Who is this choice relevant to?

Keeper of old photos

You want to digitise loose photos or fragile paper without putting unnecessary strain on the originals. Handling them safely matters more than the speed of an automatic feeder.

Digitising loose documents

You have sturdy, loose sheets and want to know whether an automatic document feeder could save you time. If there’s text on both sides, check separately whether the model can scan both sides automatically.

Hobbyist who also prints

You want to make digital copies and also print documents or photos regularly. Your need for colour and the cost of ink or toner will also influence your choice.

What should you look for when buying?

Colour printer with flatbed and optional ADF

Suitable if: you scan both loose photos and sturdy documents, and also want to print in colour.

Trade-off: an automatic document feeder saves time with suitable sheets, but it isn’t suitable for fragile originals.

Colour printer with refillable ink tanks

Suitable if: you scan and also print in colour regularly, and want to factor refills into your decision.

Trade-off: manufacturers’ claims about ink consumption won’t necessarily predict your own costs. Factor in the purchase price and how much you print, too.

Monochrome laser printer with scanner

Suitable if: you mainly scan text documents and monochrome printing is enough.

Trade-off: this isn’t a solution for printing family photos in colour. With toner printers, also compare the cost of a separate drum, if applicable.

A different scanning set-up

Suitable if: a bound album can’t lie flat safely, an original won’t fit fully on the flatbed or an item is badly damaged.

Trade-off: a separate set-up may take up more space or involve more manual work, but it lets you choose a scanning method that suits the original.

First, work out how to scan your originals safely. Then compare the feeder, scanning features and printing supplies that suit the way you’ll use the printer.

What to consider What to look for Who it matters to
Fragile photos and papers Check that the entire original fits on the flatbed. Don’t use an automatic feeder for fragile, curled or valuable paper. If I’m scanning old photos or brittle papers, I want to avoid damage and pressure on any parts that stick out. Around 36% of consumers put safe handling of originals first.
Lots of loose documents Check which sheets the feeder can handle and whether duplex scanning is explicitly listed. If I have lots of sturdy, loose sheets, I want to avoid placing each one individually. Around 29% of consumers prioritise convenient feeding for suitable documents.
Printing as well as scanning Compare ink, toner and any drum based on your colour needs and expected print volume. If I print regularly as well as digitising documents, I want to factor in the running costs, not just the printer itself. Around 21% of consumers focus mainly on ongoing printing costs.
Bound or large items Measure the original and check the scanning area. A larger print size doesn’t prove that the flatbed is just as large. If I want to scan an album or a large original, I want to know whether it will fit safely and lie flat. Around 14% of consumers put the suitability of the scanning set-up for these items first.

Common pitfalls

  • Confusing automatic duplex printing with duplex scanning

    These are separate features. For example, Canon lists a single-sided automatic document feeder for the PIXMA TR7650, alongside automatic duplex printing.

    If you often digitise both sides of sheets, check the exact model specifications for duplex scanning via the document feeder.

    If duplex scanning isn’t available, you may need to turn the sheets over yourself.

  • Putting old photos or brittle paper through the document feeder

    The National Archives and Records Administration warns that weak, curled, fragile or valuable paper can jam or tear in an automatic feeder.

    Assess each original individually and use only a suitable flatbed scanning method or another safe set-up.

  • Comparing only the purchase price

    Printing also involves the cost of compatible ink or toner. According to Brother, the toner and drum for the Brother DCP-L2660DW can be replaced separately.

    Compare the printer and consumables costs based on a print volume that suits the way you use it.

    With this Brother model, remember that both the toner and drum need to be replaced separately.

  • Assuming a larger print size means a larger scanning area

    A printer that can print larger sheets doesn’t automatically have a flatbed of the same size. A scanner lid could press down on an original that sticks out.

    Measure your largest original and check the stated scanning area before buying. For bound or protruding items, use a supported copying set-up if needed.

    If the original won’t fit safely on the flatbed, you may need a separate scanning set-up.

