Start with the originals: a flatbed scanner is handy for crumpled receipts, while an ADF can feed loose sheets through one after another. Choose a duplex ADF if you often need to scan both sides. Then decide whether the group will mainly print black-and-white text or also print in colour regularly, and compare the consumables and how scans containing personal data will be managed. Duplex printing does not automatically mean that a printer can scan both sides.
Who is this relevant for?
Anyone scanning piles of bills
If you regularly handle several loose sheets, an ADF can feed them through one after another. For crumpled receipts and unusual originals, the Consumers’ Association recommends using the flatbed scanner instead. Also decide separately whether you need to capture the backs of documents.
Anyone managing confidential scans
If scans are shared with others, it’s important to decide who needs access and where the files will be stored. The Dutch Data Protection Authority stresses that personal data must be properly protected.
Anyone printing for the group too
If you’ll be printing documents as well as scanning them, consider how much colour you’ll use and how often you’ll print. The Consumers’ Association also recommends taking the volume and purpose of your printing into account when choosing.
What should you look for when choosing?
| What to consider |
What should you look for? |
Who is it important for? |
| Handling a stack of documents |
Check whether the exact model has both a flatbed scanner and an ADF, and which originals are suitable for feeding through the ADF. |
If I have lots of ordinary loose sheets to process one after another, I don’t want to place them on the flatbed one at a time. Around 33% of consumers say handling a stack is their main requirement. |
| Access to scans |
Decide where files will be stored, who needs them and who will be given access. |
If bills contain personal data, I want only authorised group members to be able to view the scans. Around 27% of consumers prioritise access management. |
| Duplex scanning |
Check the exact model for a duplex ADF or an explicit mention of duplex scanning. |
If important information is often printed on both sides, I want to capture it without having to turn the sheets over each time. Around 20% of consumers prioritise duplex scans. |
| Printing and maintenance costs |
Estimate black-and-white and colour use separately, then compare compatible ink, toner, maintenance parts and any subscription terms. |
If I’m printing group documents as well as bills, I want to factor in the cost of that use rather than looking only at the printer itself. Around 20% of consumers say the cost of additional printing is the main factor in their choice. |
Common pitfalls
-
Confusing ‘duplex’ printing with duplex scanning
Automatic duplex printing and automatic duplex scanning are different features. If you need both sides of bills, the lack of a scanning feature could mean you have to turn over and sort the originals yourself.
Check the exact model’s specifications for a duplex ADF or explicit support for duplex scanning.
Turning over and sorting double-sided originals by hand takes extra time.
-
Trying to feed every bill through the ADF
An ADF is designed for suitable loose sheets; crumpled receipts and unusual originals may need to be handled differently.
Include a flatbed scanner in your comparison and use the ADF only for originals it can handle.
-
Looking only at the purchase price
Printing costs also depend on how much you expect to print and the consumables you’ll need. The Consumers’ Association notes that inkjet printers used infrequently can use ink for cleaning.
For the exact model, compare the compatible ink or toner, any maintenance parts and subscription terms, based on your expected black-and-white and colour use.
Allow for replacing consumables and, depending on the model, parts such as a drum or maintenance cartridge.
-
Assuming scans are shared securely or stored for long enough
Scanning does not automatically control who can access personal data, nor does it mean you can automatically throw away the paper original.
Agree who needs access and where scans will be stored. Check any tax record-keeping requirements separately, and only if they apply to the accounts in question.
Brands worth considering
Brother
The DCP-L2660DW is an example of a multifunction mono laser printer with a document feeder.
- Brother lists a 50-sheet ADF and automatic duplex printing for this model.
- The toner and drum can be replaced separately.
- This model does not print in colour. Automatic duplex printing does not confirm duplex scanning.
Epson
The EcoTank ET-4950 is an example of an ink tank printer for groups that also print in colour.
- Epson lists duplex printing, copying and scanning with a duplex ADF for this model.
- Assess an ink tank printer based on your expected printing volume and the cost of refills. Manufacturer claims about savings and page yields apply under the corresponding test conditions.
Canon
The MAXIFY GX4050 is an example of a refillable colour printer with an ADF for shared printing and scanning.
- Canon lists a 35-sheet A4 ADF and a user-replaceable maintenance cartridge.
- The stated ADF scan speed is for single-sided scanning. Don’t assume it can scan both sides automatically.
HP
The OfficeJet Pro 9120e is an example of a cartridge inkjet printer for which HP lists an ADF and duplex scanning.
- The features listed by HP may be useful if you want to print in colour and scan both sides.
- HP lists dynamic security that blocks certain cartridges without an HP chip. Before buying, check the terms for the exact model and the cartridges you plan to use.
Printers available at Joybuy
This selection includes all-in-one cartridge and ink tank printers for scanning bills and, where needed, additional printing. The models differ in their document feeders and how they scan originals.
No image available
Canon PIXMA MG2556S
An option if you want to scan bills and also use the printer for colour printing.
Listed features include colour printing, scanning and copying, with a USB 2.0 connection to a computer.
The product name lists A4 and 4800 x 600 DPI.
View at Joybuy
No image available
HP Smart Tank 7305
An option if you scan stacks of loose sheets and also print in colour for the group.
The specifications list a 35-sheet ADF, colour printing, refillable ink bottles and wireless connectivity.
Duplex printing is listed, but the specifications state that duplex scanning is not available.
View at Joybuy
No image available
HP Smart Tank 7005
An option for individual bills that you can place on the flatbed one at a time, with additional colour printing.
The specifications list a flatbed scanner, colour printing and an ink bottle refill system.
No ADF or duplex scanning is listed, so bear this in mind if you need to process stacks or capture both sides.
View at Joybuy
Frequently asked questions
Should I feed crumpled receipts through the document feeder?
No. For crumpled receipts, the Consumers’ Association recommends using the flatbed scanner instead. Use an ADF mainly for several loose sheets that are suitable for it.
Does automatic duplex printing also mean duplex scanning?
No. Check the scanning feature separately for the exact model. Epson lists a duplex ADF for the ET-4950; duplex printing alone does not prove that it can scan both sides.
What should the neighbourhood group arrange before several volunteers use the scans?
If scans contain personal data, the organisation must put appropriate security measures in place. Decide who needs access and review how the scans will be stored and shared; the Dutch Data Protection Authority explains that security measures should be tailored to the situation.
How should I account for maintenance and refills?
Compare the compatible ink or toner and any separate parts for the exact model. Brother lists a separately replaceable drum for the DCP-L2660DW, while Canon lists a replaceable maintenance cartridge for the GX4050. An inkjet printer may also use ink for cleaning if it is used infrequently.
Can I throw away all the paper bills after scanning them?
Not until you’ve established whose records they are and which rules apply. For invoices covered by the tax records described by the Dutch Tax and Customs Administration, digital storage after scanning is allowed only if the scan is an accurate and complete copy and authenticity features have also been stored; the records must remain auditable. This does not automatically apply to every household bill that a neighbourhood group helps to scan.