Making a quick lesson demo
You want to save an acoustic performance as a mixed recording straight away, and adjust levels easily while playing. Yamaha specifies four mono mic/line inputs and 2-in/2-out USB for the MG10XU.
Choose based on what you want to do with the recording after the lesson. If you need a stereo mix that’s ready to use, a mixer with 2-in/2-out USB may be enough. For separate post-production, you’ll need enough USB recording channels to record all your sources at once. If you need to record without a computer connected, look for a model that records directly to an SD card. Also check the number of microphone inputs and which features are available at the same time in your chosen mode.
You want to save an acoustic performance as a mixed recording straight away, and adjust levels easily while playing. Yamaha specifies four mono mic/line inputs and 2-in/2-out USB for the MG10XU.
You’re recording several voices or instruments at once and want to be able to adjust their levels separately afterwards. Allen & Heath, Zoom and Behringer’s specifications describe models with multiple USB recording channels.
You want to capture a demo in different classrooms without relying on a computer being connected during recording. Zoom documents SD card multitrack recording on the LiveTrak L-8.
A good fit if: you can set the balance while performing and don’t need to adjust every microphone separately afterwards.
Trade-off: the number of physical inputs isn’t the same as the number of separate USB tracks; the Yamaha MG10XU has 2-in/2-out USB.
A good fit if: you want to adjust vocals and instruments separately after the lesson. The Allen & Heath ZEDi-10 has 4-in/4-out USB, while the Behringer FLOW 8 can send ten channels to a computer, according to Behringer.
Trade-off: decide in advance which sources need to be recorded at the same time, and check the channel routing and computer compatibility.
A good fit if: you want to record without a laptop; Zoom documents SD card multitrack recording on the LiveTrak L-8.
Trade-off: check the power supply and which features are available in your chosen recording mode. At 96 kHz, features including EQ, effects and the audio interface are unavailable, according to Zoom.
| Priority | What should you check? | Which consumers does this matter to? |
|---|---|---|
| Ready-to-use mix | Count the microphone inputs you need and check how many USB inputs record separately. | If you want to set the balance while playing and save one finished demo, this is your main priority; around 31% of consumers prioritise a mixed recording that’s ready to use. |
| Separate source tracks | Compare the number of USB recording inputs available at once with the number of sources; don’t assume mixer channels are separate tracks. | If you want to adjust vocals and instruments separately after the lesson, having enough individual recording channels is essential; around 31% of consumers prioritise separate source tracks. |
| Recording without a computer | Check whether the model records directly to an SD card and which features are available at the same time. | If you don’t want to rely on a connected computer in the classroom, standalone recording is an important requirement; around 23% of consumers prioritise this. |
| Connections and controls | Make a list of your sources and check the mic/line inputs, any Hi-Z inputs, phantom power and monitoring options for each model. | If you have a specific combination of microphones and instruments, or several people need to monitor the recording, check that the connections and controls meet your needs; around 15% of consumers prioritise this flexibility. |
The Yamaha MG10XU has four mono mic/line inputs, but 2-in/2-out USB, according to Yamaha. The Allen & Heath ZEDi-10 specifies 4-in/4-out USB.
Write down how many sources you want to save separately, then compare that number with the USB recording inputs on the exact model you’re considering.
If you later find that you need to edit tracks separately, you may need a different mixer or additional recording equipment.
Zoom states that features including EQ, effects and the audio interface are unavailable at 96 kHz on the LiveTrak L-8.
Check which features are available in the recording mode you actually plan to use in class.
An audio recording in which someone is identifiable may contain personal data, according to the Dutch Data Protection Authority (Autoriteit Persoonsgegevens).
Before recording and sharing, decide who can be heard, why the recording is being made, and which school policies and GDPR legal basis apply. The Dutch Data Protection Authority also explains schools’ duty to provide information.
The MG10XU is worth considering if a compact mixer with a mains adaptor and a mixed USB recording suits the way you work.
The ZEDi-10 is worth considering if you want to record four microphone sources separately via a computer.
The LiveTrak L-8 combines mixing, USB audio and standalone SD recording for a classroom without a permanent laptop setup.
The FLOW 8 is a digital option if you want to send several channels to a computer and can use app-based controls in your classroom setup.
According to Tascam, the Model 12 combines a mixer, standalone SD recorder and USB interface.
No. Yamaha specifies four mono mic/line inputs for the MG10XU, but 2-in/2-out USB. Check both figures separately.
Choose a mixer that can actually record to an SD card and check which card and recording mode you need. Make a short test recording before the lesson and listen back to it; Zoom also notes that some features are limited at 96 kHz on the Zoom LiveTrak L-8.
Check which cables, microphones, storage media and power supply you’ll need for your setup. For a consumer purchase in the Netherlands, statutory guarantees apply if a product fails to meet reasonable expectations under normal use; according to ACM ConsuWijzer, the seller is responsible for providing an appropriate solution.
An audio recording in which someone is identifiable may contain personal data. If the school processes such recordings, it must comply with GDPR requirements, including having an appropriate legal basis and informing the people concerned. Consent is one possible legal basis, but it isn’t automatically the right basis for every recording. Whether a particular recording or sharing it is permitted depends on its purpose, the people involved and the legal basis chosen.