Artist with a small desk
Mostly scans loose sketchbook pages and wants to keep some workspace free while or after scanning.
For individual sketchbook pages that fit within A4, an A4 flatbed scanner is the more space-saving choice. An A3 flatbed is worth considering if you want to capture a larger page or spread in one scan. Also measure how much space the open book takes up, and check that your book works with the scanning position you want to use: a stand for upright scanning does not prove that a thick, bound sketchbook can be scanned effectively in that position.
Mostly scans loose sketchbook pages and wants to keep some workspace free while or after scanning.
Wants to position pages close to the spine, so checks whether the chosen scanning position works with their book.
Wants to capture a page or spread larger than A4 in one scan and can make room for a larger scanner.
First, measure the part of the drawing you want to scan in one go. Then check whether both the scanner and the open book will fit in your workspace.
| What to consider | What to look for | Who is this important for? |
|---|---|---|
| Available desk space | Measure the space available and allow room for the open sketchbook. | If I want to clear my workspace again after scanning, I consider both the scanner and the book; around 36% of consumers mainly want to save space. |
| Bound pages | Check the lid and scanning position with a representative book, without forcing the binding. | Anyone wanting to capture pages close to the spine should check with their own book; around 29% of consumers put the book binding first. |
| Size in one scan | Measure the page or spread and compare it with the stated scanning area. | For anyone who does not want to scan a large drawing or spread in sections, the size of the glass matters; around 21% of consumers prioritise capturing one large area in a single scan. |
| Details and colours | Compare the optical resolution of each model and, if possible, assess a test scan of your own paper and drawing materials. | If lines and subtle colour differences matter, I want to assess the results using my own work; around 14% of consumers prioritise detail. |
The maximum scanning size determines whether the part you want to capture will fit on the glass in one scan.
Measure the page or spread you want to scan and compare it with the stated A4 or A3 scanning area.
If the drawing is larger than the scanning area, capturing it in several scans may take extra time.
A manufacturer mentioning upright scanning does not confirm that a thick sketchbook can be scanned effectively in that position.
Check how your own book sits, and do not force the binding.
A stated resolution is not an independent comparison of colour reproduction or scans near the book's spine.
Compare the specifications of the exact models and, if possible, assess a test scan using your own paper and drawing materials.
The CanoScan LiDE 300 and LiDE 400 are A4 flatbed scanners for pages within their stated scanning area. Canon also lists an upright scanning option for the LiDE 400.
According to Epson, the Perfection V39II is an A4 photo and document scanner with an integrated stand for upright use.
The OpticSlim 1180 is an A3 flatbed scanner for originals that do not fit within A4.
These product choices are A4 flatbed scanners for pages that fit within A4; compare the stated model features with the dimensions of your own sketchbook.
No image available
An A4 flatbed option for pages that fit within A4; check the scanning area of the part you want to capture in one scan.
The product name specifies A4, flatbed and ADF (automatic document feeder), with a stated resolution of 600 × 600 dpi.
No image available
An A4 flatbed option for pages that fit within A4; measure beforehand to check whether the part you want will fit on the glass in a single scan.
The product name specifies A4 and a stated resolution of 1200 × 1200 dpi.
Only if capturing it in one scan is important for your work. Measure the spread: Canon states a maximum of 216 × 297 mm for the CanoScan LiDE 400, while Plustek Europe states a maximum of 297 × 431,8 mm for the OpticSlim 1180. A larger original will not fit entirely within the relevant scanning area.
The presence of a stand does not automatically mean it will. Epson describes upright scanning for the Perfection V39II, and Canon lists an upright scanning option for the LiDE 400. Check how your own book sits, and do not force the binding.
Not on its own: resolution figures are not an independent test of colour reproduction or scanning results near the book's spine. Canon states an optical resolution of 2400 × 2400 dpi for the LiDE 300 and 4800 × 4800 dpi for the LiDE 400. Where possible, assess a test scan of your own paper and drawing materials.
Check which connection, power supply and software will work with your computer, and measure the space needed for the open sketchbook too. Canon states that the LiDE 400 is USB-powered, and Epson lists USB for the Perfection V39II; Plustek specifies a separate mains power supply for the OpticSlim 1180. Consult the manual for the exact model for setup and use with a bound book.