Who is this choice for?

Choir archive manager

Wants to restore original takes if something goes wrong and understands that drive mirroring is no substitute for a full backup. The National Cyber Security Centre and QNAP both stress the importance of keeping a separate backup.

Archive manager with growing folders

Regularly adds large session folders and wants to plan usable capacity and future expansion in advance. Model information from Synology and ASUSTOR can help you compare enclosures with different numbers of drive bays.

Creator who shares recordings

Moves large files and gives others access, so it’s worth checking the network path and access permissions for shared folders. Synology and QNAP describe models with 2.5GbE ports.

What to consider when choosing

Two drive bays

Choose this option: if you can estimate the storage space you need with reasonable accuracy and centralised archiving matters more to you than extra room for internal expansion.

Bear in mind: once both drive bays are occupied, further growth may mean replacing drives or choosing another storage solution.

Four drive bays

Choose this option: if you keep adding large new sessions and want room to expand internally.

Bear in mind: compare the total cost of the enclosure, drives and a separate backup. Also check which drives and storage configurations are compatible with the model.

Consideration What should you check? Who is this important for?
Restorable storage Choose a separate backup destination and plan a restore test; drive mirroring is no substitute for a full backup. If I want to restore original takes after something goes wrong, I need a separate copy alongside the NAS and a restore test; around 33% of consumers prioritise the ability to restore data.
Capacity and growth Add up your existing folders and expected growth, then compare the total with the usable space available in your intended drive configuration. If large session folders are added regularly, I want to avoid the archive filling up quickly; around 27% of consumers prioritise capacity and growth.
Transferring large folders Check the network ports on your NAS, computer and switch. Synology and QNAP list 2.5GbE for certain models, but every part of the connection must support that speed. When I often move large folders, I want to know whether my network supports the transfer path; around 20% of consumers prioritise transfer times.
Access and purchase costs Check which drives are included with the model and set appropriate permissions for shared folders. If several people share or manage files, I want to understand access and included components in advance; around 20% of consumers prioritise manageable access and costs.

Common buying mistakes

  • Assuming a RAID setup is a complete backup

    Depending on the configuration, a RAID setup can help maintain availability if a drive fails, but it doesn’t protect against every type of data loss. The National Cyber Security Centre recommends keeping a separate backup; QNAP also stresses that RAID is not a backup.

    Set up a separate copy before you start using the NAS, then test that you can restore a project folder.

  • Counting raw drive capacity as usable archive space

    Usable space depends on the drives and the storage configuration you choose. It won’t necessarily match the total capacity printed on the drive labels.

    Plan around your existing folders, expected growth and the usable capacity of the specific configuration.

    You may need larger or additional drives to achieve the usable space you want.

  • Choosing a drive based only on its brand or NAS label

    Compatibility can depend on the exact NAS model and software version. The drive technology may also matter for the storage configuration you choose.

    Check the exact drive model with the NAS manufacturer and find out whether your chosen configuration requires a particular type of drive.

    A drive that isn’t suitable for your chosen configuration may need to be replaced.

NAS brands for reference

The features below apply to the models listed. Check the exact version and drive compatibility for your own setup.

Synology

Synology describes the DS225+ as a two-bay model and the DS925+ as a four-bay model; the brand lists 2.5GbE for both.

  • According to Synology, DSM 7.3 offers more flexibility for third-party HDDs on 2025 Plus models.
  • Check compatibility with the exact drive and software version; quoted transfer speeds are based on manufacturer tests.

QNAP

According to QNAP, the TS-264 is a two-bay model for file management and backup.

  • QNAP lists two 2.5GbE ports for the TS-264.
  • Drives are sold separately. The advertised speed for port trunking doesn’t guarantee the speed of a single file transfer or the performance of your own network.

ASUSTOR

According to ASUSTOR, the Drivestor 4 Pro Gen2 AS3304T v2 combines four drive bays with 2.5GbE and Btrfs snapshots.

  • Snapshots can be part of this model’s storage features.
  • Published transfer figures are laboratory results; snapshots are no substitute for a separate backup.

TerraMaster

TerraMaster lists the F4-424 as a four-bay enclosure with two 2.5GbE ports and two M.2 slots.

  • The listed ports and slots give you specific features to compare with your intended setup.
  • A quoted transfer speed tested with RAID 0, among other configurations, doesn’t show how a redundant archive setup will perform.

NAS enclosures at Joybuy

These NAS enclosures are designed for central storage of large choir project folders. Compare the drive bays, expansion options, included drives and separate backup plan for each version.

Synology DiskStation DS1525+ NAS enclosure

Synology DiskStation DS1525+

A good fit for a choir archive that needs centralised shared project folders and room to plan for growth.

Hard drives are not included, so remember to budget for a separate backup destination too.

View at Joybuy
Synology DiskStation DS1825+ NAS enclosure

Synology DiskStation DS1825+

An option to compare if centralised storage, shared access and growing project folders matter to you.

Before you buy, check the drive configuration, compatibility and whether this version includes drives.

View at Joybuy
Synology DiskStation DS925+ without hard drives

Synology DiskStation DS925+ without hard drives

A good fit if you’re considering the DS925+ for a growing archive and want to choose the drive configuration yourself.

This version doesn’t include hard drives, so remember to plan for the drives and a separate backup destination.

View at Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

Is RAID enough to protect original choir recordings?

No. RAID is no substitute for a separate backup. Protection against drive failure depends on the configuration; keep a separate copy as well, and test that you can restore a project folder.

Can I use any NAS drive in a 2025 Synology Plus model?

Don’t assume so: check compatibility with the exact model, drive and software version. Synology says DSM 7.3 offers more flexibility for third-party HDDs in 2025 Plus models, but that doesn’t mean every drive will suit every configuration.

What should I budget for in addition to the NAS enclosure?

Check whether your chosen version includes hard drives, and factor a separate backup destination into your plan. The drives you need will depend on the usable space and storage configuration you choose for your archive.

Could the GDPR be relevant to a choir archive?

It could be if recordings or project information relate to identifiable people. The European Commission defines personal data as information about an identified or identifiable living person; consider the purpose, access and retention period for the specific files.