Editing volunteer working with mixed sources
You combine historical photos, interviews, titles and new footage, and want to check details while keeping your editing timeline easy to navigate. (RTINGS.com and LG.)
For a neighbourhood history film, start with a monitor that has a native resolution of 3840 × 2160. Then choose one based on how much room you need for your footage and timeline, and whether you need SDR colour management, laptop charging or calibration. Adobe describes Direct Rec.709 as an SDR setting; a Rec.709 mode or USB-C connection alone won’t take care of your entire colour workflow or guarantee laptop compatibility. Rights to use photos and films are a separate matter from choosing a monitor.
You combine historical photos, interviews, titles and new footage, and want to check details while keeping your editing timeline easy to navigate. (RTINGS.com and LG.)
You’re delivering several versions or correcting footage from a range of sources, and want a suitable SDR colour mode, possibly with a repeatable calibration workflow. (Adobe, ASUS, BenQ and EIZO.)
You edit on a laptop and want to check whether a single connection can handle the display and peripherals while also supplying enough power. (LG, ASUS and BenQ.)
For a film combining photos, interviews and new footage, the right monitor depends on what you most want to check and connect while editing.
| What to consider | What to look for when buying | Who will value this most? |
|---|---|---|
| Detail and workspace | Check the native resolution, screen size, scaling settings and stand adjustability. | If I want to review source footage and the timeline at the same time, having a clear overview while editing matters most to me; around 33% of consumers rank this need as their top priority. |
| Consistent colour | Check whether there’s a Rec.709 mode and whether you want to calibrate the monitor using measuring equipment. | If I’m reviewing a range of scans and recordings in SDR, I want to match my display to the intended output; around 25% of consumers put consistent colour first. |
| Laptop connection | Compare your laptop’s video output, the monitor port, the cable and the power required. | If I’m editing on a laptop, I want to know whether it can send video through the monitor and receive enough power; around 25% of consumers make connectivity and power their top priority. |
| Total cost | Include any measuring equipment and energy consumption shown on the EU energy label in your comparison. | If I’m working to a project budget, I also want to account for any calibration tools and running costs; around 17% of consumers put total cost first. |
HDR support doesn’t automatically determine which colour space or settings are right for your editing and intended output.
First decide whether you’re working in SDR/Rec.709 or using a different output. Then match your editing software and monitor settings to it.
The models reviewed list different maximum power outputs. A USB-C port also doesn’t guarantee that your laptop can output video through that connection.
Check your laptop’s video output, the monitor port, the cable and the power required. You may still need a separate laptop charger or a suitable cable.
The origin of photos and films and the privacy of identifiable people are separate issues; a monitor won’t resolve them.
Record the source and usage rights for every item, and consider the presence of identifiable people before publishing more widely.
Checking rights and arranging permission can take extra time.
The LG 27UP850K-W is a 27-inch 4K IPS monitor with an adjustable stand and USB-C power delivery.
According to ASUS, the ProArt PA279CRV combines a 27-inch 4K panel with a Rec.709 preset and USB-C power delivery.
The DesignVue PD2725U is worth considering if an explicit Rec.709 mode and a Thunderbolt connection are important to you.
The ColorEdge CS2740 is designed for a repeatable, colour-managed 4K workflow.
The UltraSharp U2723QE is a 27-inch 4K IPS Black monitor with USB-C hub connections.
These Joybuy products are 4K monitors for viewing footage and your editing timeline. Check each model’s connections, colour workflow and screen size to see how well it suits your workspace.
No image available
Could suit you if you’re looking for a 27-inch screen for reviewing 4K footage while editing.
The product description lists a resolution of 3840 × 2160 pixels and an IPS panel.
The description also mentions 60 Hz, 5 ms and HDR10; an HDR label is no substitute for a suitable colour management process.
No image available
Could suit you if you’re considering a larger screen for 4K source footage and your editing timeline.
The product description lists a resolution of 3840 × 2160 pixels and a 31.5-inch screen size.
The product description mentions an integrated colour meter and automatic calibration; check that this workflow suits your editing and whether you want to use the necessary measuring and management features.
No image available
Could suit you if you’re considering a 32-inch curved screen for viewing 4K source footage.
The product description lists a VA panel, a resolution of 3840 × 2160 pixels and 100% sRGB.
The stated sRGB coverage alone doesn’t tell you how accurately an individual unit displays colour.
No image available
Could suit you if you’re looking for a 27-inch 4K screen with an adjustable stand for your editing workspace.
The product description lists a resolution of 3840 × 2160 pixels, an IPS panel and a height-adjustable stand.
The description also mentions 60 Hz, 4 ms, HDMI and DisplayPort.
No image available
Could suit you if you want to view footage and your editing timeline on a 27-inch screen and connect your laptop via USB-C.
The product description lists a resolution of 3840 × 2160 pixels and USB-C with DP Alt Mode.
The description states that USB-C delivers up to 98 W of power; check that the connection and power output are compatible with your laptop.
Not necessarily. First decide on the intended output colour space: Adobe describes Direct Rec.709 as an SDR setting, with separate workflows for material with a wider colour gamut. An HDR label alone doesn’t determine how you edit or assess the film.
Match your editing and monitor colour settings to the intended output. If you regularly work with colour-critical material, a monitor with hardware calibration can be part of a workflow using suitable measuring equipment; EIZO describes this option for the ColorEdge CS2740. A stated calibration feature doesn’t replace the right settings and working practices.
Include any calibration equipment and energy consumption shown on the EU energy label in your comparison. According to the Dutch Government, consumers buying in the Netherlands are legally entitled to a product that is fit for purpose. There’s no fixed statutory warranty period in the Netherlands, and the seller is your point of contact if there’s a problem.
Not simply because you found the material locally. According to the Dutch Government, you may generally only use copyright-protected photos and films with the creator’s permission. Check the rights and any licence for each source before distributing or publishing the material.
The Dutch Data Protection Authority explains that identifiable people in photos and films are considered personal data. Before publishing more widely, assess which GDPR legal basis applies to the specific use; consent is one possible basis, but it isn’t automatically the answer for every recording.