ll actually use it. Around 21% of consumers give the cost of infrequent printing top priority. |
| Colour printing |
Decide whether you also need colour printouts and check the cost of the relevant consumables. |
I want to print family documents in colour as well as scan them digitally, so I don’t choose based on scanning features alone. Around 14% of consumers put colour printing at the top of their list. |
Common buying mistakes
-
Confusing duplex printing with duplex scanning
These are separate features. A reference to duplex printing doesn’t mean the ADF automatically scans both sides of an original.
Check the scanning and ADF specifications for the exact model. Brother lists duplex printing for the DCP-L2660DW; Epson specifies a duplex ADF for the ET-4950.
-
Choosing an ink-tank printer based on stated yield alone
Cleaning cycles can also use ink if you print infrequently. The Consumers' Association highlights this as something to consider with limited inkjet use.
Compare the consumables with how often you expect to print. Treat a manufacturer's savings claims as dependent on the stated conditions, not as a guaranteed result for every household.
-
Automatically feeding every family document through the printer
An automatic paper feeder isn’t the right way to scan every delicate original. Canon describes a flatbed solution for delicate documents.
Separate loose sheets that are suitable for the feeder from documents you’d rather place individually on a suitable flatbed, and check that the printer model has one.
-
Assuming features and cartridges are the same across a printer range
HP distinguishes between ADF features across its OfficeJet Pro ranges. HP also sets out conditions relating to non-HP chipped cartridges for the 8122e.
Check the full model number, the scanning feature you need and the conditions for refills before choosing a model.
Printer brands to consider
Brother
The DCP-L2660DW is a mono option for anyone who scans documents and doesn’t need colour printouts.
- Brother specifies a 50-sheet ADF and a separate drum and toner for this model.
- The model prints in black and white. Duplex printing doesn’t confirm that the ADF scans both sides automatically.
Canon
The PIXMA TR7650 combines colour inkjet printing with an ADF for smaller stacks.
- Canon specifies a 20-sheet ADF and five separate inks for the TR7650.
- Check for duplex scanning and compare cartridge costs with how much you expect to print.
Epson
The EcoTank range includes all-in-one options such as the ET-2871, as well as the ET-4950 with a duplex ADF.
- Epson specifies refillable tanks and lists duplex ADF scanning for the ET-4950.
- Epson’s ink-saving claims apply under certain conditions and aren’t guaranteed results for every household. Epson lists the ET-4850 as discontinued.
HP
The OfficeJet Pro and Smart Tank ranges include colour models with different scanning and paper-feeding features.
- HP lists an ADF for the 8120 series and specifies a duplex ADF for the 9120 series.
- Don’t assume that every model in the range has these features. For the 8122e, also check HP’s conditions relating to cartridge chips and firmware.
Joybuy printers for scanning at home
These models print, copy and scan, but differ in colour, ink-tank or inkjet technology, document feeding and flatbed scanning. Check each model individually to make sure its scanning method suits your stacks of documents or delicate originals.
No image available
HP Smart Tank 7305 Wireless All-in-One
The specified ADF may suit stacks of loose documents; check duplex scanning separately.
Colour ink-tank printer with a 35-sheet ADF and automatic duplex printing.
View at Joybuy
No image available
Canon PIXMA MG2556S
A colour model with printing, copying and scanning functions; check that its scanning feed suits the documents you want to handle.
Inkjet, A4, 4800 × 600 dpi, 60-sheet input capacity and USB 2.0.
View at Joybuy
No image available
Epson EcoTank ET-5185
The automatic document feeder can be useful for scanning loose sheets one after another; duplex printing doesn’t automatically mean duplex scanning.
Ink-tank printer with an ADF, automatic duplex printing and wireless connections including Wi-Fi Direct and Apple AirPrint.
View at Joybuy
No image available
Epson EcoTank ET-M16680
The ADF and automatic duplex scanning are useful if you’re digitising stacks of double-sided text documents; this model only prints in black.
A3 ink-tank printer with an ADF and automatic duplex scanning.
View at Joybuy
No image available
HP Smart Tank 7005 Wireless All-in-One
The flatbed lets you scan individual pages by placing them on the glass; this model has no ADF and doesn’t scan both sides automatically.
Colour ink-tank printer with a flatbed scanner and printing, copying and scanning functions.
View at Joybuy
Frequently asked questions
Does duplex printing also mean duplex scanning?
No, these are separate features. Check explicitly whether the ADF scans both sides; Brother lists duplex printing for the DCP-L2660DW, while Epson specifies a duplex ADF for the ET-4950.
How do I scan delicate family documents?
Check whether the exact printer model has a suitable flatbed, and don’t use the document feeder for an original you don’t want to send through the paper path. Canon describes a separate flatbed solution for delicate documents; that doesn’t mean every printer model is suitable for this.
Do I need an automatic document feeder for a family archive?
An ADF can make it easier to scan loose sheets one after another, but it matters less if you mainly scan individual or delicate originals. Check the capacity and assess duplex scanning as a separate feature.
What should I look out for if I print infrequently?
Consider how often you print alongside the stated yield and the price of compatible consumables. The Consumers' Association points out that cleaning can use extra ink if you use an inkjet printer infrequently.
Can any printer create a searchable PDF?
Don’t assume so: OCR, which makes text in a scan searchable, is a separate feature. The Consumers' Association lists searchable PDF as a separate comparison feature; also check what software the exact model needs.