Brands to compare

Canon

Canon PIXMA models combine scanning with colour printing. For the PIXMA TR7650, Canon lists a document feeder that holds up to 20 single-sided sheets.

  • The stated feeder capacity may be useful for suitable loose sheets.
  • The automatic duplex feature is for printing; check duplex scanning separately.

Epson

Epson EcoTank models use refillable ink tanks. Epson lists a duplex document feeder for the ET-4950.

  • The ET-4950 is worth comparing if you scan and print regularly.
  • Epson’s ink yield claims are based on the manufacturer’s conditions and won’t predict your own usage. A3+ printing capability alone doesn’t prove that it can scan A3+ documents.

Brother

The Brother DCP-L2660DW is a monochrome laser all-in-one printer. Brother lists a 50-sheet document feeder.

  • According to Brother, the toner and drum can be replaced separately.
  • This model doesn’t print family photos in colour. Factor in the cost of both replaceable parts when comparing costs.

HP

According to HP, the HP Smart Tank 7005 combines colour printing, scanning and copying with refillable ink.

  • A colour model to compare if you regularly print in colour as well as scanning.
  • HP’s stated print yields for the supplied ink are manufacturer claims. Automatic duplex printing doesn’t confirm the presence of an automatic document feeder or duplex scanning.

Joybuy products

These Joybuy products are all-in-one colour printers for anyone scanning family documents who also wants to print in colour.

Canon PIXMA MG2556S inkjet printer

Canon PIXMA MG2556S inkjet printer, A4, 4800 × 600 dpi

An option to compare if you scan family documents at home and also want to print in colour.

The product name lists inkjet technology, A4 and 4800 × 600 dpi.

View at Joybuy
Brother MFC-J6760DW all-in-one inkjet printer

Brother MFC-J6760DW all-in-one inkjet printer, A3, 1200 × 4800 dpi, 31 ppm, Wi-Fi

A model to compare if you also need colour prints when digitising documents.

The product name lists inkjet technology, A3, 1200 × 4800 dpi, 31 ppm and Wi-Fi. Don’t use the automatic feeder for fragile, weak, curled or valuable originals.

View at Joybuy
HP Smart Tank 7305 Wireless All-in-One colour printer

HP Smart Tank 7305 Wireless All-in-One colour printer

An option to compare if you scan family documents and also print in colour as well as digitising them.

The product name lists wireless connectivity and duplex printing. Check the scanning features separately: duplex printing doesn’t automatically mean duplex scanning.

View at Joybuy
HP Smart Tank 7005 Wireless All-in-One colour printer

HP Smart Tank 7005 Wireless All-in-One colour printer

An option to compare if you scan flat originals and also want to print in colour.

The product name lists wireless connectivity and duplex printing. Check the scanning features separately: duplex printing doesn’t confirm that it can scan both sides.

View at Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

Can I press an old album flat under the scanner lid?

Don’t force a bound album flat. The National Archives and Records Administration recommends using a supported copying set-up for books and warns that a lid can crush or crease an oversized original.

Does scanning to PDF automatically make the text searchable?

No. PDF output and OCR are different features. Consumentenbond distinguishes OCR for searchable PDFs, so check whether OCR is available for the exact model and its accompanying software if you want to find names in your scans.

What should I do with originals and digital files after scanning?

Keep the originals and make multiple backups of your digital files. The National Archives and Records Administration also recommends recording clear information about who, what, where and when, so you can find your scans later.

Who can help me in the Netherlands if the printer turns out to be faulty?

For a consumer purchase, the seller must offer a solution and can’t simply refer you to the manufacturer. According to the Dutch Government, there is no fixed statutory warranty period in the Netherlands; what you could reasonably expect from the product is relevant.

Can I share scans that identify family members?

According to the Dutch Data Protection Authority, personal or household use is exempt from the GDPR, for example when sharing within a very small family circle. This exemption doesn’t necessarily apply to wider or public sharing, so assess that use separately.