People scanning bound journals
You want to digitise pages from a bound journal without feeding them through a document feeder. So check the flatbed, the scannable area and the space needed to open the lid.
For bound travel journals, a flatbed scanner is essential. Canon Netherlands and Brother Netherlands describe the automatic document feeders on the models mentioned as being for loose sheets, not for automatically feeding books. Also measure the space needed to open the lid and lay the journal flat. Only factor in an ADF and your choice of ink system if you also scan loose documents or print regularly.
You want to digitise pages from a bound journal without feeding them through a document feeder. So check the flatbed, the scannable area and the space needed to open the lid.
You want one device for printing and scanning, while still leaving room to lay out your journal and operate the printer.
As well as your journal, you handle loose sheets or regularly print photos and documents. In that case, feeder features and ink costs may also matter.
Start by considering how you’ll scan bound pages, then work out how much desk space, convenient paper feeding and printing capacity matter to you.
| What to consider | What should you check? | Who is this most relevant to? |
|---|---|---|
| Scanning bound pages | Check that the flatbed and scannable area are suitable, and that you can lay the journal down without forcing its spine. | I mainly want to digitise journal pages without feeding the book through a feeder; around 36% of consumers say scanning bound pages is their top priority. |
| Space around the device | Measure the available width, depth and height, including room for the lid to open and for the paper feed. | I need to leave enough room on my desk to handle the journal too; around 29% of consumers prioritise usable desk space. |
| Legibility and colour | Look at scans of similar material and check whether any software for searchable text works with the exact model and your device. | I want to be able to view or find handwriting, photos or illustrations later; around 21% of consumers prioritise scan quality and being able to find their scans again. |
| Ink for additional printing | Compare the compatible ink or refills with how often you print, and only consider a subscription if its terms suit you. | If I regularly print extra documents, I want to know what the running costs will be; around 14% of consumers put printing costs first. |
An automatic document feeder is designed for loose sheets; bound pages are scanned one at a time on a suitable flatbed. Canon Netherlands lists an ADF for up to 35 loose sheets on the PIXMA TS7750i. Brother Netherlands lists a 20-sheet feeder for the DCP-J1460DW.
First, choose how you’ll scan the book. An ADF is most useful if you also regularly handle loose documents.
A device might fit in the space available, but still get in the way when you open the lid, lay down a journal or feed in paper.
Measure the full setup while scanning and printing before choosing a specific model.
Ink and refill costs matter too. The Consumentenbond points out that with some inkjet printers, infrequent printing can lead to extra ink being used for cleaning.
Compare the ink system with your own printing habits and check any subscription terms separately.
The PIXMA range includes both straightforward all-in-ones and models with an automatic document feeder.
According to Epson, the Expression XP-4200 combines printing, copying and scanning in an A4 device that the company describes as compact.
According to Brother, the DCP-J1460DW combines printing, scanning and copying with an ADF for loose documents.
The Smart Tank 7305 is an ink-tank all-in-one worth comparing if you want to factor in print volume as well as scanning.
These printer options can help you weigh up printing and scanning on a small desk. For each model, check that its scanning features and the space available for bound pages suit the way you’ll use it.
No image available
An option to consider if you also want to handle loose travel documents as well as journal pages. The ADF is for loose sheets and won’t replace scanning a bound journal one page at a time.
The product name lists A3, Wi-Fi, 1200 x 4800 DPI and 31 ppm.
No image available
An option to consider if you want to handle both bound pages and loose travel documents. Place bound pages on the flatbed scanner one at a time and check beforehand that the journal fits on the glass.
The product name lists a wireless all-in-one colour printer with double-sided printing, copying and scanning.
No image available
An option to compare if A4 is the print size you need. To scan a bound journal, check that the flatbed and the space needed to open the lid are suitable.
The product name lists 4800 x 600 DPI.
No image available
An option if you’re looking for an A4 colour printer with Wi-Fi. Before buying, check that the exact model offers the scanning features you need and is suitable for bound pages.
The product name lists 4800 x 1200 DPI, A4 and Wi-Fi.
No image available
An ink-tank option to compare if you print as well as digitising journals. Check that the scanning features of the exact model suit your needs, and bear in mind that bound material must be scanned one page at a time.
The product name lists double-sided printing, copying and scanning.
Use an ADF for loose sheets, not to feed a bound book. For bound pages, a flatbed scanner is the right option: place each page on it individually and check that the journal and flatbed are compatible.
Measure more than just the space for the printer. Allow room to open the scanner lid, lay down the journal and feed paper in and out. Also check which connection and scanning software the model offers for your computer or phone.
Compare the cost of compatible ink or refills with how often you actually print. The Consumentenbond points out that infrequent printing can mean extra ink is used for cleaning on some inkjet printers, so look beyond the stated cartridge yield.
That depends on the flatbed, the page size and how the journal lies on it. Check these details for the exact model and look at scans of similar material before choosing.
You can make a copy at home for your own use, but you mustn’t distribute or publish someone else’s copyright-protected work without permission. The Dutch Government makes this distinction; check who created any text or images pasted into the journal.